Menu

Best Mattress Under $2,000

Updated August 16, 2019

Celebrities are always getting things for free, or at deep discounts, so it’s no wonder that they always have money. Of course, they’re getting fat paychecks, too, but you must know what you should be frugal about and what you should splurge on.

Your mattress is one of those areas that sort of falls in between. You definitely want to spend enough money on it that you’re getting the best mattress possible, but you also don’t want to just throw money away on something that doesn’t deserve all your hard-earned cash. There are plenty of mattresses out there that cost less than $2,000 but feel like they cost three times that.

Why Not Buy the Least Expensive Mattress?

Waiting for a sale makes sense. You want to get the best bang for your buck, but you want to be picky about your mattress. Sleep is an important part of feeling well throughout your day, and when you get good restorative sleep, it’s how your body repairs itself when you’re ill or even just recovering from a hard workout at the gym. Bottom line: Don’t skimp on your mattress.

As you sift through your morning paper, you might notice ads for mattresses that only cost $150 or some ridiculously low price like that. It’s tempting to go out and purchase a new mattress at a fraction of what a well-built mattress costs, but you’ll regret it.

Most of those value mattresses are inexpensive because they’re the old-fashioned innerspring coil mattresses. They’re usually made with a low count of coils, inferior materials, and they come with short warranties. You might sleep well on it for the first week, but you’re sure to start feeling aches and pains shortly thereafter.

Additionally, you could be buying a mattress from a company that doesn’t stand behind its products. That’s why you want a mattress with a long warranty that protects your purchase. You should always read through the warranty when you make a big purchase like this, so you know what to expect, in case you need to make a claim. A $100 queen-sized mattress isn’t going to be long-lasting or be comfortable.

Well Then, Why Not Buy the Priciest Mattress?

So, then you might think that buying the most expensive mattress on the market would make sense. After all, if the least expensive one means subpar quality and throwaway warranties, the priciest is going to be the opposite, right? Not necessarily. Yes, the more a mattress costs, the higher the quality of the materials and likely the support. However, some mattresses are overpriced. There’s this magical sweet spot in the price where you can buy the best mattress for you, whether you sleep on your back, side, or face down on your stomach.

The range between $1,000 and $2,000 seems to have some of the best mattresses. And it isn’t just memory foam that resides in this range. So, even if you don’t like memory foam – and some people don’t – that’s OK. There are latex foam, hybrids, and innerspring coil mattresses that fall into this category, and they’re all awesome.

Tips for Choosing the Best Mattress for the Right Price

High-quality mattresses can come in a variety of materials and styles. The right one for you starts with how you prefer your mattress to feel, your sleep position, and even your weight.

Innerspring

You probably grew up with one of these less expensive mattresses. They’re made with springs or coils, and they can be ideal for those who weigh a little more because they’re comfortable and quite supportive. Look for one with pocketed coils for the longest lasting innerspring mattress.

Memory Foam

Many sleepers love how comfortable memory foam can be, but it’s also notorious for trapping heat. The good news is that the higher-end memory foam mattresses include features like open-cell foam or gel-infused foam, which can keep you cooler. It’s an important feature for hot sleepers. Not everyone likes the hugging sensation from memory foam, though – it can make some people feel stuck in bed.

Latex

If you miss the bounce of an innerspring mattress, but you like the comfort of a memory foam mattress, latex may be your happy medium. You won’t sink into this type of mattress like a memory foam one, and it’s a little firmer. It also offers a little bounce, and it doesn’t sleep hot. These are typically a bit more expensive, though.

Hybrid

A hybrid mattress is exactly what it sounds like: a mattress comprised of various materials. You can find one that mixes latex with innerspring coils, memory foam with pocketed coils, or different types of foam to make a mattress that combines all the features you want.

The position you sleep in at night can help determine which mattress would be best for you. Adaptive foam, like memory foam or latex, is best for those who sleep on their sides or back because the foam responds to your weight and body heat and relieves pressure points. If you sleep on your stomach, an innerspring or hybrid may be a better choice, as foam mattresses can make some people feel as though they’re suffocating in their bed.

When you need the best mattress under $2,000, the best thing to do is turn to reviews. This is where you’ll be able to browse through the pros and cons, and you’ll see how others felt about the mattress. It’s a great way to determine which mattress is going to help you rest at night and prepare you for the next day – for years to come.

Top 5 Mattresses Under $2,000 Reviews

#1. Avocado Mattress

SPECS

  • Type: Hybrid
  • Materials: Latex, coils, wool
  • Firmness level: Firm to medium-firm
  • Dimensions: 60x80x13 in. (Queen)
  • Weight: 132 lbs. (Queen)
  • Trial period: 100 days
  • Warranty: 25 years

A hybrid mattress like the Avocado mattress can offer you the best of both worlds. This one is made from latex and includes a three-zone pocketed coil system, so you get soft comfort combined with firm support. That makes this a good choice for heavier people who find memory foam not supportive enough and innerspring coil mattresses not comfortable enough. You have the option of adding a pillow top that includes an extra comfy layer of latex. It might be a good idea to do this if you’re lighter weight, as this bed could be too firm for you.

The materials of this mattress are all-natural, which makes it an eco-conscious choice. Because of those natural products, including the wool cover, it means there’s no off-gassing that’s common with foam products. Other benefits of a wool cover are that it wicks moisture away, so you get a cooler night of sleep, and it’s a natural flame retardant as well. The latex and spring system gives this bed more bounce than foam mattresses, and because of those coils, you get good edge support.

As comfortable as this bed is, you might feel one of the buttons on the cover and it could be uncomfortable enough to rouse you from sleep. Other than that, you get 100 days to try this bed out to make sure you love it. The 25-year warranty is generous, and for the first 10 years, it’s a full-replacement warranty. After that, it’s a prorated warranty.

Pros

  • Offers plenty of support, comfort
  • Eco-conscious purchase
  • Good bounce
  • Little motion transfer
  • Includes handles on sides

Cons

  • Buttons on cover may be uncomfortable
  • May be too firm

If you’re looking for a good balance of comfort and support, this could be a good choice for you – especially if you’re a little heavier.

Read our full review here.

#2. Loom and Leaf Mattress

SPECS

  • Type: Memory foam
  • Materials: Memory foam, cotton
  • Firmness level: Medium to soft-medium
  • Dimensions: 60x80x13 in. (Queen)
  • Weight: 85 lbs. (Queen)
  • Trial period: 120 days
  • Warranty: 15 years

Memory foam mattresses don’t have to feel like quicksand, at least not in the case of the Loom and Leaf mattress. Although its most popular mattress is its “Relaxed Firm” one, it leans to the soft-medium side of firmness, but you don’t sink into the mattress the way you might expect. Of course, this depends on your weight. If you’re a little heavier, or you simply prefer a firmer mattress, you could consider the company’s firm option. You only get those two options for this mattress, though.

Between the high-density foam core at the base of the mattress and the contouring memory foam, you can expect plenty of support from this mattress. There’s also a layer of convoluted memory foam, which aids in the dissipation of heat to prevent the mattress from trapping too much heat. Additionally, Loom and Leaf includes a cooling gel in the top layer near as a strip toward the middle of the bed to provide a cooler feel to the mattress and keep you cool as you sleep.

This mattress is a memory foam, so you can expect the motion isolation that the material is known for. However, Loom and Leaf doesn’t perform exactly the same way as other memory foam mattresses. Yes, it offers pressure point relief, and it’s comfortable, but it doesn’t have that hugging feeling that is common with memory foam. That translates to better edge support, and you can sleep on your stomach on this mattress without feeling suffocated. If you’re on the heavier side, though, it may be too soft and not supportive enough for you.

Pros

  • Breathable
  • Durable
  • Motion isolating
  • Sleeps on the cool side
  • Two firmness options
  • Good for any sleep position

Cons

  • May be too soft

This is a memory foam that might work well for someone who thinks they don’t like memory foam – there’s no sinking-in feeling, and it doesn’t sleep hot.

Read our full review here.

#3. Spindle Mattress

SPECS

  • Type: Latex
  • Materials: Latex, cotton
  • Firmness level: Medium to soft-medium
  • Dimensions: 60x80x9.5 in. (Queen)
  • Weight: 150 lbs. (Queen)
  • Trial period: N/A
  • Warranty: 10 years

Sleepers, who are looking for the comfort and pressure-point relief of memory foam but the bounce and loftiness of a traditional innerspring mattress, should look into latex mattresses like the Spindle mattress. There are several benefits to choosing a latex mattress, including the lack of off-gassing. Many memory foam mattresses have that “new” smell that can be offensive to some people. You aren’t likely to experience any offensive odor from the Spindle mattress.

Latex mattresses are known for providing decent support and superior comfort. The Spindle mattress comes in a variety of firmness levels, but generally, they fall into the medium level of firmness. In fact, you answer a few questions on its website to get the right firmness for your body and style of sleep. It’s important to note that Spindle doesn’t have an option for overweight sleepers that are over 31 BMI because you wouldn’t receive the proper amount of support.

What’s uncommon about this mattress is that you must assemble it. It’s shipped to you in several boxes and then you put the layers one on top of the other, and then slide the cover over it. Latex foam is sticky, and this can be a frustrating process if you’re doing it alone.

The good news is that the company will work with you to help you get the right comfort level for the first year you own the mattress. It isn’t free, though. You’re required to pay for each additional layer that you need. Also, you can’t return your Spindle mattress if you don’t like it. If you want to donate your mattress, though, you can do that and send proof of donation to a charity to Spindle, you can get a partial return. The warranty on this mattress is surprisingly short at only 10 years.

Pros

  • Choice of firmness
  • Option to change comfort level
  • Motion isolating
  • Sleeps on the cool side
  • Two firmness options
  • Good for any sleep position

Cons

  • Requires assembly
  • Not suitable for overweight sleepers
  • Return restrictions

If you’re set on having a latex mattress that gives you the option of choosing your firmness level, the Spindle could be a good option for you.

Read our full review here.

#4. Nest Alexander Signature Select

SPECS

  • Type: Memory foam
  • Materials: Gel memory foam, cotton
  • Firmness level: Soft to Firm
  • Dimensions: 60x80x14 in. (Queen)
  • Weight: ~120 lbs. (Queen)
  • Trial period: 100 days
  • Warranty: 20 years

There are plenty of reasons you might want to buy the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Select, but perhaps the biggest benefit is that you choose your comfort and firmness level. Nest Bedding doesn’t claim to have the one mattress to rule them all, and the company understands that everyone responds better or worse to different firmness levels. With that in mind, you get to choose between soft, medium, firm, and various levels in between those. It seems that this memory foam mattress comes in a little firmer than what it’s labeled, so a medium firmness may be too firm for you.

Another plus about this memory foam mattress is that it has little to no off-gassing, which means you can sleep on it the first night without any harsh fumes choking you. The bed has good support all around, including the edge. It’s still a memory foam, though, so it may be a little flimsy, but you aren’t likely to just slide off when you sit on the edge.

The top layer has a plush feeling to it, but support layers underneath kick in to help relieve pressure points. If you find that your bed is too firm or too soft, you can call Nest Bedding, and the support team will work with you to get the right mattress for you – at no added cost. You have 100 days to try out the bed, but before you call to switch out, Nest Bedding asks that you try it out for 30 days, as it has a bit of a break-in period. The 20-year warranty is a decent length, and it protects you from buying a defective unit.

Pros

  • Little to no off-gassing
  • Supportive
  • Comfortable
  • Option to change firmness
  • Decent edge support

Cons

  • May be too firm

This memory foam mattress could be a good fit for you if you want to choose how plush or firm your mattress is, and you’ll able to tweak it if it doesn’t work for you in the first 100 days.

Read our full review here.

#5. My Green Mattress

SPECS

  • Type: Hybrid
  • Materials: Latex, cotton, coils, wool
  • Firmness level: Medium-firm
  • Dimensions: 59x79x11 in. (Queen)
  • Weight: ~120 lbs. (Queen)
  • Trial period: 100 days
  • Warranty: 10 years

Latex mattresses are known for offering more support than memory foam mattresses, but often they’re not as comfortable for some sleepers. My Green Mattress, though, is a hybrid of latex and pocketed coils, which means you get support and comfort. The layers of latex are different densities, which means you get a little extra support in the areas you probably need, such as the lumbar section. This also means you might find that this mattress, which is about a medium-firm level of firmness, is too firm for you.

If you happen to be overweight, then you know how hard it can be to find a mattress that’s both supportive and comfortable. My Green Mattress could be a good solution because it is a bit firmer, but the latex is still cushy and comfy. You get that good bounce and bounce-back that’s associated with innerspring coil mattresses as well as the conforming comfort of foam mattresses. Also, there’s good edge support on this mattress, so you won’t feel as though you could fall off if you sleep near the edge.

My Green Mattress makes all its mattresses with all-natural materials, which means there’s no off-gassing. So, as soon as you set up your mattress and it inflates to its proper height, you can sleep on it immediately. Latex is known for dissipating heat well, so you should be able to sleep comfortably without getting too warm. Like many mattresses you buy online, this one comes with a 100-night trial, so you can be sure it’s to your liking. The warranty is only 10 years long, but if you do return it, My Green Mattress will donate it to a charity.

Pros

  • No off-gassing
  • Universally comfortable
  • Good bounce
  • Good edge support
  • Supportive for all sleepers
  • Sleeps cool

Cons

  • May be too firm

If you want a hybrid mattress with a universally comfortable feel and the support that you need, this could be the one for you.

Read our full review here.

Conclusion

All the mattresses reviewed here are sure to be excellent choices for sleepers who want to make sure they’re spending the right amount of money on a mattress. None of them are exorbitant in price, but they’re also not so inexpensive that you wonder how they’re able to offer a good mattress at that price point. They all include good warranties and options, so you get the right mattress for a good night’s sleep. One stands out for being the best for almost any sleeper, though, with only a couple drawbacks.

The Avocado Mattress gives you the comfort you want and the support you need, thanks to a hybrid of latex materials and a pocketed coil system. The only thing that might get annoying is a button or two that you could feel on the mattress. Adding a mattress protector might help in this case. For 100 nights, you get to sleep on it risk-free. Don’t like it? Return it for your money back. You also get a 25-year warranty that protects you completely for the first 10 years and then offers you a prorated replacement option afterward.