Menu

Best Stuffed Animals: Plushies for All Night Comfort

Danielle Mcleod

When children know that they need to go down for a rest, or have been moved into their own room or new bed, it can be a bit unfamiliar and uncomfortable. This is why so many children have a favorite blanket or stuffed animal, as it provides not only a physical comfort for them to hold onto, but also a segway of familiar scents and texture. 

The love of stuffies is common as children grow, allowing them a sense of responsibility and connection with their imagination surrounding the animal or character represented. We’re highlighted some of the best stuffed animals below for you to consider for your own children and for gifting. 

1. Melissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Rabbit Stuffed Animal – Editor's Choice

Check Price
  • Type: Traditional soft stuffed animal
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: ~ 9 inches tall
  • Features: soft faux fur, durable stitching, realistic features, comfortable weight

2. Animal Adventure Jumbo Plush Character

Check Price
  • Type: Oversized stuffed animal
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: ~ 54 inches long, or tall
  • Features: Oversized, super plush and smooshy, well sewn and durable

3. Plush Treehouse with Animals – Five Stuffed Forest Animals

Check Price
  • Type: Stuffed Animal Play Set
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: each animal ~5 inches height
  • Features: Multiple animals, stuffable tree trunk, designed for interactive play, easy to store animals in tree

4. Ontel Star Belly Dream Lites

Check Price
  • Type: Stuffed Animal with Built in Projector
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: ~ 15 inches tall
  • Features: Soft plush, secure battery compartment, light and color projection, auto turn off, color choice

5. Record Your Own Plush 16 Inch Lab Dog

Check Price
  • Type: Recordable Stuffed Animal
  • Filling: Polyfll
  • Size: ~ 16 inches tall or long
  • Features: Soft and durable, recordable digital device, loud and clear speaker, safe for children.

6. WILD BABY Fox Stuffed Animal Heatable Microwavable Plush Pal

Check Price
  • Type: Heating/Freezing with scent stuffed animal
  • Filling: Removable pack for heat or cold, soft and plush
  • Size: ~ 12 inches
  • Features: Removable pack for cold or heat therapy, child safe stitching and materials, therapeutic use

7. Purrble Companion Calming Toy with Dynamic Heartbeat and Soothing Purr

Check Price
  • Type: Calming and Sensory Interaction
  • Filling: Various sensory fills, polyfill
  • Size: ~ 6 inches
  • Features: Reactive sound and heartbeat, sensory feel areas, soft and durable, great for adults and children

8. Houwsbaby Light up Kitty Stuffed Animal

Check Price
  • Type: Night light or night light/musical stuffed animal
  • Filling: polyfill
  • Size: ~ 12 inches
  • Features: light and lights with music, east button turn on, secure velcro back closure, auto turn off, soft and plush

Best Ages for Stuffed Animals

Children of all ages can enjoy stuffed animals, but many babies won’t begin to interact with them until around 6 months of age and may enjoy playing with and taking a favorite toy around with them. But you should not allow a child to sleep with a stuffed animal until at least 12 months of age. By this point they are strong enough to move out from under anything on or near their face, but until this point even a stuffed animal can be a hazard. 

Older children often enjoy their stuffies as well, and find them comforting well into adulthood. They can quickly become familiar, comfortable items that offer a sense of safety and relief from stress or a day’s anxiety.

Our Top Stuffed Animal Picks 

We’ve compiled some great brands, adorable options, and a wide variety of varying types of stuffed animals and the features they provide. Since many children are drawn to specific stuffed animals, adding in something different can allow them to enjoy more than one favorite.

1. Melissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Rabbit Stuffed Animal – Editor's Choice

Highlights

  • Type: Traditional soft stuffed animal
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: ~ 9 inches tall
  • Features: soft faux fur, durable stitching, realistic features, comfortable weight

Pros

  • Seriously well made and comforting
  • Adorable features and jointed for a floppy effect
  • Very soft and easy to clean

Cons

  • No known issues

If you love a traditional, floppy and cuddly stuffed animals for huggable comfort, then Melissa and Doug brand stuffies are excellent choices. Their bunny rabbit is only one of the many animals they offer, and all provide extra soft plush fur made from polyester, realistic looking features, and a slightly heavy, yet soft fill for a floppy effect. Most animals average about 9 inches in height, making them a perfect size for all ages.

2. Animal Adventure Jumbo Plush Character: Runner Up

Highlights

  • Type: Oversized stuffed animal
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: ~ 54 inches long, or tall
  • Features: Oversized, super plush and smooshy, well sewn and durable

Pros

  • Great for both adults and children
  • Super smooshy and soft for hugging
  • Great to lean against or use as a body pillow

Cons

  • No known issues

Available in many different animal choices, these large, oversized plush animals are perfect for curling up next to, leaning against to read, or simply to provide a comforting presence for children who love their stuffed animals. Soft and cuddly, they come stuffed into a box and when opened, burst out in a poof of stuffie love. Toss in the dryer to fully plump up, or allow it to sit in the sunshine.

3. Plush Treehouse with Animals – Five Stuffed Forest Animals: Best Learning

Highlights

  • Type: Stuffed Animal Play Set
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: each animal ~5 inches height
  • Features: Multiple animals, stuffable tree trunk, designed for interactive play, easy to store animals in tree

Pros

  • Supports hours of play
  • Well made and relatable
  • Great for a huge age range and super cute to display in a nursery

Cons

  • No known issues

Have some little learners in your house that just love to make connections between their toys and the world around them? This 6 piece set offers 5 plushies and a soft tree trunk to help them make connections between environment and animal habitat. Each animal is about 5 inches in height and fits inside the tree trunk. Well made, they provide a soft, fluffy exterior with a soft polyfill for hours of play, fun, and display.

4. Ontel Star Belly Dream Lites: Best with Projector

Highlights

  • Type: Stuffed Animal with Built in Projector
  • Filling: Polyfill
  • Size: ~ 15 inches tall
  • Features: Soft plush, secure battery compartment, light and color projection, auto turn off, color choice

Pros

  • Cute and durable
  • Easy for children to turn on and pick colors
  • Comforting and great for travel

Cons

  • Projector can be a bit bright for little eye
  • Does eat up batteries quickly

Choose from various characters and then light up your child’s ceiling or wall with a moving projector of stars and other fun shapes while they drift off to sleep. Soft and plush, each belly area of the plushies project a child safe light that has an auto turn off. To turn on, simply push the belly, and pick from 6 different colors.

5. Record Your Own Plush 16 Inch Lab Dog: Best Recordable

Highlights

  • Type: Recordable Stuffed Animal
  • Filling: Polyfll
  • Size: ~ 16 inches tall or long
  • Features: Soft and durable, recordable digital device, loud and clear speaker, safe for children.

Pros

  • Easy to use and record
  • Clear sound without being too loud for little ears
  • Soft and huggable

Cons

  • No known issues

Many different animals are offered in this recordable plush, providing you with the opportunity to record your own voice, message, music, or even a favored animal’s bark or meow. Easy to use, the recording provides a very clear, loud, long-lasting, and durable option that you can record over if needed. The stuffy itself is well made and soft with a plush, squishy polyfill. Perfect for gifting, children away from home, and just for fun.

6. WILD BABY Fox Stuffed Animal Heatable Microwavable Plush Pal: Best Heatable

Highlights

  • Type: Heating/Freezing with scent stuffed animal
  • Filling: Removable pack for heat or cold, soft and plush
  • Size: ~ 12 inches

Pros

  • Well made and durable
  • Very comforting even for adults
  • Great animal choices

Cons

  • Care must be taken not to overheat therapy pack

Wild Baby stuffed animals provide a huge array of choices to pick from, all of which have a pack that can be warmed in a microwave, or cooled in a freezer, and smell like lavender for a calming, peaceful comfort. Child safe, this is a soft and cuddly choice that has been used for both children and adults alike for stress relief, and sensory play, and even is physically therapeutic for sprains and bruises, swelling, aches, sinus pressure, and even cramps.

7. Purrble Companion Calming Toy with Dynamic Heartbeat and Soothing Purr: Best Calming

Highlights

  • Type: Calming and Sensory Interaction
  • Filling: Various sensory fills, polyfill
  • Size: ~ 6 inches
  • Features: Reactive sound and heartbeat, sensory feel areas, soft and durable, great for adults and children

Pros

  • Incredibly effective and simple design
  • Soft, soothing sounds
  • Calming and huggable

Cons

  • No known issues

Looking for a naturally stimulating stuffed animal companion that mimics true to life comforts? The Purrble Companion is a high tech toy and tool that provides a heartbeat like sound and feel that changes with how you hold it. It is a calming technique that works for children and adults to help influence self- calming regulation. It also provides soft signs and giggles for emotional response, and also has sensory clicks and bean bag fill areas for fidget control. The adorable design is soft and cuddly.

8. Houwsbaby Light up Kitty Stuffed Animal: Best Night Light

Highlights

  • Type: Night light or night light/musical stuffed animal
  • Filling: polyfill
  • Size: ~ 12 inches
  • Features: light and lights with music, east button turn on, secure velcro back closure, auto turn off, soft and plush

Pros

  • Soft lighting is perfect as a child falls asleep
  • Works well and is nice and huggable
  • Comforting for children scared of the dark

Cons

  • Musical feature may not last long
  • Musical feature may not last long

A soft light is very soothing and comforting to not only young children, but many through their elementary years. This stuffed animal is designed with cool safe LED lights to provide a soft, colorful glow with a simple press of a button on the paw of y9ur choice of animal. Soft and squishy, lights change color and automatically turn off after 15 minutes. A musical version also exists and is preloaded with 10 soft songs for soothing nightie sounds to go along with the lights.

Types of Stuffed Animals 

You might not consider just how many types of stuffed animals there actually are (unless you’ve been a parent for a while), but the sheer amount of types you can choose from can be a bit overwhelming. And missing out on some pretty cool features is common due to this fact. 

— Filling Type and Age Appropriateness

Not all stuffed animals are filled with a soft polyfill. Some use microbeads or poly beads, and knowing this is important for age appropriateness. No matter how well sewn, any stuffed product has the ability to tear or rip. Poly filling generally stays put when this happens, and is easy to replace. Bead-like materials spill, and are incredibly small. They are easy to pick up, ingest, and choke upon. Children younger than 3 or 4, or those prone to placing things in their mouths,  should not have these types of stuffed animals. 

— Recordable/Musical

Some stuffed animals are made with a removable, recordable speaker or music player. These are fun, novelty options to record favorite messages and voices, prayers, or even animal sounds from a beloved pet. Musical options are often lullaby in nature with self timers and gentle, repetitive music that can help a child fall asleep. 

— Scent

Scented stuffed animals usually provide a soft lavender or vanilla smell which is found to be soothing and relaxing. Many of these options use natural oils for an aroma therapeutic effect, which triggers physical reactions that are soothing in nature. 

— Warming

Warming options are designed to be warmed up  in a microwave to provide a gentle heat. These do need to be used carefully, but are initially cozy and comfortable for children and the heat dissipates fairly quick;y. 

— Projector/Light Up

Stuffies with built in projectors that cast stars and movement on a wall or ceiling, or those that have simple LED lights built in to serve as a night light are another fun novelty that helps children focus on something while relaxing and drifting off to sleep. 

— Calming

Some stuffed animals are designed specifically for calming and offer a combination of features, such as sound, scent, and even gentle vibration. These are often designed to mimic other comforting effects a child may be familiar with, such as warmth, heartbeat sounds, and a soft glow. 

You might want to read: The Best Stuffed Animal Storage Ideas

Wrapping it Up

Our top choices help highlight the many different types of stuffed animals available for your consideration. The many features that exist are designed for comfort and calming, and can help sooth your child or refocus them while they drift off to sleep.

Whether you prefer sound and scent, heat and lights, or a simple traditional floppy choice to hug and cuddle – we have you covered.