Menu

See our Cyber Week top picks 🤩

The Best Heavyweight Down Alternative Comforters

Updated November 10, 2020

Down comforters have great insulating properties and are made with the natural down and feathers sourced from birds such as duck and geese. However, for a variety of different reasons, not everyone wants to own and use a natural down comforter. It doesn’t matter if you are worried about animal cruelty, have allergies, or are looking for a cheaper alternative; you need to know that down alternative comforters are the next best thing to choose, sometimes even a better choice than down comforters even.

Rank Product Overview
#1

Beckham Hotel Collection

check price

 

  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, King/Cal King
  • Cover: not specified
  • Fill: polyester
#2

KARRISM Down Alternative Comforter

check price

 

  • Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
  • Cover: double-brushed polyester
  • Fill: microfiber
#3

Royal Hotel Down Alternative Comforter

check price

 

  • Available sizes: Queen, Oversized Queen, King, Oversized King
  • Cover: cotton
  • Fill:  nylon stands
#4

EASELAND Down Alternative Comforter

check price

 

  • Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, Oversized Queen, King, Cal King
  • Cover: soft crushed polyester
  • Fill: polyfill
#5

Lavish Comforts Winter Comforter

check price

 

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King, Cal King
  • Cover: microfiber
  • Fill:  poly-fiber

What Is Fill Power?

The weight of a comforter will be determined by how much fill is inside of the product itself. For the most part, fill power is used to describe a property of natural down comforters and it is a reflection of the volume taken up by one ounce of down. Comforters that have a high fill power typically provide better insulation properties, which makes them warmer compared to other options.

For the most part, down alternative comforters don’t usually have fill power but there are brands who choose to include this in the product description in order to give the customers a sense of the heat potential of that certain product:

  • Comforters that have a fill power below 400 are mostly intended for summer use or, if they are used during the winter or some other cold season, then they should be layered with other blankets.
  • Comforters that have a fill power between 400 and 599 are not very suitable for winter use either, as they are mostly purchased to be used in the other three seasons.
  • If you’re looking for something a bit warmer, you can choose a comforter with a fill power between 600 and 799. People tend to sleep cold are much more comfortable with using such a product.
  • For those who want the best loft and insulation, there is always the option to choose a comforter with a fill power that’s over 800. These are considered the true heavyweight winter blankets and they are not intended for summer use, unless you plan to sleep with your air-conditioning unit turned on.

Stitches on a Down Alternative Comforter

The stitching of a comforter is often an aspect that not a lot of people pay attention to. However, the stitching of the comforter can determine the quality of the product, can hint you on the abilities to prevent the loft from shifting location, and can grant you information of the insulating abilities of the product:

  • Sewn-through stitches mean that the top and bottom of the comforter have been sewn together in order to create individual chambers, each hosting equal quantities of fill. By creating these tiny boxes, this type of stitching will prevent cold spots which would occur if the comforter wasn’t stitched at all. However, this particular type of stitch doesn’t have a great ability to maintain loft, so it doesn’t render what most of us would call a “puffy” comforter.
  • Gusseted stitching is affected by the top and bottom of the comforter being connected to one another around the edges with the help of additional strips of fabric. Gusseted comforters more generous in terms of loft because the fill has more room for upwards expansion.
  • Diamond-quilted comforters have stitches in the shape of a diamond and they connect the top and the bottom of the comforter. They are very similar to sewn-through stitches as they don’t allow the fill to move from one side to the other.
  • Baffle-box stitching is reflected by individual compartments that are created with separate pieces of fabric connecting the top and bottom sides of the comforter. While this type of stitching also makes sure that the fill of the comforter stays in place, it also gives the fill more room to move around, which eventually leads to owning a comforter with more loft.

 

Other Important Buying Considerations

Regardless of whether you are looking to buy a lightweight or heavyweight comforter, there are a couple of extra things that you should know before paying money for such a product:

  • Heavyweight comforters generally have high insulation power, which means they are unsuitable for all-year-round use. This means that during warmer months, you will have to put away the comforter whilst making sure that you don’t compress it too much. This is why you should avoid keeping the comforter in a vacuum-sealed bag. It is a better idea for you to fold it and store it in a dry closet, or perhaps use a cotton storage bag that doesn’t stuff the comforter too much.
  • One of the main reasons why people choose down alternative comforters is because they’re easier to wash compared to products that are made from natural down. However, this doesn’t mean that every down alternative comforter can be washed in the washing machine. For the most part, brands that do allow machine washing will always specify this on the label of the product or the presentation page. If your comforter can be washed in the washing machine, you will most likely have to use a program with cold water, a delicate setting, and mild detergent. Some of the comforters that allow machine washing will require you to tumble dry them on low heat and avoid the use of bleach. It is always better to use a front-loading washing machine if you’re trying to clean the comforter in order to prevent excessive bunching.
  • Just because you are buying a down alternative comforter doesn’t mean that you will always come across very cheap products. If you are limited by your budget, you can purchase an affordable download alternative comforter for as low as $25 and as high as $75. Budget comforters are generally limited to synthetic fills and don’t provide a lot of warmth and loft. If you’re willing to spend as much as $150, you can perhaps buy a comforter that’s made entirely from natural down or a down alternative product with quality fill material. High-end comforters can cost hundreds of dollars and, if you’re looking for an alternative within this price range, you can buy something that’s filled with high-quality silk or even wool.

 

Top 5 Heavyweight Down Alternative Comforter Reviews

Having obtained some of the need-to-know information before buying a heavyweight down alternative comforter, it’s time to explore our options and see what this generous online market has in store for all of us.

 

1. Beckham Hotel Collection

SPECS

  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, King/Cal King
  • Cover: not specified
  • Fill: polyester

Label: bargain buy 

If you’re looking for an affordable comforter to be used to in colder seasons, this Beckham luxury product is definitely an option worth considering. It is a hypoallergenic product that doesn’t create a favorable environment for mildew, mold, or dust mites, thus keeping you safe from potential allergy triggers. Filled with polyester fibers, this particular down alternative comforter pretty much stays true to the standard specifications that you are able to find and others similarly-priced products. 

Created using box stitches, the comforter is designed to keep the filling place regardless of how much you toss and turn during the night. As far as maintenance is concerned, you can wash this comforter in your home washing machine by making sure to choose a cycle with cold water. You can either tumble dry on low or leave the comforter out in the sun, allowing it to dry out. 

Pros Cons
  • Affordable.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Good for winter.
  • Hypoallergenic.
  • Not available in Queen size.
  • Not durable in the long term.

Who Should Buy This? 

The Beckham Luxury Linens comforter is designed for winter use, but also for people who are looking for a very affordable down alternative, for people who suffer from allergies, or for those who wish to choose a winter comforter that offers a good price-to-quality ratio.

CHECK PRICE

 

2. KARRISM Down Alternative Comforter

SPECS:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
  • Cover: double-brushed polyester
  • Fill: microfiber

Label: Amazon’s choice 

Next up, we have another solid winter comforter that’s made with microfiber filling, resulting in a product that feels soft and rather fluffy to the touch. Because it’s made with hypoallergenic down alternative fill, this product is safe to use even by people who suffer from certain types of allergies. The comforter features corner tabs to make the whole process of fitting the duvet cover a lot easier. It’s available in white, gray, and navy, and four different sizes, so that you can pick the one that best suits your bed. 

The comforter is designed to be washed inside the washing machine, as long as you choose a gentle washing cycle and cold water. The cover is made entirely out of brushed microfiber, which also feels very soft to the touch and has surprisingly good breathability properties. What you can expect from this specific product is a decent amount of loft at a good price, and stitching that prevents the fill from shifting locations.

Pros Cons
  • Affordable.
  • Soft to the touch.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Eight corner tabs.
  • Three color options.
  • Doesn’t stay true to its size.

Who Should Buy This? 

The Karrism down alternative comforter is designed for people who are looking to stay within a very strict budget, but would still rather spend their money on a product that strives to be qualitative in spite of the fact that it’s designed for people looking for best-value kind of purchases.

CHECK PRICE

 

3. Royal Hotel Down Alternative Comforter

SPECS:

  • Available sizes: Queen, Oversized Queen, King, Oversized King
  • Cover: cotton
  • Fill:  nylon stands

Label: best with cotton cover 

Let’s spice things up a bit by looking at the down alternative comforter that’s a bit more expensive and yet surprisingly good for winter use. It comes with an outer shell that is made entirely out of cotton and has a thread count of 300, so you know that the woven fabric is strong enough to last for many years to come. With a fill power of over 750, this comforter is clearly designed for people who are looking for a product that can help them last through winter, without bringing some of the headaches that natural down comforters put on the table. 

On the sides of the comforter you will find a one-inch gusset which, as we’ve previously discussed, is designed to bring more loft to the product, to make sure that even if you buy down alternative product, you still get to enjoy the fluffiness everybody loves in a natural down item. Each of the corners of the comforter has its own individual loop to make it easier to secure a duvet cover. 

Pros Cons
  • 300 thread count.
  • Cotton outer shell.
  • Soft to the touch.
  • Loftier when compared to others.
  • No small sizes available.

Who Should Buy This? 

The Royal Hotel Down alternative comforter is designed for people who are looking for a quality product to use during the winter, but especially for fans of cotton, as this is the material used to make the outer shell.

CHECK PRICE

 

4. EASELAND Down Alternative Comforter

SPECS:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, Oversized Queen, King, Cal King
  • Cover: soft crushed polyester
  • Fill: polyfill

Label: customer favorite

There are plenty of reasons why the following comforter that’s on this list is the customer favorite. The outer shell is made from soft crushed polyester and available in a wide variety of colors. Inside the product, you’ll find a polyfill that is evenly distributed thanks to the box stitching of the comforter. Because it arrives vacuum-sealed in a package, it will take some time for the comforter to regain its original fluffiness. In fact, the manufacturer recommends that you either put the comforter in the dryer or leave out in the sunlight for a few hours.

As with most other similar products, this down alternative comforter can be washed inside your home washing machine, saving you the energy of having to spot clean it. As always, you will need to use a gentle machine cycle and make sure that you tumble dry on low heat. While this may not be the most high-quality down alternative comforter out there, it is one of the best products considering its price and it just happens to be a hit with customers that are looking for a down alternative product to keep them warm during the winter.

Pros Cons
  • Seven color/pattern options.
  • Great insulation.
  • Customer favorite.
  • Good price.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Prone to wrinkles.

Who Should Buy This?

If you are on the lookout for a down alternative comforter that plenty of other buyers have purchased and tested before you, then you will find that this product matches your given requirements.

CHECK PRICE

 

5. Lavish Comforts Winter Comforter

SPECS:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King, Cal King
  • Cover: microfiber
  • Fill:  poly-fiber

Label: editor’s choice

The last product on today’s list comes from Lavish Comforts and it is a winter down alternative comforter designed to bring you the very best of microfiber duvets without having to worry about spending too much money on such a product. The specifications of the comforter pretty much stay true to what you would expect to find in a product within this price range. Made from double-brushed microfiber, the manufacturer promises the feel the cover is somewhat comparable to Egyptian cotton.

Being a hypoallergenic product, you’re sure that your allergies are kept at a bay thanks to the fill that doesn’t create a favorable thriving environment for dust mites or mold. The product is machine washable, which makes it super easy to care for it. It features a baffle box construction to make sure that the fill stays in place no matter how much you move during the night, and it also comes with corner tabs, which makes it easy to secure the comforter to the cover.

Pros Cons
  • Microfiber cover that feels like cotton.
  • Baffle box construction.
  • Hypoallergenic.
  • Good insulation.
  • Bunches up when washed.

Who Should Buy This?

The Lavish Comforts down alternative winter comforter is an affordable alternative for people with an average budget at their disposal to spend on such a product.

CHECK PRICE

 

You might want to check: Can You Wash Down Alternative Comforters?

Bottom Line

As you can see, there are plenty of heavyweight down comforters that might actually help you get through winter for the upcoming years. However, you should also consider the fact that some of the best heavyweight comforters that provide excellent insulation are those filled with materials such as wool, which are both expensive and hard to come across.

For the most part, buying a heavyweight down alternative comforter isn’t difficult when you consider how many different products the market has to offer. The real question is: do you have to be patient to browse as many of them as possible before making a buying decision?