Menu

See our Cyber Week top picks 🤩

The Best Down Alternative Comforter

Updated November 10, 2020

If you’re looking to purchase a new comforter for your room, you could be overwhelmed by the number of options that are on the market. While goose and down comforters are most popular in the market, they’re not ideal for individuals that have allergies. While you may be under the impression that you’re losing out by purchasing a comforter down alternative, you’ll be happy to know that there are plenty of alternatives on the market that provide you with the same amount of warmth and comfort, and at a cheaper price.

Choosing the right down alternative comforter will add a unique touch to your bedroom, and provide you with that soft and luxurious feeling. To get you started on choosing the best down alternative comforter that’s best suited for you, we’ll take a look at some factors to consider before getting into some of the nitty gritty details, and get you started with five of some of the best down alternative comforters on the market.

Rank Product Highlights
#1

LINENSPA All-Season White Down Alternative Quilted Comforter

check price

  • Material Type: Microfiber
  • Sizes Available: Twin XL, California King, Full, King, Oversized King, Oversized Queen, Queen, Twin
  • Machine washable: Yes
#2

The Ultimate All Season Comforter Deal Hotel Luxury Down Alternative Comforter

check price

  • Material Type: 100% microfiber
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Queen, King, California King, Oversized Queen
  • Machine washable: Yes
#3

GrayEagle Bedding Co. All Season Down Alternative Comforter

check price

  • Material Type: Microfiber
  • Sizes Available: Twin/Twin XL, Supreme King, Super King
  • Machine washable: Yes, but it’s best to be dry-cleaned
#4

Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert

check price

  • Material Type: Soft siliconized fiber filling
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Queen, King, California King
  • Machine washable: Yes
#5

Beckham Hotel Collection 1600 Series – Luxury Goose Down Alternative Comforter

check price

  • Material Type: Synthetic Goose Feathers
  • Sizes Available: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Machine washable: Yes

You may want to read: Hotel Collection Down Alternative Comforters

Factors to Consider

  • There’s no harm taking a look at some of the reviews online, and taking a look at recommendations that other users may have
  • What type of filling are you looking for?
  • Is there a specific type of fabric that you may prefer?
  • Do you have a preferred aesthetic or look?
  • What level of warmth do you require?
  • What size do you need?
  • It is imperative that the comforter down alternative that you purchase is not only fire retardant but also purchased from a reputable source
  • You need to ensure that you’re willing to take good care of your comforter down alternative and make sure that it’s able to last for a period of time

You may be interested in: Down Comforter vs Duvet

What Exactly is a Down Alternative Comforter?

To start off, it might be best to talk about what a down comforter is. Down is usually made from a material that’s from ducks and geese. It’s an incredibly popular material as it’s not only soft but known to provide individuals with adequate warmth. Down comforters, however, tend to be on the pricier side, and they can also induce allergies and may be difficult to maintain. Hence, down alternative comforters are comforters that use materials instead of duck and geese feathers.

A down alternative comforter is usually constructed from synthetic materials that are incredibly similar to down. There is a huge range of down alternative comforters available depending on the type of material you’re looking for, along with the amount of money that you’re willing to spend.

What Are the Benefits of a Comforter Down Alternative?

There are several benefits of a comforter down alternative:

  1. Comforter down alternatives is usually much less expensive than down comforters. While down comforters tend to be in the higher price range, comforter down alternatives come in a wide range of prices and still deliver the same amount of comfort and warmth
  2. If you’re allergic to down, you’ll definitely be choosing a comforter down alternative instead as they’re usually hypoallergenic, and can still provide you with restful sleep at night
  3. It’s hard to take care of down comforters as it’s a very delicate material. You usually have to be wary when washing and storing a down comforter as one wrong move can result in catastrophic results. With down alternative comforts, however, they’re easier to maintain, and can even be thrown in the wash.

What Are Some of the Drawbacks of a Comforter Down Alternative?

While there are benefits of a comforter down alternative, it also comes with some drawbacks:

  1. In comparison to down, comforter down alternatives isn’t as warm. There are however comforter down alternatives that deal with this drawback by packing in more material
  2. If not taken care of properly, down comforters can have a short lifespan. However, overall the lifespan of a down comforter is longer than that of a comforter down alternative. Due to the fact that they require much less care, and are priced more inexpensively, they also last much less than a regular down comforter

What Material Should You Look For?

There are all sorts of material that can be used in a comforter down alternative, the below is a snapshot of the different materials to provide you with a head start:

  • One of the most common materials in a comforter down alternative is that of polyester. Since it’s an extremely flexible material, it also makes it incredibly popular. Polyester is also inexpensive and is light, soft, and able to provide adequate warmth
  • A material that’s very similar to down is also known as primaloft. Not only is it lightweight, but it’s also incredibly warm, and can even be resistant to water
  • Another down alternative is known as gel fiber. As the name suggests, the fibers are infused with gel to help in retaining heat. In comparison to polyester, gel fibers are usually warmer

What About the Fill Power?

Fill power is an estimate of how much of the comforter is filled. Usually the higher the fill power, the warmer the comforter is. While this number may not be as accurate with down alternative comforters, it can still give a good indication of the warmth that the comforter might provide.

Usually, comforters that are filled up to 400 delivery very limited warmth, and you’ll use it with other blankets or only during the summer. Anything below 600, on the other hand, wouldn’t be an all-season comforter, but can still be relatively comfortable. For numbers between 600 and 799, you’ll get something that’s relatively warm. If you’re looking for the warmest comforters, however, you’ll look for a number above 800. It’s appropriate for winter and will provide you with the warmth that you require.

Other Factors to Take into Consideration

While the above factors are important in choosing the best comforter down alternative, the factors below should also be taken into consideration.

  1. Down comforter alternatives comes in a wide variety of fabrics that you should take into account while making your decision. Batiste is an opaque cotton fabric that’s relatively lightweight, and one of the gentlest fabrics. Sateen, on the other hand, can be luxuriously smooth and soft. Damask is a fabric that’s on the glossy side, and cambric is a delicate fabric that’s relatively fine, and lightweight
  2. Another fabric that you should take into account, is the shell of the comforter down alternative. A wide variety of materials can be used such as cotton since it’s known for being easy to take care of, inexpensive, and soft. Another common shell fabric is silk as it’s soft and cool to the touch and does not retain heat easily. However, it is harder to clean and is more expensive than cotton. Shell fabric that’s made of wool is usually warmer and is relatively soft. However, they’re usually more expensive and are seldom used as shells for down comforter alternatives. The most common shell fabrics are synthetics and blends that have a combination of different materials with cotton
  3. Are you thinking of having an organic comforter down alternative? Most companies do use organic materials, and you may want to consider purchasing a comforter down alternative that uses fills that are free of chemicals and toxins
  4. Remember to consider the size of the comforter down alternative that you are purchasing. While standard sizes are available, the dimensions may be slightly varied amongst brands. Hence, you want to make sure that you measure the size of your mattress correctly, and ensure that the size you purchase is accurate
  5. Similar to bed sheets and pillows, there is also plenty of comforter down alternatives in a plethora of different colors and patterns. You can easily pick a comforter down alternative that suits the aesthetic of your bedroom best

You might want to check: Best Heavyweight Down Alternative Comforters

How Do You Care for Your Comforter Down Alternative?

After purchasing your comforter down alternative, you also want to make sure that you take proper care of it to make sure that it can last a number of years. There are just three things you need to remember when taking care of a comforter down alternative:

  1. Remember to shake it out as often as possible. This helps in redistributing the down alternative and keeps it even. If you notice that there’s a hole and the material is leaking, make sure that the shell is fixed as soon as possible.
  2. Follow the instructions of the manufacturer that you’ve purchased the comforter down alternative from. While some can be washed in a washing machine, you want to ensure that you don’t use hot water but only cold water, and with a light detergent.
  3. Store your comforter down alternative properly. You never want to stuff it in a tight box, compress, or risk trapping any moisture or dirt. Instead, if you want to store it the best thing to do is to fold it up and keep it in a closet. Ideally, you want to store the comforter down alternative in a breathable bag to keep it nice and fresh.

You may be interested in: The Best Comforters on Amazon

Top 5 Comforter Down Alternative Reviews

We’ve taken the liberty of rounding up some of the best comforters down alternatives and breaking down the details to help you choose the one that will work for you

LINENSPA All-Season White Down Alternative Quilted Comforter

Specs:

  • Material Type: Microfiber
  • Sizes Available: Twin XL, California King, Full, King, Oversized King, Oversized Queen, Queen, Twin
  • Machine washable: Yes

Label: most basic

This comforter down alternative comes in seven different colors to match the aesthetics of your bedroom. Either than being extremely soft, this all-season comforter is also made with microfiber and comes with eight built-in corners, and side loops to secure your duvet cover. Filled with 300gsm fill weight, this down comforter alternative will keep you toasty and warm without the potential of being allergic to feathers since it’s made with hypoallergenic down alternative fill.

The unique box stitch design of this comforter down alternative will help keep the filling in place, and this comforter is also backed with a three-year warranty. Maintenance is also easy since you can throw it in the machine wash on a gentle cycle, and tumble dry on the law to help in quality maintenance.

Pros:

  • Can be machine-washed and tumble-dried
  • Lightweight
  • Coms with eight built-in corners and side loops

Cons:

  • Buyers have mentioned that they don’t do really well with washing machines

Who Should Purchase This?

If you’re looking for something basic that’s relatively inexpensive. Not only does it come in different colors, but it’s also made with microfibers so you can be assured that you’ll be kept nice and warm. It’s also easy to maintain since this comforter can be washed and tumble-dried. It also has a reversible design, so you can flip it over accordingly.

check price

The Ultimate All Season Comforter Deal Hotel Luxury Down Alternative Comforter

Specs:

  • Material Type: 100% microfiber
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Queen, King, California King, Oversized Queen
  • Machine washable: Yes

Label: Most popular

This luxurious comforter is sure to keep you cozy and comfortable at night. Either than being made with 100% microfiber, it’s also extra plush and comes with tabs. It’s also incredibly soft as this down alternative comforter is made with premium double brushed 1,800 series double fiber, which makes it softer than Egyptian cotton.

You can also easily pop this in the washer, and it’s also made of hypoallergenic 100% polyfiber filling. The comforter has also been meticulously constructed with a baffle box construction to prevent both corner tabs as well as shifting.

Pros:

  • Machine washable
  • Made with premium double-brushed 1,800 series double fiber
  • Constructed with a baffle box construction

Cons:

  • Sizes seem to vary, hence it’s best to ensure that you have the right size before purchase

Who Should Purchase This?

This is a fantastic buy for someone that’s looking to keep themselves warm and have a soft and cozy comforter at night. Either than having a sufficient amount of fill, it also has the right amount of warmth to ensure that you’re not too hot and not too cold at night. Furthermore, you can also easily toss this in the wash if it gets dirty.

check price

GrayEagle Bedding Co. All Season Down Alternative Comforter

Specs:

  • Material Type: Microfiber
  • Sizes Available: Twin/Twin XL, Supreme King, Super King
  • Machine washable: Yes, but it’s best to be dry-cleaned

Label: premium option

If you’re looking to purchase something that’s a little more expensive, this is the comforter that you’re looking for. Either than being hypoallergenic and filled with microfiber, it’s also soft, luxurious, and will provide you with the warmth that you need.  This comforter is also meticulously constructed with a baffle box stitch and double needle stitching to prevent the filling from shifting. This is also an all-season comforter that you can use whether it’s warm or cold.

While this down comforter alternative can be machine –washed, you’d want to air dry it instead of tossing it in the dryer. The manufacturer also recommends that it is dry-cleaned instead. This comforter is also oversized and is hence perfect for pillow-top beds. The microfiber filling is also easy to take care of and is made with 116 ounces of filling.

Pros:

  • Oversized comforter, and is extra wide
  • Can be machine-washed
  • The soft comforter that’s filled with microfiber

Cons:

  • Buyers have mentioned that the filling isn’t as secure

Who Should Purchase This?

Someone that’s looking for something a little more luxurious. Extra bonus if you have a pillowtop bed since this is an oversized comforter. Since this is slightly oversized, it’s also extra wide, and hence you won’t have to worry about fighting for the comforters at night, and you can be provided with adequate and restful sleep.

check price

Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert

Specs:

  • Material Type: Soft siliconized fiber filling
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Queen, King, California King
  • Machine washable: Yes

Label: best buy

This comforter comes in a total of four different colors to match the different aesthetics of your bedroom. It also has 350gsm filling features to ensure that you’re kept warm throughout the night. The box stitching also helps to ensure that the comforter filling doesn’t shift over time. The comforter is filled with a soft siliconized fiber-fill material that’s supremely soft and will lull you to sleep.

To take care of the comforter, you can have it machine-washed in cold water, and it can be tumble-dried or sun-dried accordingly. This comforter is also suited to all seasons, and the softness and impeccable stitching will ensure that you have the best sleep every single night.

Pros:

  • Can be machine-washed
  • Made of soft siliconized fiber-filling that’s supremely soft
  • All-season comforter that’ll also keep you warm

Cons:

  • Some buyers had issues with washing it

Who Should Purchase This?

If you’re looking for an all-season comforter that’ll keep you comfortable and warm throughout the year, this is the best comforter for you. Not only is it known to be supremely comfortable, but it’s also inexpensive and will keep you warm. Buyers have also mentioned that Utopia Bedding provides excellent customer service if you run into any issues.

check price

Beckham Hotel Collection 1600 Series – Luxury Goose Down Alternative Comforter

Specs:

  • Material Type: Synthetic Goose Feathers
  • Sizes Available: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Machine washable: Yes

Label: most color options

This down alternative comforter comes in 11 different colors, so you’re able to decide on whichever color suits the aesthetic of your bedroom best. Either than being filled with synthetic goose feathers for a lightweight comforter, this hypoallergenic comforter is also stitched with hems that are durable and impeccable stitching.

In terms of care, this comforter can be machine-washed or tumble-dried, and it would be best if it was sun-dried. There’s also a 30 days customer satisfaction guarantee so you’re free to return the item within 30 days if it isn’t to your liking.

Pros:

  • Machine washable and can be tumble dried
  • Comes with a 30-day guarantee
  • Has an array of colors to choose from

Cons:

  • It’s a more lightweight comforter

Who Should Purchase This?

If you need to find a comforter that matches the aesthetic of your bedroom but is also comfortable. Coming in 11 different colors, you’re sure to find a color that would suit you best.  Since it comes with a 30-day guarantee, this is also great if you want to try something out but are unsure if it would suit your needs.

check price

You may want to read: Down Comforters VS Down Alternative

The Bottom Line

Purchasing a comforter down alternative doesn’t have to be a difficult decision. By considering the necessary factors and being able to decide what’s most important to you, you’ll have no problem purchasing a down alternative comforter that’s best suited to your needs.

The above comprises of various options of comforter down alternatives ranging from those that are a little more expensive, to those that come in a variety of colors. With the above, you’re sure to be able to find a comforter down alternative that suits your needs. Most importantly, you need to find one that will provide you with a great night’s sleep. The above options are meant to get you started on your process, if you’ve found the article helpful, do share with us your comments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a down alternative comforter cool in the summer?

Down comforters first came into popularity due to their warmth. Down alternative materials were developed to mimic this insulation property of down but not everyone needs a super warm blanket all season. There are all-season options for summer or lightweight down alternative comforters that will help you to keep you cooler in warmer weather. The first thing you will need to do is choose a comforter with an appropriate fill rating. anything that is rated over 600 would not be a good all-season comforter. To keep cool in the summer make sure the shell of your comforter and the duvet cover are made from breathable wicking materials that will draw moisture out and keep you cool.

How do you take care of a down alternative comforter?

For the most part down alternative comforters should not be dry cleaned, bleached, ironed or steamed as this can damage the comforter and reduce its softness. However, make sure you check the manufacturer's cleaning instructions for the proper details for your purchase. When machine washing you will want to use the gentle or delicate cycle and use cool water. You will want to run the machine through multiple rinse cycles and use only a small amount of a mild detergent. If you use too much detergent or do not wash it out completely it can hinder the softness and longevity of the comforter. Before you wash, check for any rips or tears and stitch them up so that the filling does not come out in the washing or drying process. One of the best ways to take care of your down alternative comforter is to use a duvet cover. If you are using a cover it is the cover you will be washing regularly and the comforter itself would only need to be washed once a year or if it has become soiled. This will help keep the bedding in prime condition. Shake out the comforter often as it helps to redistribute the filling and keeps it even. If you are going to be storing your comforter, keep the blanket in a breathable bag to prevent mildew from forming. Make sure the item is completely dry before storing and that the storing area is ventilated. This will also prevent mildew from forming.

Can you wash a down alternative comforter?

Yes! One of the great benefits of having a down alternative fill as opposed to a down fill is how much easier and cheaper it is to wash and care for them as they can be washed at home in your machine. In fact, unlike a down comforter, most down alternative comforters should not be dry cleaned as it can affect its fluffiness. You should be washing the comforter on the gentle cycle using cool water. Use a small amount of a mild detergent and put the comforter through two rinse cycles to ensure that all of the detergent is washed out of the comforter. Any detergent that is left on a comforter can cause stiffness and can interfere with the product's longevity. To dry, tumble dry on low with no heat and add a tennis ball or sneaker to the dryer. These items help to fluff the comforter as they knock out the lumps while drying. Be sure you check the manufacturer's washing directions for your individual products before cleaning.

What material should you be looking for in a down alternative comforter?

Down is the cluster of fine feathers found underneath the harder exterior feather of ducks and geese. It is a very popular material for comforters due to it’s fluffy and soft nature as well as its insulating properties. Down comforter, however, can be on the pricier side and for some asthmatics or allergy sufferers that cannot be used at all. Industry has created down alternatives to mimic the attributes of down while eliminating some of the negative features. Polyester is a very popular down alternative as it is inexpensive, light, soft, and able to provide adequate warmth. Primaloft was invented by the US military as a down alternative that would provide the warmth of down even when wet. Finally there is the down alternative known as gel fiber. This material has fibers that are infused with gel to help in retaining heat. It is lightweight and fluffy with the properties of natural down. These synthetic materials are both animal free and hypoallergenic. There are also natural fiber alternatives to down-like fillers that use bamboo, silk or buckwheat hull.