Menu

What is the Best Crib Mattress Cover?

Updated January 14, 2020

Rank Products Highlights
#1

American Baby Company Crib Mattress Pad Cover

Buy Now

  • Available in two different sizes for the cover and two more for the pad.
  • Features a waterproof protective layer.
  • Can be cleaned in the washing machine.
#2

Jambini Fully Encased Crib Mattress Cover

Buy Now

  • It’s free of any toxic chemicals.
  • Has a zipper that allows you to fix the cover in place.
  • Can be cleaned in the washing machine.
  • Has waterproof capabilities.
  • It fits standard crib sizes.
#3

SureGuard Mattress Protectors Crib Size

Buy Now

  • Available in crib size, but also full bed sizes.
  • Surface is made with cotton terry.
  • Can be washed and dried in the machine.
  • Can fit any mattress within six inches of height.
#4

Baby and Brooke Organic Crib Mattress Cover Pad

Buy Now

  • Is made from organic bamboo, being both safe and pleasant to the touch.
  • Since it doesn’t use any chemicals in its construction, it doesn’t emit chemical odors either.
  • Doesn’t make any noises when the child moves in his sleep.
  • Is waterproof.
  • Responsive and polite customer service.
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty against wet accidents.
#5

MILLIARD Crib & Toddler Mattress Protector Cover

Buy Now

  • Provides waterproof protection.
  • Cover allows airflow to pass through, so your baby can sleep dry through any season.
  • Acts as a barrier against the most common contaminants.
  • Can easily be cleaned inside the washing machine.
#6

Crib Mattress Protector Cover by Margaux & May

Buy Now

  • Doesn’t make almost any noise when the baby turns in his sleep.
  • Is waterproof and breathable.
  • Doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals like lead or BPA.
  • Can be washed in the machine.
  • Made with high-quality bamboo rayon.

 

Whether your kid is still sleeping in a crib or is ready to move to a regular bed, a mattress cover should always be an option because it provides so many benefits that every parent can take advantage of, from the fact that they prolong the life of a mattress to the fact that they make changing the bed a whole lot easier. So, today we’re going to talk about the best crib mattress cover, but not before giving you heads-up on the signs to follow and determine whether your toddler is ready to switch from crib to bed.

What Makes a Good Cover?

As you can imagine, some crib mattress covers are better than others. Parents often prioritize when looking to purchase such an item, but they could look for ones that meet all the important criteria:

  • Protection is a very important feature when we’re discussing crib mattress covers. But protection can mean more than just one thing. It could be waterproof protection, which ensures that both the mattress and the baby won’t get wet in case of a leaking diaper, excessive sweat or other liquids that can find their way into the crib. Even so far as SIDS protection. It could be allergen protection, that ensures the baby is kept away from contaminants such as dust mites, pollen, bacteria, bed bugs, allergen triggers and more (in most cases, organic covers do a good job in keeping them away from your child).

A picture of a bed-bug on the mattress

  • Comfort is another important thing to consider when purchasing a crib mattress cover. Quilted covers will generally add an extra layer of cushioning, but you need to make sure that the combination between top sheet + cover + mattress pad + crib mattress isn’t that soft as to suffocate the baby if he turns face down onto the bed. But comfort also refers to the breathability technologies that included in the construction of a mattress cover. The best such products will allow a decent amount of airflow to pass through the surface, regulating your baby’s body temperature throughout the entire year.
  • Cleaning is really important because your mattress cover is very exposed to liquid accidents. The best piece of advice is to always have a spare cover and pad at hand, so you can throw the dirty ones into the dryer. Speaking of which, always choose covers that are resistant to multiple washes, because you won’t want to buy a new cover every week.

 

Top 7 Best Crib Mattress Cover Reviews

1. American Baby Company Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad Cover

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 28 x 52 x 9 inches
  • Weight: 2 pounds
  • Sold as: a single unit or a pack of two or three covers

Made from a top and bottom that features a 100% polyester construction and a middle layer that’s waterproof, the American Baby Company mattress cover is in it to win. This pad can fit a mattress that has a maximum of 6 inches in height, even if the pockets are 9 inches deep. The cover is super-easy to clean, as you can just remove it whenever needed and throw it into the washing machine. Of course, it’s best to go with the two-pack offer, so you can always have a spare at hand. You can buy the cover and the pads sold by American Baby Company in the following sizes: Mini Crib 24 x 38 inches, Bassinet 15 x 33 inches, Cradle 18 x 36 inches, Twin Size 39 x 75 inches, Multi-use pad 18 x 27 inches, Multi-use pad 27 x 36 inches.

Pros

  • Available in two different sizes for the cover and two more for the pad.
  • Features a waterproof protective layer.
  • Can be cleaned in the washing machine.

Cons

  • Some parents reported a chemical smell in the cover.

Buy Now

2. Jambini Fully Encased Crib Mattress Cover

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: fits a standard crib mattress
  • Weight: 15.2 ounces
  • Sold as: a single unit

If you were looking for a cover that definitely won’t come off the bed unless you want it to, this is just the right product for your baby’s crib. Due to the side zipper, you can rest assured that no matter how much your kids fuss during the night, the cover will stay in place and keep the pad underneath it in place, as well. This cover is made from materials that are hypoallergenic, which means that it’s safe to use it around kids of all ages. The manufacturer promises that this crib mattress cover can withstand the stress of hundreds of washes and still be in great shape to use.

It’s made without any sort of toxic materials, although we would have like to know more about the layers and construction of the cover.

Pros

  • It’s free of any toxic chemicals.
  • Has a zipper that allows you to fix the cover in place.
  • Can be cleaned in the washing machine.
  • Has waterproof capabilities.
  • It fits standard crib sizes.

Cons

  • Zipper feels a bit flimsy.

Buy Now

3. SureGuard Mattress Protectors Crib Size

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 28 x 52 inches
  • Weight: 12.3 ounces
  • Sold as: a single unit

SureGuard-Mattress-Protectors-Crib-Size-1.jpg

What we liked about the SureGuard cover is that it’s been made available for all sorts of bed sizes, which means that you can buy it for the baby crib mattress, but also for the following beds: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full XL, Queen, King, Cal King and Mini Crib. Made from cotton, this product vouchers for using natural materials that won’t harm your baby in any way. Even more, this particular mattress pad comes with a 10 year warranty period, which is more than you can say for other covers. Since it’s hypoallergenic, it can block unwanted contaminants such as bacteria, dust mites, bed bugs or several allergy triggers. The top of the cover is waterproof, in order to prevent small liquid accidents from ruining your baby’s sleep. Thanks to the elastic band, it’s really easy to take the cover and off the bed and throw it inside the washing machine for cleaning. You also have a 30 day free trial period to benefit from, during which you can ask for a refund if you’re not completely happy with the cover.

Pros

  • Available in crib size, but also full bed sizes.
  • Surface is made with cotton terry.
  • Can be washed and dried in the machine.
  • Can fit any mattress within six inches of height.

Cons

  • Cover tends to slide off memory foam mattresses.

Buy Now

4. COZYCUDDLES Premium Crib Protector & Cover

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 6 inches
  • Weight: 1.3 pounds
  • Sold as: a single unit

COZYCUDDLES-Premium-Crib-Protector-Cover-1.jpg

There are the whole bunch of features that made us appreciate the CozyCuddle crib mattress protector. First, there was the 360 degrees angle zipper, which is always a nice feature to see on a bed cover, as it guarantees that it will stay in place no matter how much the sleeper tosses and turns during the night. The waterproof feature is integrated in the cover, to make sure that your mattress stays protected, while your child is able to enjoy a night’s rest without feels discomfort caused by moisture. Because the manufacturer has invested in creating a premium bedding brand for babies and parents all over the world, this cover comes with a gift: a protective pillow cover for your baby made from organic cotton. Don’t you just love organic baby products?

Pros

  • Features a cotton top with a waterproof film.
  • The quilted cotton top allows good airflow for maximum breathability.
  • The cover is quiet and won’t make any noise as your baby moves while sleeping.
  • Hypoallergenic product protects children from bed bugs and dust mites.
  • Can be washed and dries in the machine.

Cons

  • Zipper can’t be tucked in the encasement.

5. Baby and Brooke Organic Crib Mattress Cover Pad

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 8 inches
  • Weight: 15 ounces
  • Sold as: a single unit

Taking things up a notch, we’d like to introduce the Baby and Brooke Organic crib mattress cover, which costs more than what you’d usually spend on a product of this kind, so we wanted to see if the price is really justified. We’re really impressed with the organic bamboo cover that’s extremely soft to the touch and provides a pleasant surface for the baby to rest upon. Another impressive feature is the lifetime guarantee that comes with this mattress cover. The manufacturer promises a full refund in the event that the cover ever leaks any liquids. We’d like to give kudos to Baby and Brooke because if this isn’t standing by your product, I don’t know what is. As expected, the organic cover is also hypoallergenic and breathable, so it can absorb moistly and maintain your baby’s temperature at optimal levels when sleeping. It does n’t use any plastic or other materials that are harmful to kids.

Pros

  • Is made from organic bamboo, being both safe and pleasant to the touch.
  • Since it doesn’t use any chemicals in its construction, it doesn’t emit chemical odors either.
  • Doesn’t make any noises when the child moves in his sleep.
  • Is waterproof.
  • Responsive and polite customer service.
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty against wet accidents.

Cons

  • Takes a long time to air dry.
  • Doesn’t include any padding.

Buy Now

6. MILLIARD Crib & Toddler Mattress Protector Cover

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 28 x 52 x 6 inches
  • Weight: 15.2 ounces
  • Sold as: a single unit

MILLIARD-Crib-Toddler-Mattress-Protector-Cover-1.jpg

Here is yet another mattress cover that can protect the baby against dust mites, mold spores, bacteria, allergens or pollen. We love how these companies are all stepping up their game and making sure they invest in developing child-safe products that have the best interest of your baby in mind. The Millard cover provides a great combination of cushioning, comfort, breathability, and waterproofness to ensure the proper environment for your baby. The top of the cover combines hypoallergenic materials that blend with the polyester fiberfill to acts as a barrier against dangerous contaminants that could find their way to the baby’s mattress. The cover is ventilated enough to regulate the baby’s body temperature for the best night’s sleep possible. It can be easily cleaned inside the washing machine and can fit mattresses up to 14 inches.

Pros

  • Provides waterproof protection.
  • Cover allows airflow to pass through, so your baby can sleep dry through any season.
  • Acts as a barrier against the most common contaminants.
  • Can easily be cleaned inside the washing machine.

Cons

  • Cover is advertised as being thicker and with more padding that it actually has.

Buy Now

7. Crib Mattress Protector Cover by Margaux & May

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 9 inches
  • Weight: 12.8 ounces
  • Sold as: a single unit

One thing that stood out from all the messages that the manufacturer was trying to send is that the quilted terry cloth top feels so comfortable that you’ll want to use it without a protective sheet. We always like to see brands that are very confident in the products they create (as long as it doesn’t lead to false advertising). Another thing that caught our attention is the fact that this cover produces virtually no noise that could eventually wake up the baby during his sleep. The waterproof cover also ensures breathability, as this is important with babies that need to have constant body temperatures when they sleep. The cover is also easy to clean in the washing machine, as long as you’re careful with the drying process (exposing the cover to high temperatures could damage the waterproof film).

Pros

  • Doesn’t make almost any noise when the baby turns in his sleep.
  • Is waterproof and breathable.
  • Doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals like lead or BPA.
  • Can be washed in the machine.
  • Made with high-quality bamboo rayon.

Cons

  • Waterproof layer can shrink if dried in hot temperatures.

Buy Now

Conclusion

By now, you already have a list of priorities in mind and know exactly what you want from your future crib mattress cover. The most important things are waterproofness and lifespan. During their early years, babies will wet the bed a lot (and not just with pee, but also with drool and sweat and other gooey things that come out of these precious little orifices). This means that a cover that can withstand hundreds of washes and dries without shrinking or deteriorating is a good investment. If the cover you’re planning to purchase isn’t waterproof, the mattress pad underneath has to be. But we don’t actually recommend looking into covers that are not waterproof, because that increases the odds of staining the mattress which, in turn, can lead to several other problems on the long run (like the apparition of mold or a bad smell).

With these two important features in mind, you can start considering what other things you want in a crib mattress pad. Do you want it to have filling/padding so that it can have extra cushioning? Are you interested in a product with many years of warranty? Or are you just looking to buy something cheap, regardless of how often you might need to replace it?