Mattress Protectors Buyers Guide and Our Top Choices

Slumber Cloud sent us the Core mattress protector and it may not be the most cost effective solution to outfitting your mattress with a protective cover, but it’s by far the highest quality among those I’ve tested – and totally worth the added expense. It’s thicker and more comfortable than the average mattress protector, but it also incorporates Outlast technology, which really does keep you cooler during the night. It actually helped prevent sweating (I tested it during a hot summer) and aided in keeping me fast asleep.

Liquid spilled on the mattress cover did not soak in right away, but then, the cover is quite thick and still kept the juice in place (so there was no draining or penetration through to the mattress).

The material – lycra and polyester – makes the Slumber Cloud Core soft and thick, and I found it to be extremely comfortable. I would not recommend using it for a mattress thicker than 16 inches, but otherwise it’s a great fit and comes in a wide variety of sizes. My mattress with its topper is 14 inches thick, and it was snug enough not to have to worry about shifting and making noise. Yes, this is a noiseless product, too! Overall, I’d have to say I was extremely impressed with this mattress protector.

Perhaps the first thing I found exciting about the Saferest Premium Mattress Protector was the 10-year full replacement warranty, which let me know the company was confident enough in the product to ensure great performance. On top of that, I instantly found that the cotton terry material that topped the protector was comfortable and aided in keeping the waterproof layer beneath from crinkling and awakening you with noise during the night as you shift in your sleep. To make this even better, the cotton terry material is hypoallergenic.

To test the waterproof layer – since this is the essence of what a mattress protector should prevent from reaching your mattress – I poured a cup of liquid on the Saferest mattress protector. I noticed instantly that it didn’t seep into the cover but spread and remained atop the protector. I thought that it might run down the sides, but it seemed to pocket the liquid on top, holding it in a reasonably small area and waiting for me to clean it off. This remained the case after several hours.

Maybe the only thing that wasn’t top notch about the Saferest was that, though the cotton layer on top is breathable and allows for airflow, this particular product slept a little too hot. While this is typical of many mattress covers due to the waterproof layer, I’ve had better (and worse) experiences. The slight overheating is tolerable, and with the many other benefits, I can’t complain too much.

Other great things about this mattress protector include the range of sizes, lack of odor, and the material being lightweight. It’s machine washable, and you can tumble dry (always on a low heat setting, though).

If you sleep hot or have issues with night sweats due to a condition you suffer or a medication you take, this mattress protector is likely not for you. I wouldn’t recommend it, simply because it won’t assist you in keeping your sleep environment cool and dry, which is essential to a good night’s rest. For anyone else, the heat retention shouldn’t be a problem.

Lucid is no stranger to the bedding material market, and that gave me a confident feeling when I received this mattress protector for testing. Even more exciting was the 15 year warranty they offer, since this is definitely above and beyond the norm for mattress protectors.

Most important for mattress covers is to prove their waterproof capabilities, so I always perform an 8 hour test, checking back periodically after spilling juice on the mattress protector (this helps to gauge retention of odor and stains, as well as liquid penetration). With this Lucid mattress protector, I found not a single damp spot on the towel I placed beneath the mattress cover, which was quite impressive.

Another great feature is that it’s completely hypoallergenic, which will help you rest easier whether you have allergies or not. The terry cotton material is comfortable for sleeping and negates the nasty crinkling sounds that come with plastic mattress protectors. If you aren’t completely satisfied, Lucid allows full returns within 120 days, and you can be sure they’ll back their 15 year warranty in full. Just be sure to take proper care of the mattress protector, laundering on medium heat (or cooler) and tumbling dry on low heat to avoid damage to the waterproof material.

If you invest in a good mattress protector, you’ll find that the technology doesn’t just keep liquids from seeping through to the mattress. It also incorporates a technology that pulls moisture away from your body. Perhaps this is one of two small complaints with the Linenspa premium mattress protector, which otherwise receives incredibly high ratings based on my trial. First of all, this product is very soft and thin, and it feels much like a standard bed sheet. However, it’s 100% waterproof, as proven by my typical spill test. It doesn’t retain odor from the spill, either, and though I didn’t let the juice continue to set after the 8 hour test, the color came right out when I washed the protector.

The thin cotton cover and the under-layer of polyurethane work well together to create a nice fit for your mattress, utilizing elastic siding to make sure you get a tight fit. In comparison to other protectors, the Linenspa is quite thin, but it’s still completely waterproof. The Linenspa mattress protector comes with a 10 year warranty to support you if you do find any issues. Overall, I feel that this protector is among the best currently on the market for its value.

I’ve included the Luna premium hypoallergenic mattress protector among the ranks of the top products because it’s great value, comes in a number of sizes and has an excellent 15 year warranty that the manufacturer fully backs. When it comes to sleep products, Luna has a great reputation, and this mattress protector hits the mark to keep that reputation intact.

When it comes to protection, the Luna premium hypoallergenic mattress protector worked wonders, not only proving it was completely waterproof during my typical spill test but also showing the ability to draw in the moisture and move it away from the surface so that there was no concern that I would be sleeping in puddles of sweat during the night. One thing to keep in mind is that the solidity of its waterproofing does lead to a hotter sleep environment, though it’s a moderate change.

This particular mattress protector has a terry cotton top and a waterproof membrane underneath, and it is completely hypoallergenic, and it is textured for a great sleep. I found it very comfortable, with the exception of the slight plastic sound on occasion when I shifted. With the performance, there’s really not much to complain about, especially since the elastic corners made it fit my mattress with no slipping and shifting during the night.

The Bear Mattress Protector is a high quality waterproof covering for your precious mattress. This guarantees that no water or moisture can get onto your bed. The protector is five-sided, breathable, and has a soft top that absorbs spills and moisture.

It has HeiQ fabric technology that helps to transport moisture and heat away from the body and protects from dust mites, bacteria and other nasty allergens. It has a 100% waterproof barrier that protects your bed from stains and liquid damage and comes with a generous 10 year warranty. It’s also created to work with Celliant technology and the Bear Mattress.

This cover may be best suited for those who have incontinence, pets, toddlers that frequently sleep in your bed, or if you sweat a lot in your sleep.

Mattress protectors weren’t always a must-have item, but only because they used to be so inconvenient. The Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector has removed most of the negative issues that people have with mattress protectors. There won’t any loud crinkly noises when you move in bed. Plus, this mattress cover shouldn’t create or trap heat when you sleep on it. In fact, the material is actually cool to the touch.

Best of all, the Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector does precisely what it’s meant to do: protect your mattress. The waterproof materials work well to keep your bed dry, free of stains, and it prevents odors from getting into the fabric of your mattress.

If you have a tall plush bed, you’ll appreciate the deep pockets of this mattress protector because you won’t struggle to get it on your bed. However, the pockets may be too deep, which could present an issue with slippage. If it does, you can add bed garters to help keep it in place.