Purchasing a mattress is harder than it looks. There is a multitude of factors that you must consider since it’s a long-term investment, and one that would have a direct impact on the quality of your life. The research process therefore requires careful planning and narrowing down on the basis of a stringent criteria.
In the (now) densely populated landscape of the mattress industry, Simmons has developed an iconic reputation for itself. With a history that goes back 140 years, the manufacturer has strived for excellence and delivered best-in-class innovative features over-time.
Simmons has a number of products for its customers, however its two major offerings are the Beautysleep and the Beautyrest mattress lines. Each line offers a wide variation in attributes and is designed to cater specific customer preferences. If you’re going for a Simmons mattress and can’t decide which way to go, the following Simmons Beautysleep vs Beautyrest comparison would help clear things up.
Beautysleep vs. Beautyrest Comparison
Before we move ahead with a head-to-head comparison, here’s a brief summary for both Beautysleep and Beautyrest mattresses to bring clarity regarding each offering.
Beautysleep
This is Simmons’ entry-level mattress lineup. Beautysleep mattresses are available in a wide variety of firmness and sizes. While they won’t have most of the advanced build features of the Beautyrest line, they still offer great value, perfect as a secondary mattress for the guest room.
Beautyrest Silver
The series gets its name from the silver-infused fiber in the top layer that increases dissipation of heat, moisture and prevents bacterial outbreak.
This is the most affordable mattress of the Beautyrest series. This makes it ideal for people who wish to enjoy a luxurious mattress, but don’t want to exceed their budgets. Beautyrest Silver is composed of multiple layers of polyurethane and proprietary foams, providing pressure relief, heat exchange and contouring. Additional pocketed coils in the center-third provide enhanced lumbar support.
Beautyrest Platinum
Beautyrest Platinum was introduced in 2017 and strikes a balance between the Silver and the more-expensive luxury line. The comfort layers of the mattresses have additional cooling materials to maintain a cooler temperature while providing greater pressure point relief.
Hundreds of pocketed coils in the base and the foam layers on top result in greater response to your body’s shape as you sleep. There is also a “Platinum Hybrid” subseries that sports an added layer of latex and a PlatinumICE™ cooling mechanism.
Beautyrest Black
This is the premium-most series of mattresses offered by Simmons. With features like triple stranded Advanced Pocketed Coil ® technology, Micro Diamond ™ and BlackICE ™ memory foams, the mattresses offer high-end comfort, contouring soft support and excellent thermal regulation.
Beautysleep Breakdown
The Beautysleep series may be Simmons’ entry-level line of mattresses but this doesn’t mean it is completely irrelevant in the sleep industry.
Basic Construction
The mattress is primarily made from foam, covering 5 – 5.5” depending on the size chosen. On select models, Simmons Beautysleep mattresses are lined with a layer of GelTouch foam that provides extra comfort. The foam brings softness to the overall build of the mattress.
In addition, there is also a layer of AirCool Memory Foam on limited layers, which provides pressure relief and greater freedom of movement. The purpose of this foam is to let the mattress adapt according to the contour of the body, along with adding to its breathability.
Firmness and Feel
Beautysleep mattresses are available in the following support levels:
- Plush
- Plush pillow top
- Firm
- Luxury firm
- Luxury firm pillow top
Edge Support System
Beautysleep has a Foam-encased Edge-Support System that maximizes sleeping surface area and provides a supportive seating edge. This lowers the risk of fall if/when you move over to the edge of the bed during sleep.
Motion Separation
The mattresses are embedded with independently wrapped coils that bring long-lasting support and adjust according to the contour of the body. The level of motion separation won’t be as much as Beautyrest, and there have been reports of inadequate levels of motion, i.e. you’ll feel your partner move more.
Cooling
SurfaceCool ®
Right beneath the cover fabric of the mattress is the SurfaceCool Plus Fiber that has been developed after years of research by Simmons, held as a proprietary technology. It allows the mattress to boost heat dissipation, transferring heat sideways or to the lower layers where further dissipation removes it completely.
AirFeel ™ foam
This is a soft, high-quality layer of foam that promotes airflow and adds to the durability of the mattress. The feature works in conjunction with SurfaceCool ® to lower the temperature of the mattress, bringing serenity to one’s sleep.
Warranty
Depending on the price of the exact product you choose, a Beautysleep mattress can have a non-prorated warranty period from 3 to 10 years.
Beautyrest Breakdown
Simmons’ luxury lineup, Beautyrest mattresses are well-known as a luxury product, with over 100 million sold globally. Due to the high build quality and advanced features of the mattress, they are often found in many of the world’s top hotel chains.
Basic Construction
Both Beautysleep and Beautyrest models are infused with proprietary foams to bring softness, comfort and conformity to the mattress. However, the types of foams used within Beautyrest mattresses are much superior to those present in Beautysleep, quantitively and qualitatively.
AirCool™ Memory Foam
In each of the three categories (Silver, Platinum & Black) of the Beautyrest mattress line is a layer of AirCool foam. The prime function of AirCool foam is to adapt according to the contours of the body. The pricier models within the Beautyrest mattress line offer AirCool Gel and AirCool Max variants that add towards the breathability and thermal dissipation of the mattress.
Dynamic Response Memory Foam
Above the layer of AirCool foam is a layer of Dynamic Response Memory Foam, which adds to the softness of the mattress and enhances its responsiveness.
DualCool Technology Memory Foam
Exclusively present in Silver models, the DualCool Foam makes use of the heat conduction properties of natural silver to keep your bed cool. Furthermore, the silver infused foam also prevents any bacterial buildup, keeping the mattress hygienic for years.
PlatinumICE Memory Foam
The material is unique to Platinum series of mattresses and is found in the top-most layer, keeping the temperature of the surface to a minimal value.
Micro Diamond Memory Foam
This high-end memory foam is present only in the Black lineup, and brings comfort with the combination of viscoelastic and millions of microscopic diamond crystals that possess amazing cooling properties.
BlackICE™ Memory Foam
Once again, a premium feature, limited to the Black series, BlackICE Foam is a fusion of micro diamond foam with a breathable gel that allow optimum temperature to be maintained during sleep.
Firmness and Feel
Beautyrest mattresses are available in the following support levels:
- Plush
- Plush pillow top
- Luxury Firm Pillow Top
- Firm
- Luxury Firm
- Extra Firm
Energy Foam
A layer of polyurethane foam acts as a deep support mechanism for the body, working in conjunction with the innerspring layers to bring stability to the body’s posture. The layer sits between the plush viscoelastic upper layers and the tough steel coils below, adding to the overall durability of the mattress in the face of extreme dynamic loads.
Pocketed Coil
The Pocketed Coil system was developed in-house by Simmons and offers personalized support to the body without impacting the neighboring regions. The steel coils are available in different variations so that optimized firmness can be achieved based on personal preferences.
Advanced Pocketed Coil
The technology is built on top of the Pocketed Coil system, adding conformity and motion isolation to the mattress. The addition of these coils has potential pain relief benefits that last for an extended period of time due to the greater durability of the mattress.
Edge Support
The Ventilated AirCool Beauty Edge is responsible for edge support in the mattress, stabilizing your body as load is applied on the edges. This eliminates the sinking concern completely. In addition, holes along the sides allow air to pass to the surroundings, keeping the mattress at a stable temperature.
Cooling
Almost every layer of foam that makes the mattress is enhanced by some sort of cooling mechanism. First, the SurfaceCool fiber acts as the first layer of dissipation, maintaining the surface level temperature. The AirCool BeautyEdge boundary has small holes in it primarily to improve ventilation and preventing temperature buildup.
In addition, DualCool technology’s silver crystals and BlackICE’s diamond crystals, each supplement the overall heat dissipation of the mattress. Due to the absence of a multitude of layers and more-expensive features, the Beautyrest line is more superior to the Beautysleep lineup in terms of cooling.
Warranty
The Beautyrest product line sports a 10-year limited warranty period, something that may be a turn-off, especially when several mattress brands offer lifetime warranty at a much lower cost. Since Simmons mattresses are sold via retailers and not by the company itself, there are no money back guarantees or trial periods in place.
For a first-time buyer, this may seem like a steep condition, but it must also be understood that Simmons has established itself as a key market player over decades and wouldn’t have a reputation that it enjoys today if it was for sub-standard products.
SmartMotion Technology
Simmons’ SmartMotion Bases allow the mattresses’ bed profile to be adjusted to match your activity’s requirement, e.g. reading, watching TV, sleeping, etc. To promote healthy sleep, Beautyrest mattresses also come with a massager along with a smartphone app to monitor the quality of your sleep.
Environment Friendliness
Both Beautysleep and Beautyrest range of mattresses are certified as CertiPUR-US® Certified, i.e. free from harmful chemicals such as heavy metals, flame retardants, formaldehyde, etc. This means that your health, and that of your family, is never at stake whilst sleeping on a Beautyrest mattress.
Off gassing
Customers often complain of a chemical smell in a newly purchased mattress, which comes as a result of the manufacturing process. This isn’t the case with Simmons and virtually no odor has been reported from both Beautyrest and Beautysleep mattresses. This makes the entire experience of owning a Simmons mattress much more pleasant.
Which One to Get?
Beautysleep
First and foremost, Beautysleep mattresses are extremely affordable, being Simmons’ entry-level lineup. Unlike Beautyrest’s pocketed coil design, Beautysleep has an innerspring system which makes its production much more cost-effective.
While the mattresses aren’t as high-end or durable as those belonging to the Beautyrest series, they still hold a decent level of quality and will provide a comfortable nights’ sleep to a budget-bound sleeper who’s had a long day.
Moreover, if you’re going for a mattress that would only be used from time to time, e.g. guest room, backup, etc. then a Beautysleep mattress is the way to go. This, in particular, applies to owners of motels who want a quality mattress for their upscale bedrooms.
Beautyrest
Beautyrest mattresses are Simmons’ flagship product. With luxurious fabrics, multi-layered padding and enhanced cooling mechanisms, Beautyrest mattresses are highly-recommended for someone who values their sleep above all else. The patented pocketed coil technology cushioned in fabric wrap means each spring moves individually, providing a level of contouring the Beautysleep line can’t achieve.
The greater comfort and durability are supplemented by features such as SmartMotion Technology that makes for precisely targeted support, pressure relief and adaptability. For someone who wants a potent amalgamation of sleep quality, luxury, and brand recognition, a Beautyrest mattress is the better choice.
I hope you found the comparison helpful. In case you have any queries, feel free to leave your comments in the section below. Plus, don’t forget to share the posts, so others may benefit from it as well!
| Beauty Sleep | Beautyrest Silver |
Beautyrest Platinum | Beautyrest Black |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Layers Used |
|
|
|
|
| Thickness | 6 – 12.5 inches | 11.5 – 15.5 inches | 12.5 – 16 inches | 12.5 – 18.5 inches |
| Firmness | Medium-Firm | Mostly medium – firm | Soft-firm | Soft-firm |
| Support | Pocket coil (700) or open coil | Pocket coil (800 – 850) | Pocket coil (1000) | Advanced pocket coil (850+) |
| Warranty | 3-10 years non-prorated | 10 years non-prorated | 10 years non-prorated | 10 years non-prorated |
| Pricing | $400 – $930 | $670 – $1800 | $1350 – $1800 | $2000 – $5100 |