Menu

Welcome to the redesigned SleepJudge! Click here to send us feedback

The Best Throw Pillow Reviews

Updated July 17, 2019

Rank Products Highlights
#1

Pillow Perfect Outdoor Full Bloom Throw Pillow

Buy Now

  • Available in 20 different color combinations and patterns.
  • Piping trimming matches the rest of the pillow.
  • Easily match any type of patio or outdoor furniture.
#2

Cheer Collection Throw Pillows

Buy Now

  • Available in both rectangular and square shapes.
  • You can opt for one of the 9 different colors.
  • They can be cleaned in the washing machine.
  • Faux fur is very soft to the touch.
#3

DEMDACO Decorative Throw Pillow

Buy Now

  • Comes in a beautiful gifting package.
  • Combination of materials creates a pillow that’s soft to the touch.
  • Is heart-shaped (!)
  • All 3 available colors are soft and pleasant.
#4

MoonRest Microfiber Decorative Pillow

Buy Now

  • Faux suede is very pleasant to the touch.
  • Generous color range, suitable for most living room chromatic combinations.
#5

Brentwood Pillow

Buy Now

  • Beautiful and vivid colors.
  • Suitable for living rooms, bedrooms and children’s rooms.
  • Cover feels very soft to the touch.
#6

Cheer Collection Round Donut Pillow

Buy Now

  • Available in 3 different patterns: simple pink frosting, pink frosting with sprinkles and chocolate frosting.
  • Each pattern is reversible, so every pillow is actually a 2-in-1.
  • Ideal for kid’s bedroom and playrooms.
  • Very comfortable to hug/lean against.
#7

Brielle Cozy Cable Knit Throw Pillow
OVERVIEW

Buy Now

  • Cable-knit pillow, reminiscent of childhood Christmases.
  • Suitable for people who love a traditional décor.
  • Cover is pleasant and soft to the touch.

If you are the least bit passionate about interior decorations, then you know how essential a throw pillow is and how it can embellish the coziness of your home. In fact, there is such a thing as a throw pillow addiction, as the minute you see a gorgeous one, you just have to have it. How comfortable is it when you get home after a long day’s work and just throw yourself on the couch, surrounded by these fluffy accessories? Today, we’re going to go over some of the most awesome throw pillows money can buy, but not before we go over the essential factors that can make or break the pillow deal.

Things to Consider

Throw pillows are a decorative item, which means that the design, colors, shape and size are all determining factors that should be analyzed before making a purchasing decision. So, let’s talk about each and every one of them.

Color

A general rule of thumb states that your throw pillows should match the color of the bed or sofa or chair upon which it will rest. You have two options: you can either make the colors blend or choose colors that will make either the pillow or the furniture stand out. In other words, you can match colors or buy pillows in a completely different color.

Shape

There are 5 main shapes as far as throw pillows are concerned:

  • Square is the most common shape, mainly because it fits on just about every piece of furniture.
  • Box pillows are deeper than other types and they are generally used because they add dimension to space.
  • Round pillows aren’t that common, because they’re not exactly compatible with any type of furniture. They could work on chairs with rounded backrests, but they limit your placement options quite a lot.
  • Rectangle pillows are almost as popular as a square pillow, especially when used at the center of a sofa or a bed.
  • Bolster pillows are normally used as armrests at the ends of sofas and are characterized by their long, rounded shape. They are no longer as popular as they used to be, because of their outdated look.

Trim

A fancy border can make a throw pillow look better, there’s no doubt about it. But you need to choose the trim carefully because inserting a fringed pillow into a simple room décor might be a deal breaker. However, trim is still a great way to embellish a pillow and turn it from plain to awesome.

Piping is the most common trim and due to its simplicity, it should be able to easily fit into just about any room décor. The key thing to remember is to make sure that the piping fabric is identical to the rest of the pillow if you want to go for the classic look.

Alternatively, you can opt for rope trim, which is pretty similar to piping, except that it makes the pillow look more traditional because it has more depth. Some people are fans of decorative trims that can include anything from pom poms to tassels, and even fringe. But choosing such a trim is highly dependent on how the room is set up. If you’ve opted for modern furniture, these decorative won’t do the trick. They are rather more suitable in bohemian or country-style rooms.

Size

Throwing a small pillow in the middle of a large sofa simply won’t do the trick. It’s important that the pillows you choose are proportionate to the size of the furniture upon which they are placed. The main role of a throw pillow is to enhance the overall look of a particular room, which means that it should be a good fit.

She’s Got the Look

The perfect combination between throw pillows and your room isn’t that hard to find. But if you have no idea where to start, we’re going to give you some pretty neat pointers:

For those of you who won’t go for a more modern look, we recommend choosing an odd number of pillows. You should also consider choosing a lower number of bigger pillows rather than a high number of small ones. As far as dimensions are concerned, anything in between 18 and 24 inches should do the trick. You can opt for solid colors or a pattern. Modern bedrooms and living rooms should have throw pillows made from fabric such as linen or cotton.

  • Traditionalists can buy 2 or 4 large pillows to place on either side of the couch, to create a sense of symmetry. As for the size, it really depends on how big your sofa is. Pillows in between 20 and 22 inches work just fine. If it’s a classic look you’re going for, buy pillows that are made from silk or velvet, maybe something with floral patterns. Don’t be afraid to pair up simple and generous patterns. As for the trim, tassels will create a stunning traditional look.
  • Do you want your room to feel more eclectic? Then you need to go with asymmetry and that means that you need an odd number of pillows. Randomness is the keyword here. However, don’t be random when it comes to the fabric: you can have each pillow in a different fabric, but at least try to match one of the colors, as not to give the impression that you threw just any pillow on the sofa. The trim should be simple and the pillows should be big: anything from 18 to 24 inches should suffice.
  • Inserts are also important, as they contribute to the lifespan and the comfort given by your throw pillow. Polyester inserts are quite common, as they keep your pillows fluffy and in good shape. However, they are not exactly something you want to cuddle with. If you’re looking for something that falls and the plushier side and is more comfortable to hug, feather or down filling is a much more suitable choice. And since they are better and comfier, they are also more expensive. But if you’re not the kind of person that likes to cuddle with throw pillow while binging on Netflix series, it’s totally fine to go with cheaper options.

Top 7 Best Throw Pillow Reviews

1. Pillow Perfect Outdoor Full Bloom Throw Pillow

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 18.5 x 5 x 11.5 inches
  • Weight: 1.9 pounds
  • Shape: rectangular
  • Sold as a set of 2 pillows

If you want to add a touch of color to your living room or bedroom, this 2 pillow set sold by Pillow Perfect is ideal. Since they are made from polyester fabric that’s resistant to sunlight (meaning that the colors won’t easily fade away), they also make for a great patio furniture decoration. You have 20 different color combinations and patterns to choose from: Annie Chocolate, Black/Beige, Brown/Green Tropical, Burnt Orange, Carmody Navy, Fairington Aqua, Geo Red, Green/Brown, Hockey Teal, Modern Flora, Omnia Lagoon, Orange, Pom Pom Play Peachtini, Primro Orange, Solid Red, Red/Brown Floral/Striped, Splish Splash Blue, Tamara Paisley and Turquoise. The edges of the pillow are trimmed with fabric that matches the rest of the pillow. Inside, you will find a plush filling that makes the pillow comfortable enough to rest your back upon.

Pros

  • Available in 20 different color combinations and patterns.
  • Piping trimming matches the rest of the pillow.
  • Easily match any type of patio or outdoor furniture.

Cons

  • Colors are not that resistant and easily fade away.

2. Cheer Collection Throw Pillows

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 18 x 18 x 5 inches
  • Weight: 2 pounds
  • Shape: square
  • Sold as a set of 2 pillows

If it’s faux fur pillows you’re interested in, this affordable set of 2 pillows provided by Cheer Collection might please you. You can opt for the square pillows, that measure 18 by 18 inches, but there are also rectangular ones, measuring 12 x 20 inches. The pillows are available in Black, White, Blue, Grey, Chocolate, Maroon, Purple, Sand, and Rust. Since they are reversible, one side is a soft faux fur while the other features micro plush. Inside the pillows you’ll find a plush fiber filling, making these pillows comfortable both inside and out.

Pros

  • Available in both rectangular and square shapes.
  • You can opt for one of the 9 different colors.
  • They can be cleaned in the washing machine.
  • Faux fur is very soft to the touch.

Cons

  • Pillow runs a bit flat so may need extra stuffing.
  • They lose texture and shape in time if you sit against them.

3. DEMDACO Decorative Throw Pillow

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 10.3 x 10.4 x 2.6 inches
  • Weight: 2.27 pounds
  • Shape: heart
  • Sold as a single unit

Whether you purchase this beauty as a gift or want to decorate your home with this absolutely lovely heart throw pillow, you have to give kudos to Demdaco for creating this gem. It doesn’t matter if you go for the pink, cream or grey model, because all these 3 shades are soft and pleasant to the eye. We do feel that this makes for a perfect holiday gift, that comes packed in a sweet little gift box. Made from a combination of cotton, acrylic, nylon, polyester and with a plastic filling, you shouldn’t doubt the softness of the pillow that was designed to replicate the warmth of a hug. What we love more than the product itself is the heart-warming presentation that convinced us to add the pillow to our holiday shopping list.

Pros

  • Comes in a beautiful gifting package.
  • Combination of materials creates a pillow that’s soft to the touch.
  • Is heart-shaped (!)
  • All 3 available colors are soft and pleasant.

Cons

  • Size is really small.

4. MoonRest Microfiber Decorative Pillow

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 22.2 x 16.3 x 6.9 inches
  • Weight: 1.35 pounds
  • Shape: square
  • Sold as a set of 2 pillows

For those of you looking for a simple, monochromatic and square throw pillow, the MoonRest set should be more than enough. Even if the standard size is 20 x 20 inches, you have smaller sizes to choose from, like the 16 x 16 or the 18 x 18-inch ones. The color palette is pretty generous, as you can opt between Sage, Wine, Navy, Burgundy, Camel, Chocolate, Royal Blue, Stone, Coffee, Olive, Cinnabar, Cool Black, Rust, and Shell. The inserts can easily be removed from the cover thanks to the conveniently hidden zipper. Covers are made from faux suede and are unbeatable considering their price.

Pros

  • Faux suede is very pleasant to the touch.
  • Generous color range, suitable for most living room chromatic combinations.

Cons

  • Inserts are not stuffed into the covers as shipped.
  • Colors may differ in reality (this is typically a monitor calibration problem).

5. Brentwood Pillow

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 18 x 18 inches
  • Weight: 15.8 ounces
  • Shape: square
  • Sold as a single unit

We fell in love with the fuzzy Brentwood pillow the minute we laid our eyes on it. Available in Black, Brown, Hot Pink, Lime, Orange, Purple, Red, and Turquoise, we couldn’t stop picturing these pillows resting on top of a children’s bed. The colors are amazingly vivid and we feel that shades of pink and lime would be perfect for a kid’s room. However, the more serious colors, like black or brown, should easily find their way on your living-room couch. This polyester pillow features a plush filling that’s so comfortable both inside and out, we’re pretty sure you won’t make just a single purchase. Maintenance is also pretty simple since the fabric requires spot cleaning with a damp cloth.

Pros

  • Beautiful and vivid colors.
  • Suitable for living rooms, bedrooms and children’s rooms.
  • Cover feels very soft to the touch.

Cons

  • Hard to clean.
  • Pillows flatten out over time

6. Cheer Collection Round Donut Pillow

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 16 x 16 x 4 inches
  • Weight: 1.37 pounds
  • Shape: round
  • Sold as a single unit

If you’re a fan of cute and colorful pillows, this one is a doozy. That pink donut with rainbow sprinkles… I’d be worried about my guests getting drunk and trying to eat it! This micro plush pillow is not just cute, but also extremely comfortable. It’s an absolute must in every child’s room, but also in a playful adult bedroom (because being an adult is sometimes too boring). The design is super realistic and if you ever get tired of the pink frosting with a sprinkler, the double-sided feature should get boredom out of the way.

Pros

  • Available in 3 different patterns: simple pink frosting, pink frosting with sprinkles and chocolate frosting.
  • Each pattern is reversible, so every pillow is actually a 2-in-1.
  • Ideal for kid’s bedroom and playrooms.
  • Very comfortable to hug/lean against.

Cons

  • Print quality not that good.

7. Brielle Cozy Cable Knit Throw Pillow

OVERVIEW

  • Dimensions: 18 x 18 x 2 inches
  • Weight: 1.4 pounds
  • Shape: square
  • Sold as a single unit

Traditionalists are going to fall in love with this acrylic cable knit pillow. We would have loved to see this model in a wider variety of colors, but we’re pretty OK with the ivory, red, light blue, gray and taupe nuances. This Brielle pillow is a combination of cable knit with a faux Sherpa back that has winter written all over it. It will remind you of those sweaters that your grandma used to knot for you when you were a kid. You hated them back then, but they now remind you of childhood: with hot cocoa and chocolate chip cookies around the fire.

Pros

  • Cable-knit pillow, reminiscent of childhood Christmases.
  • Suitable for people who love a traditional décor.
  • Cover is pleasant and soft to the touch.

Cons

  • Cable knit runs a bit thin.

Conclusion

There is no such thing as the perfect throw pillow because tastes, rooms, budgets; they’re all different. However, there are some stepping stones between you and finding the best pillow combination that will comfortably fall into the current décor of your home. Size is important when paired with that of your furniture. If your pillows are too big and your sofa is too small, you will literally have no room to sit down comfortably and your guests will be forced to hold the pillows on their laps to sit down. As for the colors and patterns, you can either opt for a color that matches the nuance of your furniture or you can go with something completely different, to create contrast.

Fill and inserts are important if you care a lot about comfort. If you want a squishier pillow, go for one that has feather-and-down fill. Alternatively, you can choose a pillow with synthetic fills that aren’t as soft, but they hold their shape longer. Don’t be afraid to experiment with adding mixed pillows into the scenery. You can easily combine a solid pillow with another one with a geometrical pattern. You can also experiment with pillows of different sizes. Add smaller ones at the edge of the sofa and one bigger one right in the center. On a general note, interior decorators recommend that you go with an odd number of pillows, depending on the size of your couch. Texture also has its importance, because it should match the upholstery of your sofas and chairs.