Best Pillow Top Mattress Pads

TheSleepJudge Editorial Team

Did you realize that we spend about one third of our life in bed, sleeping? Sleep is absolutely necessary and good sleep is where it’s at. Good sleep starts with the right mattress. However, you may want to protect that mattress from sweat and stains. You may also want to rejuvenate your existing mattress without purchasing a new one.

That’s where a mattress pad comes in. A mattress pad is the perfect option to protect, refresh, and rejuvenate your mattress. A mattress pad goes right on top of your mattress to add an extra layer of protection and softness.

We have compiled a list of the best pillow top mattress pads available online to help you narrow down your options.


EASELAND Pillow Top Mattress Cover


Best Seller

oaskys Cooling Mattress Topper


Cooling Option

LEISURE TOWN Mattress Pad Cover


Cooling and Supportive

TESIONE Extra Thick Mattress Pad Cover


Ultimate Thickness


Sleep Mantra Pillow Top Mattress Pad


Hotel Experience


COONP Extra Thick Mattress Pad Cover


Luxurious Comfort

Our Picks for the Best Pillow Top Mattress Pad

We have compiled a list of the six pillow top mattress pads that you can buy online. Read on to find the one that best suits your needs.

1. Best Seller – EASELAND Pillow Top Mattress Cover


  • Material: Cotton
  • Color: White 
  • Closure: Deep Pocket and Flexible Elastic Band
  • Size: Twin to California King

This best selling pillow top mattress cover provides a softness and smoothness thanks to the 32 ounces of down alternative microfiber fillings.  In addition to that, it will protect your mattress from dust, debris, and stains. If you value comfort and cleanliness, look no further than this option from EASELAND. 

Let’s talk about how soft and skin friendly this mattress topper is. It is 100% cotton and has a 300 thread count that will absorb sweat which makes it breathable. This is skin friendly which is great especially if you have skin sensitivities or share your bed with little ones. 

The alternative down fillings will not shift around in this mattress topper. It is designed with multiple square boxes which keep the pad fluffy in every single corner. You won’t be annoyed at this mattress pad moving all around your bed. It fits the bed in the same way as a fitted sheet and it has a lot of stretch.  It is designed with 130GSM single track elastic fabric that surrounds the mattress in a 360 degree angle to keep it in place. 

You can clean this right at home as it is machine washable, using the gentle cycle. 

  • Skin-friendly and noiseless. 
  • 100% cotton. 
  • Machine washable. 
  • Fits like a fitted sheet and stays in place. 
  • Highly breathable thanks to the high thread count. No more sweaty nights!
  • Some users stated that it is not as fluffy as stated. 
  • May not provide enough support for some.


2. Cooling Option – oaskys Cooling Mattress Topper


  • Material: Cotton
  • Color: White 
  • Closure: Elastic fabric pocket 
  • Size: Twin to California King

If you are sick and tired of sweating in your sleep, check out this cooling mattress topper from oaskys. You will feel like you are sleeping on a comfy, cool cloud. It is filled with 49 ounces of snow down alternative fill and a 300 thread count combed cotton surface. This has the feel of authentic goose and duck down, all without the feathers. 

This is also hypoallergenic, perfect for those that have allergies too. No more runny eyes or stuffy noses when you sleep. The filling will not move all around the pad as it is designed with square jacquards that keep the filling in place. The elastic fabric pocket makes it easy to put on your existing mattress. On the queen size, the deep pocket measures 1.18″  and fits a mattress up to 8″- 21″. 

This mattress pad comes in a vacuumed bag. The manufacturer recommends spreading it out for a few days before use so that it can return to the normal thickness. The cover is made out of 100% cotton and any spills can be quickly wiped away. It is also machine washable and tumble dry on low.

  • Hypoallergenic for people with allergies. 
  • Cooling mattress pad to avoid those sweaty nights. 
  • Machine washable for easy maintenance. 
  • Deep pockets that keep the pad on your bed without moving around.
  • Some stated that this mattress topper is too thin.


3. Cooling and Supportive –  LEISURE TOWN Mattress Pad Cover


  • Material: Cotton
  • Color: White 
  • Closure: Elastic Gusset
  • Size: Twin to California King

The last thing you want is to wake up feeling sweaty. This mattress pad from LEISURE TOWN is crafted with HNN cooling technology. This technology increases the air flow which makes the mattress pad more breathable and comfortable. 

The pad is made out of 300 thread count and is 100% cotton which gives it a soft, cloud-like feel. Snow Down Alternative Fill is a state-of-the-art fiberfill that has the feel of authentic goose and duck down minus the mess and poking that comes with real feathers. It has overfilled filling that feels much thicker when compared to other mattress pads. 

A plush mattress topper is a great way to minimize the wear and tear on your mattress as it acts as a barrier between your body and the mattresses surface.

The pillow top quilting seam is more supportive and soft, keeping the filling in its place. Plus, the fabric sides have a lot of stretch to fit mattresses up to 21 inches thick. No matter how much you twist and turn at night, this pad will stay in place. 

It is super easy to clean too as it’s machine washable. If you have a small spill, it can be wiped quickly due to the thickness. If it’s less than 200ml, it will not soak the mattress underneath. It comes packaged in a vacuum bag, so be sure to wash and dry it or spread the pad out for a few days before using it. This will allow it to return to the normal thickness.

  • HNN cooling technology to reduce sweating. 
  • Easy to clean in the washer. 
  • Stretchy sides that will fit your mattress without sliding off.
  • The pad is not very thick after using it once or twice. 
  • Others stated that it feels hot.


4. Ultimate Thickness – TESIONE Extra Thick Mattress Pad Cover


  • Material: Cotton
  • Color: White 
  • Closure: Pull On
  • Size: Twin to California King

If you want an extra thick pillow top mattress pad, check out this cover from TESIONE. The thickness has been upgraded using their innovative “double border pillow top construction” technology. This not only gives you an amazing sleep experience but it also prevents the filling from moving or leaking out. This mattress topper is overstuffed with 100% more filling than other pads on the market. Your existing mattress will feel brand new again and you will wake up feeling energized and refreshed!

It is made out of a breathable and soft 400 thread count cotton. This cotton surface helps the pad stay breathable, cool, and comfortable so you can enjoy a restful sleep. You don’t have to worry about waking up in a hot sweat. 

The fabric sides will easily stretch to fit any mattress from a twin all the way up to a California King. Just be sure to select the correct mattress size when you place your order. No matter how much you toss and turn in your sleep, this mattress pad will stay in place. 

This is super easy to take care of. Simply toss it into the washer and then dry using a low temperature. After washing, it will look brand new and return to its normal thickness. This mattress pad is designed to not shrink, pill, or fade over time.

  • Extra thick and upgraded filling. 
  • Breathable and super soft.
  • Machine washable.
This option may be a bit pricey for some.


5. Hotel Experience – Sleep Mantra Pillow Top Mattress Pad


  • Material: 100% Cotton Sateen
  • Color: White 
  • Closure: Zipper
  • Size: Twin to California King

Enjoy a luxurious hotel-like experience with this pillow top mattress pad from Sleep Mantra. This one’s for you if you want the best of the best comfort and optimum thickness that will leave you feeling relaxed and rejuvenated. 

This mattress pad is filled with a down-like alternative fill that makes your bed feel soft and bouncy. The top is pure cotton and is completely noiseless. Enjoy a 300 thread count, 100% all natural cotton material for extra breathability and a natural cooling element no matter the season. It has just the right amount of thickness to help support and prevent back aches. You also won’t wake up with all of your bedding bunched up because it slipped off in the night while you were moving in the bed. It has a deep pocket which will give your bed the perfect fit. The double walled gusseted construction and piped edges stay put and fits tight around your mattress. 

Not only does it feel like a luxurious hotel experience but it is stain and water resistant too. The toppers will protect your mattress against spills and stains. If you spill any fluid, it can easily be wiped away so that it doesn’t soak the mattress. Plus, it is machine washable and can be tumble dried. You can sleep well at night knowing this mattress pad is certified Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX® which means it is tested to be safe from 300+ harmful chemicals. It also comes with a 10 year limited product warranty.

  • Optimum thickness for a luxurious hotel-like experience. 
  • Fitted style with a deep pocket to prevent slipping. 
  • Stain and water resistant.
  • Some stated that it flattens too easily.


6. Luxurious Comfort – COONP Extra Thick Mattress Pad Cover


  • Material: 100% Cotton 
  • Color: White 
  • Closure: Elastic Deep Pocket
  • Size: Twin to California King

COONP has designed their extra thick mattress pad to be the ultimate in luxury. You will drift off to a much deeper sleep on this overfilled topper. It is filled with a supportive 3D snow down alternative fill that distributes your weight evenly to alleviate pressure. If you’re ready to wake up without back pain, keep on reading. 

The top surface is constructed from 400 thread count and it is cool and breathable. It will wick away sweat to keep you cool and dry. 

The elastic deep pocket wraps around your mattress tightly to prevent it from slipping off. It works just like a fitted sheet so that it will stay in place no matter how much you toss and turn.

To clean, just toss in the washer. After drying it comes out fluffy and clean.

  • Extra thick and luxurious. 
  • Deep elastic pocket to wrap around your mattress. 
  • 400 thread count.
  • May not be as thick as the reviews state. 
  • Might be hard to fluff up.


What To Look For in a Pillow Top Mattress Pad

A pillow top mattress pad is used to add a layer of protection, softness, and added comfort to your existing mattress. Think of it as a way to refresh your old mattress without having to purchase a new one. 

As you shop around for a new mattress pad, there are some things to keep in mind. 

What material is it made out of?

Most mattress pads are made out of cotton. However, you will see options for polyesters, bamboos, and even microfiber blends. You’ll want to take into consideration any allergies or skin sensitivities. If you suffer from allergies, look for one that states it is hypoallergenic. 

What thickness do you need?

The thicker the pad, the plusher and softer it is. It really depends on your personal preferences. A medium thickness, for example, may provide more support and breathability. You also want to look at the thread count too. The higher the thread count, the most fluffy and supportive it will be. 

Does it protect my mattress from staining?

A major reason some people want a mattress pad is to add a layer of protection against stains. Make sure that the mattress topper you select states that it is stain and/or water resistant. Typically if it is, you can easily wipe away a quick spill. 

Can I wash the mattress pad at home?

You also want to purchase one that is machine washable at home.  This makes it super easy to maintain if you can wash and dry in the comfort of your own home. Aftering washing and drying, the pad will bounce back to its original fluffiness. 

Now that you have more knowledge about what to look for in a pillow top mattress pad, you’re well on your way to creating a sleep oasis! There is something for everyone on our list of the best pillow top mattress pads that are sure to meet your needs. Take all of our tips into consideration so that you can make the best choice when shopping online.

Photo credit: Iakov Filimonov/Shutterstock