Menu

The Best Pillow Filling for Comfy Pillows

Updated October 15, 2020

Whether you are used to stuffing your own pillows, or you’re new to this crafty universe, the one thing that is super important is the type of filling you choose. If you don’t have a great filling for your pillows, odds are you are not going to have a good experience all around.

In order to take out some of the frustration from not great fillings, we’ve compiled a list of the top six best pillow fillings you can find online right now. All of these fillings are great to use in decorative pillows, throw pillows, bed pillows, or even upholstery projects such as refilling a bean bag chair or a cushioned dining room chair. Whatever you need are, these fillings are sure to stand up to the challenge. Before we get into these amazing products, though, let’s go over some of the types of filling and the benefits of each.

Rank Product Highlights
#1

Fairfield Poly Fil Premium Fiber Fill

buy now

  • Materials: Recycled polyester fibers
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon
#2

Foamily Set of 4-18 x 18 Premium Hypoallergenic Stuffer Pillow Inserts

buy now

  • Materials: Polyester microfiber
  • Weight: 3.26 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon
#3

Shredded Memory Foam Fill Replacement

buy now

  • Materials: Shredded memory foam
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon
#4

Posh Beanbags Refill Foam Filling Shredded

buy now

  • Materials: Shredded foam
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon
#5

Pillow Insert Stuffing Filling

buy now

  • Materials: Polyester
  • Weight: 8 ounces
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon
#6

Nestle Adjustable Shredded Gel Memory Foam Fill

buy now

  • Materials: Shredded gel memory foam
  • Weight: 1 pound
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon

Types and Benefits of Pillow Filling

Not all fillings are alike, so whether you want a loose memory gel foam filling, or you are looking for a pretty standard pillow insert, we’ve got you covered!

Loose Filling

Loose fillings are great for people who have used them before and are not strangers to stuffing their own pillows, but that doesn’t mean newbies or novices can’t take advantage of loose fillings, too! While most crafters may think that loose fillings are too messy for pillow stuffing, others think it’s great to be able to stuff or unstuff a pillow to your exact specifications. With a loose filling, you can easily make a pillow softer, flatter or wider and fuller just depending on your preference.

Pillow Inserts

Pillow inserts are the easiest way to fill a pillow, but you may not always get an insert that will fill the pillow to your liking. In order to prevent that from happening, it’s wise to choose an insert that is up to two inches larger than your pillow sham to prevent the pillow from looking soggy or under stuffed. Nothing is worse than a sad, under a stuffed decorative pillow, so you’re going to want to make sure to find an appropriate size for those pillow shams.

Combination Filling

A foolproof way in making sure your pillows are vibrant and full of life is by combining pillow inserts with pillow filling. Where an insert may miss some parts of the pillow, especially the corners, pillow filling can come in and rescue the day by helping you fill out those hard to reach corners. Once you see your pillow all puffed up and perfectly stuffed, you’ll be glad you went through the extra steps in making sure it was full to its maximum potential.

Shredded Foam

Shredded foam fillings are great because they usually vary in viscosity. This means that you can easily choose standard foam, but there are other more plush foams such as shredded memory foam that will contour to your body. This is especially great when you are looking for a pillow filling to fill your standard bed pillows to sleep on at night. These breathable, easy to use foams are versatile and mostly machine washable.

Polyfill

Polyfill is great for decorative pillows, dolls, toys or anything else that needs stuffing. It is not recommended to use a polyfill to sleep on, as the materials are usually too light and airy in order to maintain a good resting position, but that’s not to say you couldn’t use it if you wanted. Polyfill is perfect for keeping things in shape, so it’s great for those holiday pillows you’ve pulled out of storage or for re-stuffing your dog’s favorite stuffed toy.

The Top 6 Best Pillow Fillings

We’ve compiled a list of the top six best pillow fillings, so you don’t have to waste time scouring the internet. All of these high-grade pillow fillings are sure to keep your pillows soft, durable and maintain their shape. These pillow fillings are backed by great customer reviews and have been featured on best selling lists.

Fairfield Poly Fil Premium Fiber Fill

Specs:

  • Materials: Recycled polyester fibers
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon

This poly fil by Fairfield is a premium fiber filling that is made of 100 percent polyester fibers. The durable yet soft fiber filling is sure to adequately stuff your next pillow, but it can also be used for so much more. This kind of polyfill is a universal fill that could easily be used to stuff pillows, dolls, seat cushions and so much more.

This is a superior fiber fill with a resilient and smooth consistency that won’t pile up or bunch up in one area. The light, airy texture will maintain the fluffiness of any kind of pillow and it is light enough to easily move it around without causing a mess. This fiberfill is made from recycled polyester fiber, so you can also feel good about using a recycled product within your home. This fiberfill is washable, which means you can easily toss your pillows into a standard washing machine on a gentle cycle to get the polyfill clean with ease.

This poly fill material is also hypoallergenic, so if you are someone who suffers from allergies, or you know of someone who suffers from allergies that you want to give a pillow to, this is the best kind of filling for the job.

Pros:

  • Made of 100 percent premium polyester fiber
  • Superior resiliency
  • Smooth consistency
  • Washable

Cons:

  • Maybe too lightweight for some

Who should buy this?

This polyfill is a great pillow filling because it is non-allergenic and is easy to use. This polyfill would make a great pillow filling for the craftsperson who is just starting out or needs an easy filling to use.

buy now

Foamily Set of 4-18 x 18 Premium Hypoallergenic Stuffer Pillow Inserts

Specs:

  • Materials: Polyester microfiber
  • Weight: 3.26 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon

This four-pack of 18 x 18 pillow inserts by Family is a great alternative to a loose filling. These pillow inserts could just make the job much easier, and you will never have to worry about overstuffing or under stuffing your pillows, as these are filled to perfection. These inserts are a great way to pack many cushions on your sofa couch or bed for lumbar support, or just for awesome decoration.

These inserts are resilient and firm, yet fluffy and nice to lean up against or hold. These pillow inserts are filled with 100 percent hypoallergenic polyester microfiber, so these are wonderfully soft and sturdy. These inserts are ideal to use in the home or in an outdoor setting with a cover to protect against the elements. In order to ensure a wonderfully fluffy pillow, it is suggested to order a size up from your sham that way the sham will be full and plump.

Since this set comes with four pillow inserts, you’re sure to have enough to add on to a bedding comforter set for decoration, use them for throw pillows on the couch, or even add these into a reading nook setting for extra comfort. Find your favorite pillow shams and let the decorating begin!

Pros:

  • Comes with four pillow inserts
  • Made of hypoallergenic polyester microfiber
  • Fluffy and strong
  • A good alternative to loose filling

Cons:

  • May be too thin for some pillow shams

Who should buy this?

These pillow inserts are great for someone who needs pillow filling but is unsure about how to use loose pillow filling.

buy now

Shredded Memory Foam Fill Replacement

Specs:

  • Materials: Shredded memory foam
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon

This shredded memory foam fill replacement is perfect for pillows, bean bags, toys, recliners – you name it! Anything that needs to be stuffed can be stuffed with this amazingly soft and durable filling. This filling meets the CertiPUR-US standards for content, emissions and durability, so this foam has no ozone depletes, which is great to know before incorporating it into your home.

This foam filling is flame retardant, has no lead, mercury or heavy metals, formaldehyde or phthalates within the making of this pillow. This is an extremely soft pillow filling that will offer you so much support and comfort. In order to make sure this filling maintains its shape, simply re-fluff the pillow or item in order for the filling to bounce back to its original shape. This filling is longer lasting and much more comfortable than traditional polystyrene beads and Styrofoam filling pellets.

This memory foam filling comes to your vacuum compressed for easy shipment, so all you need to do is fluff it up and allow it some time to get to its intended shape before you use it.

Pros:

  • Super soft and durable
  • Simply fluff up to restore to original shape
  • Long-lasting
  • Has many uses

Cons:

  • May be too soft for some

Who should buy this?

This shredded memory foam filling is great for anyone who needs to fill pillows, couch cushions, bean bag chairs, stuffed animals, dog beds or use it in upholstery and arts and craft projects.

buy now

Posh Beanbags Refill Foam Filling Shredded

Specs:

  • Materials: Shredded foam
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon

This shredded foam filling is great for reupholstering or refilling any pillows or other furniture items you may have in your house. This product is made entirely of foam, so it is safe for you and your family and does not contain any fire retardants. It also meets all the CertiPUR – US standards and is manufactured solely within the USA.

This is a five-pound bag of foam that will expand to approximately two cubic feet when fully expanded and fluffed. It is long-lasting and features an extremely comfortable feel. You can easily use this foam to refill and renew your favorite bean bag chair, foam chair or even dog bed. As like other foam fillings, this filing is highly adaptive and can be used in so many different ways throughout your home or even in the car.

This foam is a blend of several different foam densities, making it highly durable and long-lasting. The unique blend of various densities makes this foam great to sit on, lean on and incorporate into any type of chair or bean bag chair item. The durability of this product means it will last a lifetime and you simply need to fluff it up every now and then by hand to get it back into its intended shape.

Pros:

  • Highly durable
  • Comes with different densities in foam
  • Long-lasting
  • Can refill multiple things in your home

Cons:

  • Maybe too lumpy for some

Who should buy this?

This shredded foam filling is perfect for refilling items around the house, including pillows, furniture and bean bag type chairs.

buy now

Pillow Insert Stuffing Filling

Specs:

  • Materials: Polyester
  • Weight: 8 ounces
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon

This pillow inserts stuffing and filling is great for giving your pillow inserts or pillows a new life. This filling can be used specifically for filling the corners of pillow casings to give it a decorative, refined look. It’s a simple product with an even simpler method of filling. You just add the stuffing inside of the case, then add your insert into the case and close it securely.

As pillow inserts sometimes don’t fill the entire pillowcase, this is a great way to make sure the entire pillowcase is full. The corners especially in pillowcases can often go overlooked or unstuffed, so this filling is meant to embellish an existing pillow insert and make sure all those corners are puffed out and looking their best. You could easily use this filling as a pillow stuffing alone, but it works best in conjunction with a pillow insert for maximum fullness.

This pillow stuffing would be great for sprucing up the holiday pillows once you gather them out from storage, or even to fluff up some old throw pillows in the guestroom. There are so many uses with this filling and it’s an easy product to use that is sure to last a long time.

Pros:

  • Easy to use
  • Great for filling out pillow corners
  • Long-lasting
  • Multipurpose use

Cons:

  • May be too thin for some

Who should buy this?

This pillow stuffing is great for anyone who wants to puff out the corners of decorative pillows and doesn’t want to use stuffing alone when filling a pillow. Works best in conjunction with a pillow insert.

buy now

Nestle Adjustable Shredded Gel Memory Foam Fill

Specs:

  • Materials: Shredded gel memory foam
  • Weight: 1 pound
  • Care: Machine washable
  • Return Policy: 30-day free returns through Amazon

This amazing adjustable shredded gel memory foam filling by Nestle provides one full pound of premium shredded gel-infused memory foam and poly-fill for your adjustable pillows. You can easily fill a pillow as much as you’d like to take advantage of luxurious depths that contour to your body for the perfect amount of support for your neck, shoulders and head.

This is a gel memory foam that was tested to meet rigorous standards producing this environmentally safe product that will make you feel good and will be good for the environment. To use this foam filling you simply unzip the inner shell of a pillow and add as much foam filling as you’d like. To test it, try stuffing some of the fillings in, and lay on it to see if you need more or less. Since everyone is different, you may want a firmer or softer pillow depending on your body type.

In order to enhance this filling, once the pillow is filled to your specifications, simply throw the pillow into the dryer to get the foam to expand to its full size. This way, you can easily get to your preferred level of loft and create the most comfortable pillow you’ve ever slept on.

Pros:

  • Environmentally friendly
  • Good for contouring to the body
  • Can be fluffed up in the dryer
  • Memory foam is good for the joints

Cons:

  • Maybe too fluffy for some

Who should buy this?

This pillow filling is great for anyone who needs a little extra neck, shoulder and back support as you can easily use as much or as little of this memory foam filling as you need.

buy now

The Wrap Up

So, there you have it – some of the best pillow fillings you can find on the market right now. Whether you are a hobbyist who prefers to fill their own dolls or decorative pillows, or you are trying something new out in terms of pillow stuffing, you are sure to find just what you’re looking for within this amazing list.

All of these products are backed by amazing customer reviews and have been featured on best-selling or top-rated lists, so you know you are looking at ideal products. Best yet, all of these products are backed by free return policies, so your purchase is definitely protected.