The Best Overall Comforter Reviews
| Rank | Product | Highlights |
| #1 | 
Wayfair Basics |
|
| #2 | 
Captiva Comforter |
|
| #3 | 
LINENSPA |
|
| #4 |  Silk Camel |
|
| #5 | 
SNOWMAN |
|
| #6 |  YOUR MOON BUY NOW | ● Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King ● Fill: wool ● Outer shell fabric: cotton ● Weight (Queen): 3.31 pounds |
| #7 |  BAMBOO TRANQUILITY BUY NOW | ● Available sizes: Queen, King ● Fill: bamboo viscose ● Outer shell fabric: bamboo viscose ● Weight (Queen): 6 pounds lightweight, 7 pounds all season |
Comforters are the cold sleeper’s best friend, there’s no doubt about it. Every time you’re at work during a cold winter day, you surely dream about crawling into your comfortable bed, the only place that seems to “get you”. However, make no mistake, buying a comforter isn’t a walk in the park, and there are plenty of fabrics that have unique properties that you may not be familiar with, making your purchasing decision a lot more difficult.
Down & Down Alternative
There are plenty of ways to classify a comforter, but if we were to narrow it down to the most common one, comforters are filled with a down or down alternative. Naturally, there are pros and cons to each of these two comforter categories.
- Natural down has the advantage of providing an eco-friendly product because it’s renewable. Down that is sourced from ducks and geese has better insulating properties, creating some of the coziest and warmest comforters on the market. Sadly, some people are allergic to down, plus comforters made with natural down are more expensive compared to their own alternative counterparts.
- Down alternative features synthetic man-made combinations that create a more affordable, but also a cheaper and hypoallergenic alternative to down fill. Down alternative can mean anything from a microfiber/polyester to cotton, wool, or even silk. Down alternative doesn’t have the superior insulation properties of natural down, but it’s also a fraction of the cost of a natural down comforter, so many people prefer to invest in one of these.
Down might be the best and most common choice of fill, especially for winter comforters, which are supposed to trap heat underneath. If you live in a region with particularly cold winter climates, there really is a no better alternative to a down comforter. Aside from that, down is lofty, creating some of the fluffiest and most comfortable products out there.
But if you’re questioning the ethical implications of plucking feathers and down from birds, or if you feel that a down comforter is a bit too expensive, why not go for a down alternative comforter, which can be just as good.
Best Outer Fabric Choices
Make no mistake; the outer fabric that’s used for a comforter cover is just as important as the fill. You can a fabric that’s breathable because heat is good, but too much heat underneath the comforter can cause thermal discomfort and decrease your sleep quality.
You also want a fabric that’s durable, because you don’t want to spend money on a comforter that you’ll be throwing away after the first few washes, nor should feathers be sticking out of the fabric, in case you’re going with a down comforter.
How the material itself feels may not be important to some people, but it is for those who don’t use their comforter with a duvet cover. Since the fabric comes in direct contact with the skin, it’s important to look for a fabric that feels pleasant to the touch, and that is a very subjective matter.
— Cotton
For a very long time, cotton has been the king of the clothing industry, because nothing quite compares to the durability, breathability, and softness of cotton clothing. So it shouldn’t come as a surprise that cotton has made its way into the bedding industry.
Cotton is very soft to the touch, but that’s not its only quality. It is very efficient at trapping moisture but is also breathable, so the chances of sweating underneath this fabric are pretty low.
However, the biggest debate of the cotton world is how to tell good cotton apart from the bad. Normally, people believe that the thread count of the fabric is the main quality indicator, but the truth is that there are many different factors to take into account. While a thread count of 300 is good, 500 is ideal, and anything over 600 is just science fiction.
— Silk
Silk is a luxurious material, there’s no doubt about that. Sadly, that also makes it very expensive. However, you’d be surprised to know that price isn’t the most common reason why people turn away from silk comforters: it’s actually the feel of the fabric that a lot of people can’t get used to.
If you’ve been using cotton sheets your entire life, you will definitely know the difference between the feel of cotton and silk. Silk is cool to the touch, but also way more slippery. Because of its distinct nature, silk feels very different from other fabrics, and some people can’t get used to that.
But if you’re not one of those people, there are actually a ton of benefits in buying a silk comforter. First of all, silk isn’t treated with chemicals, which makes it 100 percent hypoallergenic. Also, it has this wonderful ability to trap a lot of moisture but still allows the skin to breathe despite that. Since it’s breathable, silk allows trapped moisture to evaporate, without causing discomfort to the sleeper.
— Wool
When you think about wool clothing or wool blankets, you’re probably picturing yourself in front of a fireplace, sipping on red wine on a chilly winter’s night. That’s because wool is exceptional at keeping people warm.
As far as comforters are concerned, it’s best to opt for wool only when you’re looking to buy a winter comforter because even if this fabric offers plenty of benefits, it’s not a good summer choice. Another major downside of wool is that it costs very much (assuming that you find a comforter made with actual wool), but it’s also one of the most durable fabrics out there.
— Bamboo
It’s no secret that bamboo bedding items are currently a big hit. Bamboo is inexpensive, soft, breathable, but can retain heat without causing discomfort. But the true major benefit of buying a bamboo comforter is that the properties of the fabric make it exceptional for couples who have different temperature preferences.
That means that if you tend to sleep hot, but your partner sleeps hot, bamboo comforters can regulate the temperature for both you, providing a comfortable sleeping environment.
You may want to read: The Best Comforters on Amazon
Top Comforter Reviews
#1. Wayfair Basics
SPECS
- Available sizes: Twin, Full/Queen, King
- Fill: polyester
- Outer shell fabric: polyester
- Weight (Queen): 4 pounds
Bargain buy
Every now and then, you come across that one person that can’t say goodbye to their comforter despite it being summer outside. If you are that kind of person, not even you can stand sleeping under a winter comforter, so you need a warmer season alternative.
Wayfair Basics offers one of the least expensive down alternative comforters on the market, priced so low, you’ll probably buy more than one. The comforter is available in nine different colors, including a wild shade of sage, a romantic purple, and a dreamy seafoam green.
With both a polyester cover and synthetic fill, the comforter provides a very basic sleeping experience, but you can’t exactly hope for silk and natural down fill at this price range. What you get is a light summer comforter that’s affordable, easy to clean, and most likely comes in a color that matches your current bedroom decor.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Purchase This?
Are you looking for a comforter that’s inexpensive, but decently constructed? Wayfair Basics will now provide you with such a product, as their comforter is designed to be affordable, and great for the warmer seasons.
#2. Captiva Comforter
SPECS
- Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
- Fill: cotton
- Outer shell fabric: cotton
- Weight (Queen): N/A
Best with floral pattern
Taking things up a notch, we wanted to show you what a premium floral pattern comforter looks like. With a cotton filling, but also cotton exterior, this moisture-wicking and highly-breathable comforter are bound to make a lot of buyers happy, provided they are willing to pay the price to get their hands on one.
The cover sports a natural look that scatters green leaves on a red background, which gives the whole thing a jungle/rebellious type of look. The 300 thread count of the outer cotton fabric is more than enough to ensure durability and a smooth surface that you wouldn’t mind touching your skin every night.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Purchase This?
If you’re looking for an upgrade from the single color choices out there, this floral pattern on the Captiva comforter is bound to… captivate your interest. Aside from the stunning colors combination of natural red and green, it’s made with comfortable cotton cover and fills.
#3. LINENSPA
SPECS
- Available sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Oversized Queen, King, Oversized King, Cal King
- Fill: polyester
- Outer shell fabric: polyester
- Weight (Queen): 5.1 pounds
Customer’s choice
I’m going to level with you, the LINENSPA down alternative comforter can fit under many different labels, because it’s affordable, preferred by many sleepers, has a good price-to-quality ratio, and provides great comforter throughout the entire year.
Available in six different color options, plus a white version, this comforter is made with down alternative fill, perfect for those who are allergic or sensitive to natural down. Aside from the plain white model, each of the other six has a reversible design, with a different color on each side. Both the cover and the fill are made from polyester, which is to be expected considering the price of the product.
There are four duvet loops, one stitched to each corner, but also four more that are located on the sides of the comforter. The comforter is easy to care for, but also loved by tens of thousands of customers that save it a shot.
Who Should Purchase This?
If you’re not particularly picky about your comforter and want a lightweight and affordable option that people just keep buying over and over again, you’ve hit the jackpot with this LINENSPA comforter.
#4. LILYSILK
SPECS
- Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King, Cal King
- Fill: silk
- Outer shell fabric: cotton
- Weight (Queen): 3.85 pounds
Best silk comforter
Where do we even begin talking about how amazing this summer comforter is. The cotton shell is smooth to the touch, while the filling is long strand mulberry silk floss, one of the finest types out there. Silk can naturally keep moisture away from the body, forcing it to evaporate without weight or discomfort for the sleeper.
The included zipper grants you access to the fill, so you can check the quality of the fill yourself. The corner and side loops make the comforter compatible with a duvet cover. And the best part of it all, it’s allergen-free, and can naturally repel dust mites and bed bugs.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Purchase This?
Ever wondered what it would feel like to sleep under a silk comforter? Is silk the best fabric in the world, in your opinion? Do you want a high-quality comforter that’s perfect for the summer season? Then LILYSILK has a treat in store for you.
#5. SNOWMAN
SPECS
- Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
- Fill: white goose down
- Outer shell fabric: cotton
- Weight (Queen): 7.05 pounds
Best goose down comforter
Except for maybe wool, no other fill material will have the insulating properties of natural down, so we just had to include a down product in here somewhere. Let’s start off by mentioning the cool cotton cover, which is hypoallergenic, and offer comfort without borders.
The eight attached loops will help secure the duvet in place, without you having to worry about it piling up inside the duvet cover. Then, there’s a fill: a blend of white goose down and feathers, which gives you loft, insulation, and the quality that you can only get from natural down.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Purchase This?
For true down fans, the SNOWMAN comforter comes with the fill power to provide you with many warm winter nights, while the cotton exterior is perfect for those who love the properties of this fabric, and aren’t willing to sacrifice quality to get the lowest price possible.
#6. YOUR MOON
SPECS
- Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
- Fill: wool
- Outer shell fabric: cotton
- Weight (Queen): 3.31 pounds
Best wool comforter
Temperature-regulating, moisture-wicking, hypoallergenic, and a natural material – wool has it all. This all-season comforter is made from quality natural materials that are suited for use in all seasons: the filling is sterilized fine Australian sheep wool and the shell is made from 100% Egyptian cotton for breathability and softness.
Thanks to the 100 minutes of repeated cleaning to grease and 18 carbonization processes to remove wool impurities, this comforter has no smell at all – you don’t have to worry about sheep scent in your bed. Also, it is OEKO TEX certified to ensure that there were no harmful substances used in the processing and manufacture.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Purchase This?
If you prefer natural materials and want a temperature-regulating comforter you can use throughout the year, YOUR MOON delivers. Made from finest Egyptian cotton with an Australian wool fill, this insulating comforter will keep the temperature optimal at all times.
#7. BAMBOO TRANQUILITY
SPECS
- Available sizes: Queen, King
- Fill: bamboo viscose
- Outer shell fabric: bamboo viscose
- Weight (Queen): 6 pounds lightweight, 7 pounds all season
Best bamboo comforter
Whether you sleep with a partner that has different temperature preferences than you or you’re a hot sleeper yourself, bamboo is the perfect choice. It is breathable, dissipates heat, and feels luxurious against the skin – and this Bamboo Tranquility comforter is made from bamboo viscose inside and out.
Even though denser and heavier than, say, cotton, bamboo is still lightweight and very pleasant as a year-round choice, as it will keep you toasty in the colder months and pleasantly cooled (but not cold) in the summer heat. To tailor the experience to your exact needs, this bamboo comforter comes in a lightweight or all-season version.
| Pros | Cons |
● Bamboo viscose shell and fill. ● Hypoallergenic and natural material.
● 8 loops for a secure fit. ● Baffle box construction keeps the fill fluffy and in place. |
|
Who Should Purchase This?
You don’t have to toss and turn when the temperatures rise or forgo comforters altogether – cooling, breathable bamboo keeps temperature regulated and its silky feel will have you sleeping like a baby. Bamboo Tranquility offers this all-bamboo viscose comforter that is made from natural materials and comes in two weight options: fluffier all-season and a lightweight that’s perfect for hot sleepers.
Bottom Line
The most important thing to do before buying a comforter is fully understanding what the properties of different fabrics and fill materials are, but also knowing the exact purpose of the comforter you want to buy.
If harsh winter climates are something you have to face every year, you should consider going for a comforter with a lot of lofts, and preferably for one, that’s made with natural down or wool. If you want a product for summer use, consider looking for an all-season comforter. Those of you that have allergies, should look for a hypoallergenic fabric, and steer clear of natural down.