Best Innerspring Mattress
A good mattress is essential for good sleep quality. The innerspring mattress design is an old-school, established approach to mattress construction with a long-standing tradition. As the name suggests, these mattresses rely on a dense core of steel coils – or springs – which gives them that classic bouncy feel and plenty of support as well. Innerspring coils can be the ideal solution for plus size sleepers and couples, as the independent coils in some designs allow your weight to be equally distributed, and has a good motion isolating effect.
Of course, not all innerspring mattresses are made alike – if you don’t choose a high-quality mattress with good cushioning, there are more downsides to this type of mattress than there are benefits, so pick with care.
| Rank | Product | Highlights |
| #1 |  Swiss Ortho Sleep
|
|
| #2 |  Classic Brands Serena
|
|
| #3 |  Linenspa 6” Innerspring Mattress
|
|
| #4 |  Modway Jenna Innerspring Mattress
|
|
| #5 |  Sealy Bed-In-a-Box Innerspring Mattress
|
|
| #6 |  Molblly Mattress In a Box
|
|
Table Of Contents
- What are the Benefits of an Innerspring Mattress?
- Breathability and free airflow
- Durability
- Support
- Motion isolation
- Best Innerspring Mattresses
- 1. Editor’s Choice: Swiss Ortho Sleep
- 2. Runner Up: Classic Brands Serena
- 3. Customer Choice: Linenspa 6” Innerspring Mattress
- 4. Best for Side Sleepers: Modway Jenna Innerspring Mattress
- 5. Best Adjustable: Sealy Bed-In-a-Box Innerspring Mattress
- 6. Best for Back Pain: Molblly Mattress In a Box
- Bottom Line
What are the Benefits of an Innerspring Mattress?
At its core, the innerspring mattress design can be quite a different experience from some other common options on the market, such as the popular memory foam mattress. However, every sleeper is unique and the versatile innerspring design can be a much better solution for plenty of people- but most often hot sleepers, plus-size people, and couples, and it’s all thanks to the unique benefits this type of mattress has.
Breathability and free airflow
Thanks to its super-wide core region, and the free space between the coil springs, these mattresses boast a greater airflow and unparalleled breathability. The air can freely pass through the mattress core, preventing the slow moisture buildup that leads to mildew, but also limiting the accumulation of bacteria, dust, and bedbugs. This increased airflow is a crucial contribution to better hygiene but also for temperature regulation, especially during the warmer months of the year. The breathability of innerspring mattresses makes them much cooler to sleep on and ideal for hot sleepers.
Durability
Durability is a very important aspect of every reliable mattress, and it plays a big role in innerspring designs. Thanks to the robust core of coil springs, and the equal weight distribution across the entire mattress, longevity is greatly increased. Moreover, with the addition of the necessary foam layers and woven fabric casing, the important central components are protected from wear and tear, adding to the durability. And since a mattress is a big investment, you’d want it to last as long as possible. And innerspring mattresses always do.
Support
Cheaper mattresses and soft foam mattresses tend to cater to very light persons, and usually don’t offer enough support for an average or plus-size sleeper. They are also very bad at weight distribution, increasing wear and tear, and making the mattress uncomfy for couples. This is not the case with innerspring mattresses. Here, you can rely on the robust core that can take a lot of weight without sagging. It equally disperses the pressure across the entire surface, and thus removes the pressure from your back and joints. This support also comes in handy if you are sleeping with a partner and there’s a bigger weight difference between you.
Motion isolation
Most innerspring mattress designs boast a base consisting of independent, individually wrapped coils. This allows the mattress to perfectly adapt to your shape, sleeping position, and weight. But more importantly, this independent movement isolates all your motion. For couples, this comes particularly in handy: you restless moves during the night won’t disturb the sleep of your partner.
Best Innerspring Mattresses
1. Editor’s Choice: Swiss Ortho Sleep
Specs:
- Available Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
- Available Thickness: 12”
- Feel: Medium/Firm
- Weight: 80 lbs
If you suffer from back pain and aches, it’s probably your old uncomfortable mattress to blame. Thanks to the superb ergonomic design of this Swiss Ortho innerspring mattress, you can potentially put a stop to all such issues that have been troubling you for years. With the perfect, mid-range thickness of 12”, this mattress boasts well-balanced layers to ensure its orthopedic qualities. At the very core is a dense forest of individually wrapped pocketed encased coil springs, which remain protected and evenly spread out your weight.
To insulate them, Swiss Ortho relied on a natural solution – a solid layer of white cotton adds to breathability and keeps the mattress core free from bacteria and dust. To top it off, you have a 1” layer of supportive wave foam, and a 0.5” layer of regular foam to add to your comfort. This design is perfect for pressure relief and can adapt to your body with surprising precision. It is also completed with a hypoallergenic, breathable bamboo fabric cover, which adds to the hygiene level and is also fire retardant – adding to your safety. With a solid choice of sizes and a superbly balanced design, this innerspring mattress is without a doubt a solid choice for a wide variety of sleepers.
Pros
- Great thickness
- Independent coils
- Breathable bamboo fabric top
- Foam and cotton cushioning
- Hypoallergenic and flame-retardant
- CertiPUR USA certified
Cons
- Takes a while to fully expand
Who Should Buy This Product?
This Swiss Ortho design perfectly fulfills the role that every mattress ought to have: orthopedic support. An innerspring mattress with perfect thickness and balanced dispersion of layers, it is the best bang for the buck you can get.
2. Runner Up: Classic Brands Serena
Specs:
- Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
- Available Thickness: 10”
- Feel: Medium/Firm
- Weight: 83 lbs
When it comes to innerspring mattresses, nothing beats the tried & tested, a by-the-book design that covers all the crucial aspects. Classic Brands rely on a straightforward design, but with high-quality elements – the end result is a perfectly balanced product. This mattress’ core relies on an even spread of individually wrapped pocketed tempered steel coils, with each one having the ability to move independently, allowing them to contour to your body with utter precision. What’s more, you won’t feel the coils themselves and risk discomfort – they are evened out with a layer of high-quality comfort foam that acts as a buffer level, adding to the superb comfort.
The surface layer relies on a quality quilted knit pillow top cover, which is breathable and durable as well. For a medium to firm feel, you can’t beat this Classic Brands mattress – it has all the prerequisites for a night of top quality sleep.
Pros
- Comfy quilted top
- High-quality independent coils
- A great medium to firm feel
- Suited for back sleepers and stomach sleepers
- Comfort foam relieves pressure
Cons
- Edge support could be better
Who Should Buy This Product?
With a good ratio between price, quality, and reliability, this Classic Brands mattress is one of those balanced designs that leaves little to be desired. With plenty of size choices and a lot of stability for all types of sleepers, it is a real no-brainer choice.
3. Customer Choice: Linenspa 6” Innerspring Mattress
Specs:
- Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
- Available Thickness: 6”
- Feel: Firm
- Weight: 24.4 lbs
In the world of mattresses, Linenspa really stands out thanks to the quality and reliability of its products. This 6” innerspring mattress is no exception, and really brings out some great qualities of the design itself. Here is a classic example of what an innerspring mattress really is: this design follows the basic elements to offer a reliable, but simple product. Undoubtedly, the central part of the mattress is its core: composed of heavy gauge tempered steel coils, it offers great support and stability, without being too firm or too soft.
Above the coils is a thin layer of felt pad fabric, designed to provide insulation. The top surface features a thin layer of foam, for that soft and comfy feeling that won’t allow the coil springs to poke through and make you uncomfortable. The finish quilted top is the perfect snooze surface for every sleeper, especially back and stomach sleepers that prefer a firmer bed. However, if you are a plus size sleeper, you’ll be left wanting for some more thickness and cushioning for better comfort.
Pros
- Affordable
- Fits a variety of frames
- Ideal for bunk beds, trundle beds, and day beds
- Great for dorm beds or guests rooms
- Suited for back and stomach sleepers
Cons
- Could be thicker
Who Should Buy This Product?
It isn’t all about fancy features and high-end solutions – sometimes even the basic, simple designs can do the trick. This Linenspa innerspring mattress is a clear example – a traditional design that has everything you need for a night of quality sleep. And with a feather-light price tag to boot!
4. Best for Side Sleepers: Modway Jenna Innerspring Mattress
Specs:
- Available Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, California King
- Available Thickness: 8”, 10”, 14”
- Feel: Firm
- Weight: 33 lbs
If you are a side sleeper, a thick, cushiony innerspring mattress can be just the thing you have been looking for. With ample stability and superior durability, this Modway Jenna mattress is easily one of the best choices for people that sleep on their side. Its “secret” lies in the modern and robust core made out of high quality individually wrapped coil springs. Not only are they durable, but also perfectly isolate every motion, allowing both you and your partner to sleep in comfort – no matter your personal habits or positions. But what makes it particularly great for side sleepers are the layers that give you comfort and protect the mattress core. The coils are thus topped off with an insulating felt layer, and 3” of egg crate foam, with the finishing layer of 1” responsive foam. These layers are crucial to make you feel comfortable, without negating the role of the coil springs. They will adapt to your sleeping position and help minimize the stress and relieve key pressure points. No more waking up sore and stiff!
Pros
- Great for side sleepers
- Extra-wide innerspring core
- Supportive enough for plus-size people
- Comfortable and sturdy
- A good choice for back pain sufferers
Cons
- Could be too firm for some
Who Should Buy This Product?
Ideal for side sleepers, this innerspring mattress will offer comfort and support both. Plus size sleepers will also benefit from this superb design: the thickness is unparalleled when it comes to support and stability.
5. Best Adjustable: Sealy Bed-In-a-Box Innerspring Mattress
Specs:
- Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen
- Available Thickness: 8”, 10”
- Feel: Medium
- Weight: 33 lbs
A classic choice, this innerspring mattress is compatible with all bases and foundations, including adjustable beds. At its core is a very thick layer of tempered Sealy Support coils, making for an exceptionally stable base that offers support for every type of user. Furthermore, they are adaptive and flexible enough to handle an adjustable bed. To even it out and add more comfort to the design, Sealy opted for a 3.5” layer of special SealyCool Gel Foam, which not only adds softness but also effectively regulates the temperature, making it great for every season and hot sleepers as well.
The durable woven cover on the surface layer adds the finishing touch and keeps all the layers within protected. With over 130 years of experience, Sealy is by far one of the veteran brands out there – and that expertise can really be seen in this advanced design.
Pros
- SealyCool Gel Foam layer
- Breathable materials
- Compatible with all bases and foundations
- Suited for hot sleepers
- Great for guest rooms and dorms
- Made in the USA
Cons
- Could be thicker
- Limited size choices
Who Should Buy This Product?
If you want a versatile innerspring mattress that is compatible with all bases and foundations, then this Sealy design might be what you need. Sturdy, supportive, and comfy to boot, this mattress will be a good choice for any bed frame.
6. Best for Back Pain: Molblly Mattress In a Box
Specs:
- Available Sizes: Full, Queen, King
- Available Thickness: 12”
- Feel: Firm
- Weight: 79.8 lbs
Molblly is a brand that takes the established innerspring mattress design and adds a whole range of superb new features to take it to a whole new level, making for a high-end solution that’s ideal for back pain sufferers. It relies on an advanced multi-layer design, all of which work to emphasize the effect of the strong innerspring core. That core relies on 9” of individually wrapped, independent encase coils that boast a consistent distribution of your body weight, but also ample flexibility to contour to your natural position and ensure proper spine curvature essential for pain-free sleep.
The base also features a fireproof felt pad and a layer of base pressure relief foam, while on top there is the 1” layer of HD support foam. This is followed by the finishing layers of regular and breathable wave foam, both of which add a hypoallergenic character to the mattress and increase the overall comfort. As a result, you’ll experience pressure relief and healthy sleeping posture, all of which are crucial for eliminating back and shoulder pain.
Pros
- Premium layered design
- Helps eliminate back pain
- High-quality independent coils
- Distributes weight equally
- Suited for couples
- CertiPUR-US Certified
Cons
- Limited size choices
Who Should Buy This Product?
If you wake up sore and stiff every morning, it’s time for a new mattress- and this premium innerspring mattress will have you sleeping like a baby and feeling brand new, too. Specially designed for optimal support and pressure relief, it will give you the pain-free sleep you crave.
Bottom Line
Quality sleep is essential for a happy, healthy life and you can’t count on it unless you have a supportive and comfortable mattress. An innerspring mattress is a traditional design that really goes back a while, and over the years it got honed and perfected to the final design we have today. The combination of individually wrapped coils in the base that offer support and make the mattress breathable and cushioning that relieves pressure and pain make innerspring mattresses a great choice for hot sleepers, couples, people with back pain, and heavier people.