Menu

The Best Down Comforters to Choose From

Updated May 18, 2020

Few things can beat the comfort of a down comforter. In fact, the whole idea of sliding under something heavy and fluffy and warm after a long day of facing winter’s temperatures sounds like a slice of Heaven. But down comforters are so much more than oversized blankets: they are an item that needs to be researched if you want to make the best out of your experience with a product of this caliber.

Rank Product Highlights
#1

SNOWMAN

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: white goose down and feathers
  • Outer shell: cotton
#2

ROYALAY

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: white goose down
  • Outer shell: cotton
#3

The Company Store LaCrosse

buy now

  • Available sizes: Queen, King
  • Fill: natural down
  • Outer shell: cotton
#4

Egyptian Bedding

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: Siberian goose down
  • Outer shell: Egyptian cotton
#5

APSMILE

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: European goose down
  • Outer shell: 60% cotton, 40% polyester

Fabrics & Fill

Consider a down comforter as something made of two parts: an outer shell that acts as a cover and (without a cover) comes in direct contact with your skin, and a filling that’s either goose or duck down and can provide a certain loft (or fill power).

Down comforters, which are different from down alternative comforters (filled with synthetic fibers or other types of fill), are filled with duck or goose down. Of course, there are differences between the two, the most important one being that goose down is typically warmed compared to duck down. The explanation is simple: geese are larger than ducks, which means that their down is also bigger and provides more loft.

Naturally, this characteristic may or may not be accurate, depending on the source of the down. If the down doesn’t come from mature geese, then it won’t be warmer compared to duck down. On the other hand, it’s important to consider that down clusters have a higher warming power, which means that a comforter filled with a lot of duck clusters will be at least as warm as a down comforter made with a lower ratio of goose clusters.

As mentioned before, a comforter has two main parts, so it’s good for you to know a little bit about the main fabrics that are used to create the outer shell of your comforter:

  • Cotton is one of the most appreciate fabrics in the bedding industry, which means that it also found its way into the construction of down comforters. Cotton has the most benefits out of all the types of fabrics used: it is soft, comfortable, affordable, and durable. However, the feel of cotton is also subject to a lot of… subjectivism, as some people claim it isn’t breathable, while others wouldn’t trade it for any other fabric.
  • Synthetic fibers are probably the second most common types of fabrics used to make outer shells for down comforters. These man-made fibers are usually used in combination with cotton in order to make it more breathable, but also less expensive.
  • Silk is another common fabric used in the bedding industry, and while it has a luxurious feel, a lot of people can’t get used to it. Aside from being considerably more expensive compared to cotton, silk is also naturally cooling, but rather prone to wrinkles.

  • Bamboo sheets have gained a lot of notoriety lately, and are now being used to make down comforters as well. Bamboo is an eco-friendly and breathable fabric, but for some reason, people are still too skeptical to sleep with it.
  • Wool is actually a wise fabric to combine with down because it provides a really high level of warmth, is soft, and moisture-wicking. However, wool is also expensive, and the construction of the fibers also makes it very heavy.

Sustainability

There are two main issues that revolve around the idea of making down comforters: the cruelty-free aspects and the organic range of the materials being used in the manufacturing process. Down comforters are made with animal-sourced raw materials, which often raises a lot of questions about how down is being plucked from these animals in order to make comforters.

You can rest assured that harvesting down for these birds is a cruelty-free process and the standards in the industry have become more and more rigorous on the topic. If you want more peace of mind knowing that your down comforter hasn’t been made as a result of animal cruelty, you should look for manufacturers that are transparent as possible about their supply chain. You can look for products that have the Responsible Down Standard certification.

There is also the matter of how the outer shell material fibers have been obtained, as people are now increasingly more interested in using products made with cotton/silk/wool that are organically raised and harvested.

Think of it this way: cotton that doesn’t come from organic sources has most likely been treated with pesticides or other toxins that help fight off insects and pests. Naturally, people believe that his greatest impact not necessarily the quality of the fiber, but rather the health of the sleeper, because those toxins linger in the fibers are eventually end up in a person’s bedroom. There is also the matter of how toxins from pesticides end up in landfills and pollute the soil and water.

Thankfully, organically-raised cotton is now easier to come across, but it does vamp up the cost of a down comforter if you’re looking for one that has an organic cotton outer shell. Generally speaking, people who prefer organic cotton down comforters are those who buy them for their children, those who have allergies or skin sensitivity, or those who are looking to protect Mother Earth by buying products that were made with as little negative impact on the environment as possible.

You may be interested in: Best Down Comforter Buyer’s Guide

Top 5 Down Comforter Reviews

With a little more comforter-related knowledge in the back of our minds, it’s time to explore what the market has to offer in terms of decent down comforters, so stick around and see if there’s something in here for you.

SNOWMAN

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: white goose down and feathers
  • Outer shell: cotton

Best value

Let’s start off this a comforter that matches expectations in terms of price: the Snowman down comforter. It is a product filled with a combination of white goose down and feathers, available in three sizes for all kinds of beds.

The manufacturer promises that the down and feathers used inside this comforter have been washed, rinsed, and sterilized at a high temperature in order to make sure that you enjoy a hypoallergenic comforter. The product has been made using box stitches, which help ensure that the fill is evenly distributed across the surface of the comforter without creating any cold spots.

The filling is brought together by an outer shell that’s made entirely out of cotton, which a really high thread count (600) that vouches for the quality and durability of the materials. There are eight side loops that will make it really easy to secure the comforter inside a cover and prevent shifting as you fuss during your sleep.

Pros:

  • Convenient price.
  • Fill was thoroughly cleaned.
  • High thread count.
  • 100 percent cotton outer shell.
  • Good for all-season use.

Cons:

  • Noisy.
  • Too thin for very low temperatures.

Who Should Purchase This?

Want a down comforter but they all cost hundreds of dollars? Here is that one option that won’t make you spend all that money. The Snowman comforter is for those who are looking for a quality comforter filled with goose down and feathers at a really convenient price.

buy now

ROYALAY

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: white goose down
  • Outer shell: cotton

Best all-season comforter

Despite is being quite the inexpensive down comforter, this Royalay product comes with a lot of features that you get from premium comforters. First of all, it comes with a soft cotton outer shell that has a thread count of 600, making sure that the filling will never poke through the fabric and cause any discomfort.

The seams on this comforter are double-stitches, meaning that they won’t come loose during washing or after numerous nights of use. The loops in the corners are ideal for pairing this comforter with a suitable duvet cover.

The filling is natural goose down, making sure that you stay nice and toasty during cold winter nights. Because it is designed to be used in every season, this comforter will make bring temperature regulation to the next level, making sure that your body stays warm in colder months, but also making sure that summer heat is dissipated without you feeling suffocated by it.

Pros:

  • Corner loops.
  • 600 thread count.
  • Made with a cotton outer shell.
  • Good for all-seasons use.
  • Warm, but not heavy.

Cons:

  • Not as fluffy as the pictures.

Who Should Purchase This?

Comforters are normally associated with the cold temperatures of winter, but when you have the right all-seasons product, who says you can’t use a comforter in the summer? The Royalay down comforter is designed for people who want to be able to use it all year round, as it provides a great balance between warmth and breathability.

buy now

The Company Store LaCrosse

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Queen, King
  • Fill: natural down
  • Outer shell: cotton

Best luxurious down comforter

The Company Store has a reputation for making high-quality down comforter, and the LaCrosse does not disappoint. From the moment you brush your hands against the cotton outer shell, you will feel quality in all of its pores.

There is plenty to be said about this particular comforter (aside from it being considerably more expensive than the other two we spoke of so far). It is available in a light/medium version, and a heavier version that’s suitable for people who live in climates where winter nights are harsh.

It is filled with a certified down that reaches a fill power of 550 (which means it can trap heat underneath it to keep you nice and warm regardless of the temperature in the room). The shell is made with combed cotton that has a thread count of 295 (some might say it’s low, but we like to call it realistic).  It is hypoallergenic, comes with corner loops, and it has been certified under the Responsible Down Standard.

Pros:

  • High fill power.
  • Available in two warmth levels.
  • Made with quality cotton.
  • Certified under Responsible Down Standard.
  • Hypoallergenic.
  • Finished with a double-needle top-stitch.

Cons:

  • Expensive.
  • A bit slippery if used without a cover.

Who Should Purchase This?

Hey, if you’re looking to spend more money on a quality down comforter, we have plenty of recommendations for you! Today, we’ve chosen to recommend the LaCrosse comforter, made by a veteran in the down comforter industry. This product is for those who want to pay for the front-row ticket, as it is a product made with responsibly-sourced materials and emits quality through all its pores.

buy now

Egyptian Bedding

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: Siberian goose down
  • Outer shell: Egyptian cotton

Editor’s choice

Let’s take a couple of minutes to talk about what the Egyptian Bedding comforter has to offer. As you probably know by now, Egyptian cotton is considered to be one of the most luxurious types of cotton (aside from Pima, of course), which is why plenty of people like to use bedding sheets made with its fibers. This comforter is made with that specific type of cotton, which also promises a thread count of 1,200. From our own experience, that’s surely an overstatement, but the exaggerated marketing claim doesn’t affect the end price in this case, so we’ll let it pass.

The inside of the comforter is filled with goose down. While the manufacturer claims that it’s designed for all seasons, we do feel it tends to retain heat a lot, which makes it a much better choice for colder seasons only.

It comes with a square-box design, which is what you want in a comforter if you want to avoid cold spots and have the fill shifting from one side of the comforter to the other. Not only does that make you feel cold, but it’s also uncomfortable.

Pros:

  • Hypoallergenic.
  • Great for winter use.
  • Fluffy.
  • Filled with Siberian goose down.

Cons:

  • Too warm for summer use.
  • Noisy.

Who Should Purchase This?

This Egyptian Bedding down comforter is suitable for plenty of different buyers: those who want a quality product without paying hundreds of dollars for it, those who love the feel of cotton and the warmth that natural down provides, but also those who want to buy a comforter that received so much praise from the people who already use it.

buy now

APSMILE

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • Fill: European goose down
  • Outer shell: 60% cotton, 40% polyester

Best overall

The ASPMILE down comforter is our last choice for today: a product that comes in three different weight options: an all-season product, a lightweight product, and a heavyweight winter one. It is a comforter wrapped in an outer shell that combines Egyptian cotton and polyester, to make it more breathable. It promises a thread count of 1,600, but if you’ve read any of our past articles, you know how we feel about figures over 800.

But with that out of the way, we love everything about this product. It has a high fill power, meaning you’ll stay warm to the point of not wanting to get out of bed in the morning (still not sure if that’s a good thing or a bad thing). The comforter is Downpass and Oeko-Tex certified, at it is made with responsibly-harvested down and cleaned and sterilized to create a product safe for allergies.

It comes with eight corner tabs to make it easy to secure inside a duvet cover. You will also receive a duvet bag that makes it easy to store the comforter in a clean environment when you’re not using it.

Pros:

  • Soft.
  • Lightweight and comfortable to move under.
  • Corner loops.
  • Breathable outer shell.
  • Storage bag included.

Cons:

  • Offgassing.

Who Should Purchase This?

Why have we chosen this as the best down comforter at the moment? Because, for an average price, you get a quality product that’s fluffy, warm, and durable. This is the kind of comforter that you can’t go wrong with.

buy now

You may be interested in: Down Comforters VS Down Alternative

Bottom Line

Unlike other products, we believe that choosing a down comforter is way less complicated than choosing, let’s say, a new mattress. While your options are not limited by any means, with down comforters the sorting process it’s pretty simple. You can either opt for goose or down filling, while the highest-quality outer fabrics are bamboo, cotton, silk, and wool.

As long as you pay attention to details like the fill power of the comforter (the higher the fill power, the warmer the comforter will be) and the thread count of the outer shell (generally speaking, a thread count of 300 – 400 is more than enough to indicate quality fabric), the rest is all a matter of how much money you’re willing to spend.