Menu

Best Down Alternative Mattress Toppers

Your mattress should undoubtedly be the most comfortable place in your home. You can get the perfect night’s rest in your bed and be refreshed every morning for the new day. The perfect mattress is a one-time investment you should make in every seven or so years.

Your mattress, however, may decide to deteriorate in shape before that, which means you may experience discomfort. Buying an entirely new mattress may be too out of the way, so a more cost-effective solution is to invest in a mattress topper. Like an additional layer of plush softness, a topper can make an uncomfortable mattress comfortable once more.

Rank Product Highlights
#1 Pure Brands Mattress Topper and Pad Cover

CHECK PRICE

  • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Super Queen, King, California King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber
#2 SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper

CHECK PRICE

  • Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, California King
  • Interior Filling: HTMicrofiber
  • Exterior Fabric: 100% Cotton
#3 D & G DUCK AND GOOSE Store Overfilled Extra Thick Mattress Topper

CHECK PRICE

  • Sizes: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, Short Queen, King California King (with 2” and 3” options)
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative Gel Fiber
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber
#4 Marine Moon Mattress Topper

CHECK PRICE

  • Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber
#5 Royal Hotel Royal Plush Mattress Topper

CHECK PRICE

  • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cali King, Split King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Plush Fiber Microfiber Shell Cover
#6 LUCID Plush Alternative Fiber Topper

CHECK PRICE

  • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Super Queen, King, California King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber

Mattress Topper vs Mattress Pad

The misunderstanding between a mattress topper and a mattress pad is quite common. Many people believe them to be one and the same when truth is, they serve two different purposes.

What we are discussing is a mattress topper. Mattress toppers are made to be a layer of additional support and comfort. They are used to make a firm mattress softer and a soft mattress firmer. They make sleep more cloud-like after the mattress has run down. You can place your mattress toppers tucked away under the sheets, or as the name implies, on top of the mattress.

Mattress pads are another situation. Rather than prioritizing the comfort level of the mattress, these are made to protect the mattress so you don’t have to clean it as often. Stains, spills, dirt, damage, this is what the mattress pad prevents from reaching your mattress. They are typically thinner than mattress toppers to better fit underneath sheets, since this is the only way to install them.

Both a mattress topper and pad serve to prolong the life of a mattress, just in two different ways.

Why Buy a Mattress Topper?

A mattress topper may not be everyone’s cup of tea, but it does come in handy when your mattress is too firm or too soft. You may have bought a mattress only to realize you’re not settling into it quite as well as you’d like, and returning it isn’t an option. A smaller investment of a topper can fix that issue immediately. Older mattresses which aren’t the level of luxury they once were can be rejuvenated with a new fluffy topper.

Toppers are also a good idea if you need to travel or reside somewhere away from home for a longer while. Hostels, hotels, hospitals, these all have beds you won’t have direct control over but have to compromise for. A mattress topper of your own can make the stay much more comfortable.

Finally, there may be a dispute between you and your partner when it comes to firmness levels. In this case, one of you can use a mattress topper, so both of you can sleep soundly together.

Benefits of a Mattress Topper

A mattress topper can immensely improve the sleep surface you’re on, allowing for less or greater sinkage when you sleep. This makes it more immersive and beneficial, as your body aligns itself properly. There is greater support underneath you while you sleep, so you can wake up without aching and soreness.

Once again, this is the inexpensive solution to having two different preferences on the same bed. One person can purchase a mattress topper which meets their needs while the other can rest nicely on the original mattress. There is no need for two separate beds and there’s no loss in terms of closeness to one another.

A mattress topper creates minimal noise when you move around at night, unless it is a down topper. In this case, you can hear the ruffling of feathers within the stuffing. Otherwise, you can sit, toss, and turn without having to hear it all. Another benefit that goes in hand with this one is motion isolation. Your partner won’t wake up to your movements when the topper isolates surface movement.

Best of all, buying a mattress topper is so much less expensive than having to buy an entirely new mattress. You can relish in the comfort of a new bed without having to make the extensive investment.

Downfalls of a Mattress Topper

A mattress topper, being a thick additional layer to the bed, could make it harder to find sheets that will fit over it. The universal or standard sizes may prove to be too small for the topper as well as the mattress underneath. It also becomes difficult to move the mattress topper once it’s been fitted onto the mattress.

Adding a mattress topper to your bed can reduce the initial edge support of the mattress underneath. This makes it harder to sit on the edge, climb in and out of bed without disfiguring the topper. The level of improvement to your sleeping surface won’t be a miracle either. Not every topper will provide the same level of comfort. This depends on the material and the thickness of the actual topper.

Toppers made out of synthetic materials or foam can off-gas when you first receive them. Leaving them to air out or under the sun for a couple of hours is the best way to remove the odor. Toppers also are harder to maintain as most are not machine washable.

Why Buy a Down Alternative Mattress Topper?

Down goose and duck feathers are the utmost level of exquisite comfort, but not everyone can afford or handle down feathers. Some people may have a tighter budget while others may have allergic reactions to the material.

The next best alternative is down alternatives. This material doesn’t trigger allergies and comes at a much cheaper price. In some situations, you can even find a vegan option for toppers.

• Maintenance

Toppers are a little more complicated to maintain than mattress pads. When you install the topper, be sure to flatten it to the best of your ability so it fits underneath your covers. It’ll regain shape even when under them, it’s just easier for it to be relatively flatter when the covers go up.

Toppers may also come with a smell after being freshly opened from packaging, so give it a day or two to properly air out and regain its former shape.

Machine washing, though an option for some mattress toppers, isn’t the most ideal one. The better way to go about cleaning mattress toppers is by spot-cleaning them by hand or if possible, dry-cleaning. Washing machines could make the material shrink or unravel the stitching, even if the manufacturers say machine-wash is okay.

 

Best Down Alternative Mattress Toppers

1. Pure Brands Mattress Topper and Pad Cover

SPECS:

  • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Super Queen, King, California King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber

Pure Brands’ product is a combination of a mattress topper and pad. It has down alternative filling wrapped underneath a soft microfiber fabric for plush rest. This mattress topper is great for softening a stiff mattress. The thicker layer of softness will help alleviate unnecessary strain on your neck, shoulders, and back. The construction also allows for better airflow throughout the night and distributes heat to keep you cool while you sleep.

This topper is also a lightweight means of protection, though it would be wiser to partner it with a waterproof protector for maximum defense from stains, spills, and ruin. The topper can prevent perspiration, spills, stains, and bed-wetting from ever reaching the mattress.

The topper is fitted to cover mattresses 18” deep to prevent shuffling and provide a snug fit. It’s an easy, flexible mattress topper which can be folded, stored, and carried wherever and whenever needed. It provides annual comfort, no matter the weather. For cleaning, simply machine wash and tumble dry on low for maximum loft.

Pros Cons
  • Machine washable
  • Protection and additional comfort and support
  • Year-round comfort
  • Cool sleep
  • Sizes may be smaller than standard mattress sizes, purchase one size larger

Who Should Buy This?

There is nothing better than a two-in-one purchase. This mattress topper from Pure Brands combines the benefits and features of a mattress topper and a mattress pad into one durable product, now you’ll get the benefit of two means of protection under one affordable price tag.

CHECK PRICE

 

2. SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper

SPECS:

  • Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, California King
  • Interior Filling: HTMicrofiber
  • Exterior Fabric: 100% Cotton

Best Cooling Alternative Mattress Topper

Sleeping cool is sometimes the only way to sleep. If you can relate to this idea, then you’re looking for SPOAT’s Extra Thick Mattress Topper. With 50% more filling and HTMicrofiber filling throughout, you can sleep on fluffy clouds while still keeping sweat and heat at bay.

The double border pillow-top construction keeps all of the filling neatly in place, preventing long-term or resting deformation after you sleep on it. The filling is soft, breathable, and quiet so you can shuffle and shift without waking up your partner. The fabric material is 100% breathable cotton, which promotes consistent airflow throughout the night. You won’t wake up to a hot or sweaty mattress in the morning, or in the middle of the night.

This mattress topper can be fitted over a mattress 21” deep and stays securely in place. You won’t feel it shuffle around at night or slip off when you get up. You can machine wash the topper on a gentle cycle and tumble dry on low or simply sun-dry it. 

Pros Cons
  • Machine washable
  • Cooling Sleep
  • 50% more filling for softer sleep
  • Fits larger and thicker mattresses
  • Does not alleviate pains

Who Should Buy This?

If you’re looking for a long-term investment that will provide you with comfort all throughout the year, then SOPAT has just the mattress topper for you. Will cooling comfort, this mattress topper will help you sleep soundly every night you use it.

CHECK PRICE

 

3. D & G DUCK AND GOOSE Store Overfilled Extra Thick Mattress Topper

SPECS:

  • Sizes: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, Short Queen, King California King (with 2” and 3” options)
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative Gel Fiber
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber

Best Gel Fiber Down Alternative Mattress Topper

DUCK & GOOSE are the only option on our list to provide you with gel fiber down alternative filling. You can purchase your topper in a wide variety of sizes, in either 2” or 3” thickness. There is a milky white and white color to select from.

This topper is ideal for making firm mattresses softer and support your back while asleep. The outer cover material is skin-friendly so there’s no worry of rashes or itchy skin after use. The construction is both anti-bacterial as well as hypoallergenic for a safer sleep. The construction of the actual topper is a channel weave which permits greater levels of continuous airflow through the fabric. It removes moisture and heat from the surface of the mattress topper and disperses it throughout the night to prevent any build-up underneath you.

There are anchor bands to lock the mattress topper in place. The topper can fit over a mattress ranging from 6” to 22” in depth. For maintenance, machine wash this topper bi-annually in a front loader machine. Top-loader machines risk damaging the stitching. If you feel the topper is flat, then place it in tumble dry for a maximum of 20 minutes.

Pros Cons
  • Square stitching keeps the filling in place
  • Channel-weave construction promotes airflow
  • Anchor bands for a secure fit
  • Flattens out quickly, needs a tumble dry to fluff back up

Who Should Buy This?

Gel fiber is a whole new level of plush and soft. This mattress topper from D & G is ideal if you have an old mattress which has begun to sag and is need of some softening improvements.

CHECK PRICE

 

4. Marine Moon Mattress Topper

SPECS:

  • Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber

Premium Pick

Marine Moon’s mattress topper is an all-time favourite with higher quality and reliability fitted into their price. The interior filling is a down alternative while the outer cover is made from microfiber. It’s 50% thicker than most other mattress toppers for a more luxurious night’s rest.

This topper is made to cradle all sleeping positions and still offer pressure-point relief to your neck, shoulders, back, and hips, all vital areas in need of support when you sleep. The construction material is naturally breathable and allows a cooler sleep with each passing night. The surface of the topper will regulate temperature to ensure you’re never waking up drenched in sweat or shivering.

The topper uses a baffle-box pattern to keep the filling locked in place while 4 double anchor bands keep the entire piece from shifting or falling off the mattress. The topper can be placed on mattresses with an 18” depth.

Marine Moon provides customers with a 30-night risk-free trial to see if they’re satisfied with the product. Upon receival, leave the topper outside in the sun for a few days so it can regain its loft and shape. You can tumble dry the mattress topper for 20 minutes or leave it out in the sun if you feel it’s too flat.

Pros Cons
  • 30-night risk free trial
  • 4-anchor bands and baffle box pattern for stability
  • Year-round usage
  • 50% thicker than the average mattress topper
  • Shorter lifespan

Who Should Buy This?

There is nothing better than treating yourself to a good night’s rest. This mattress topper from Marine Moon is the perfect choice for you if you’re in desperate need for some stress-relieving, deep sleep.

CHECK PRICE

 

5. Royal Hotel Royal Plush Mattress Topper

SPECS:

  • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cali King, Split King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Plush Fiber Microfiber Shell Cover

Best Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Mattress Topper

The final option on our list comes from Royal Hotel. This mattress topper is filled with down alternatives and comes with a plush fiber microfiber shell cover. The interior filling is 100% down alternative fill for the most replicable touch of natural down.

There are 4 anchor bands located on the sides to keep the mattress topper in place once installed over the mattress. It can be fitted snugly on a mattress 8” to 18” in depth. The materials used in this topper permit it to be 100% hypoallergenic, perfect for customers keen on avoiding any potential allergic reactions, either from feathers or synthetic materials. It’s also machine washable for easier maintenance.

When you first receive the mattress topper, be sure to leave it outside to recover maximum loft. It’s also best to let it air out in the case of odors from being packaged.

Pros Cons
  • Hypoallergenic mattress topper
  • Machine washable
  • 4 anchor bands
  • May not fluff up to full size

Who Should Buy This?

One of the main reasons people tend to avoid real down bedding is because they trigger allergies! There is no doubt about the superior comfort of down however, which is why hypoallergenic alternatives such as Royal Hotel’s Plush Mattress Topper are made for those who don’t want that compromise on comfort for functionality.

CHECK PRICE

 

6. LUCID Plush Alternative Fiber Topper

SPECS:

  • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Super Queen, King, California King
  • Interior Filling: Down Alternative
  • Exterior Fabric: Microfiber

Best bargain option

The best thing about mattress toppers is the additional comfort, cushioning, and support they can give the sleeper; especially when its one like the LUCID Plush Alternative Fiber Topper with three inches of softness. The worst thing about mattress toppers is the fact that they can move around on the mattress and become quite uncomfortable. Luckily, the LUCID mattress topper we are looking at has thick SecureStrap elastic straps that keep the mattress topper in place, whether you roll around the bed all night looking for that one spot.

Fully hypoallergenic, this mattress topper has numerous air flow channels from the baffle box stitching method used to prevent dust and debris from gathering which can trigger allergic reactions along with respiratory irritation.

Another great thing about this one is the fact that it can be washed in your machine at home and dried in the dryer on low, adding another layer of convenience.

Pros Cons
  • 250 thread count 100% cotton percale cover provides durability and breathability
  • Can be fluffed by hand or through the clothes dryer to fill each pocket with additional air for comfort
  • No sharp odors that most mattress toppers have
  • Some customers reported loss of shape after continuous use within months

CHECK PRICE

 

Conclusion

A mattress topper could be the easy-way-out solution you need to save your mattress and wallet from another big investment. Mattress toppers help support you at night, make your bed more comfortable, and act as a light means of protection from spills and stains.

Down alternative is a tricky topic to handle since you’re comparing it to the king of comfort; down. If you have any comments or tips on handling down alternative, feel free to leave a comment below, and share this article with others who’d benefit from a more comfortable sleeping surface.

Photo credit: Andrey_Popov/Shutterstock