Menu

We found the best Memorial Day deals here.

The Best Down Alternative Comforters

Updated May 19, 2020

Commonly associated with cold winters and low temperatures, comforters are the coziest way to sleep in optimal thermal comfort. However, there are plenty of people who find it really comfortable to sleep under a comforter even during warmer summer months, provided they have chosen a product that excels at temperature regulation. Even if down comforters are considered to be the best option in terms of insulation and quality, sometimes down alternative is the way to go. Why is that and what are the best down alternative comforters right now? Read and find out!

Rank Product Highlights
#1

Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Available colors/patterns: 10
  • Cover: polyester blend
#2

Tuft & Needle Down Alternative Duvet Insert

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Available colors/patterns: 1
  • Cover: Cambric cotton
#3

Linenspa Down Alternative Quilted Comforter

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Oversized Queen, King, Cal King, Oversized King
  • Available colors/patterns: 12
  • Cover: microfiber
#4

Sleep & Beyond Organic Comforter

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin, Full/Queen, King, Crib
  • Available colors/patterns: 1
  • Cover: organic cotton sateen
#5

Silk Camel Luxury Comforter

buy now

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King, Cal King
  • Available colors/patterns: 1
  • Cover: cotton

Do You Want a Down Alternative Comforter?

Talking about down alternative comforters doesn’t really make much sense unless we compared them to those made from natural down. In fact, most of the benefits of choosing a down alternative comforter are only upside when you put them side-by-side with their natural counterparts. That being said, what are some of the main reasons why is down alternative such a frequent option for plenty of sleepers when natural down has better insulation and is, after all, natural?

But, first of all, what is a down alternative comforter, anyway? Down alternative is a filler material that is used to make bedding items such as pillows or comforters. While it does have some limitations, it is often chosen in favor of down because of features such as good price, hypoallergenic construction, and ease of maintenance. So, before you venture off and buy a down alternative comforter, here are five things that you should know about it:

  • Comforters that are made with natural down are expensive, and down alternative ones are considerably cheaper. Price is, therefore, one of the main reasons why people choose down alternative products instead of natural down.
  • One of the things that you’ll be sacrificing if you choose a down alternative comforter instead of a natural down one is the insulation. As a general rule, natural down has better insulation properties, which means that natural down comforters are warmer when compared to those filled with synthetic materials. Even so, down alternative comforters sometimes make up for this low warmth power by adding more fill compared to what you normally see in a natural down product.
  • While natural down is good, it can also trigger allergies in some people, which makes down alternative a safer option for people who have allergies.
  • For the most part, down alternative comforters are relatively easy to care for, at least easier when compared to the efforts you have to make to clean a natural down comforter. With a few exceptions, you can wash a down alternative comforter in your washing machine without the risk of damaging it.
  • One of the biggest cons of down alternative comforters that people should know about is that these aren’t as durable as those made with natural down. When you care for a natural down comforter, it can last a lifetime, but sadly, the same thing can’t be said for down alternative products.

What’s Inside a Down Alternative Comforter?

When you’re looking into comforters, you will often come across the concept of “fill material”. This refers to whatever is used inside the comforter itself (for instance, natural down comforters have… well, natural down inside their covers). Inside a down alternative comforter, you can find fill materials such as:

  • Polyester is one of the main materials that you’ll find in down alternative comforters. Being flexible, people have molded polyester to different lofts and weights, which makes it really easy to put inside different kinds of comforters. It is also the least expensive option, but it doesn’t sacrifice warmth as much as some people think.
  • Primaloft comforters are made with high-end synthetic fibers that are often compared to natural down when it comes to performance. Primaloft is known for being warm, lightweight, but also water-resistant.
  • Cotton comforters are also considered quality down alternative products because it’s soft and comfortable. It can also be produced at relatively low-costs, but cotton isn’t that big of a champion when it comes to insulating power.

  • Wool comforters are warmer and heavier, but the biggest surprise is finding out that wool comforters can also be breathable. But, because it provides great warmth and has moisture-wicking properties, it is also an expensive filler material, which makes wool comforters a rather costly choice.

  • Silk comforters also tend to be quite expensive. People choose silk comforters because they are lightweight, in spite of the fact that they lack the insulating properties that down comforters have.

What’s Outside of a Down Alternative Comforter?

Naturally, there has to be an outer shell that holds the fill together in one place, and that means that you should know what to expect in terms of the outer cover if your future down alternative comforter:

  • Down alternative comforters that are designed to be cheap will mostly have a shell made with some synthetic blend.
  • Cotton is the second most common choice for the outer shell of a down alternative comforter. Widely used in the textile industry, cotton is soft and breathable, but also easy to care for and quite durable, at least when compared to a polyester blend.
  • Some down alternative comforters come with a silk shell that’s very cool to the touch and have a unique feel to it. Sadly, silk is also a fabric that’s hard to clean and quite expensive for that matter.
  • Some comforters have a wool outer cover, which makes them breathable and great at wicking moisture. They are also warmer than the average comforter, but they also tend to be very expensive.

Top 5 Alternative Down Comforters

With a little bit of insight gained on the topic of what down alternative comforters are and what you can expect to find inside them, we can move forward to a list of some of the best options of 2020.

Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Available colors/patterns: 10
  • Cover: polyester blend

Label: bargain buy

Sleep Restoration has an affordable down alternative comforter that you’ll bound to love if you’re looking for a budget pick. Available in 10 different colors, this is a polyester-filled/polyester blend comforter available in all three standard sizes that every other similar product can be found in.

It is advertised as being a good solution for use all year round, but it feels more like a summer/fall comforter, as there are other thicker options available for colder seasons for those who want more insulation from a product in this category.

Even so, it is a hypoallergenic product that promises to deliver an allergy trigger-free environment for those who want to breathe at ease when they’re in bed. The comforter can be washed in a cycle with cold water and then tumble dried on low heat.

Pros:

  • 10 available colors.
  • Really good price.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Great for summer.

Cons:

  • Not very breathable.

Who Should Buy This?

Down alternative comforters are already a cheaper option compared to natural down ones, but if you’re in a situation where you’re looking to buy one of the most affordable products out there, Sleep Restoration can help you make that buying decision.

buy now

Tuft & Needle Down Alternative Duvet Insert

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Available colors/patterns: 1
  • Cover: Cambric cotton

Label: best luxury option

Tuft & Needle doesn’t just manufacture and sell those mattresses that we’ve all heard about, but they also make other bedding items. This alternative down comforter is an option worth considering if you’re interested in buying a luxury product, even if it’s filled with polyester.

With a Cambric cotton shell that feels super soft to the touch and quality polyester fill that won’t stick together, T&N’s down alternative comforter is available in a lightweight version (perfect for warmer months) but also a medium-weight one (great for winter use).

This quality down alternative comforter has two different constructions, depending on the option chosen. You get a sewn-through down alternative comforter if you buy the lightweight version, while the medium-weight version is made with a baffle-box construction. Both products come with corner loops that allow you to easily put the comforter inside a cover.

Pros:

  • Corner loops.
  • Two loft options.
  • Cambric cotton shell.
  • Oversized dimension.

Cons:

  • Expensive.

Who Should Buy This?

The Tuft & Needle down alternative comforter is a product for people who are willing to spend more money to acquire an item made by someone who truly knows their way around the bedding industry.

buy now

Linenspa Down Alternative Quilted Comforter

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Oversized Queen, King, Cal King, Oversized King
  • Available colors/patterns: 12
  • Cover: microfiber

Label: customer’s choice

The Linenspa down alternative comfort is quite the superstar. Available at a low price and getting lots of praise from its community of buyers, this down alternative comforter is an all-season product designed with corner and side loops to make it easier for you to secure it inside your favorite duvet cover.

It is filled with microfiber down that comes with a 300 gsm fill weight, which is pretty decent for all-around year use, unless your bedroom gets really cold in the winter and you need something that can provide you with better insulation. It features a box stitch design which is there to make sure you feel comfortable with the loft of the product, but also to avoid the fill from shifting from side to side.

You can wash it pretty much as you’d wash most down alternative comforters: just select a machine cycle that uses hot water and air dry on tumble dry low

Pros:

  • Customer favorite.
  • Good price.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Features corner and side loops.
  • Multiple color options.

Cons:

  • Seams could be better.

Who Should Buy This?

By far one of the best-rated products is this Linenspa down alternative comforter, making it a top choice for people who want a product that others have tested and approved of.

buy now

Sleep & Beyond Organic Comforter

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Full/Queen, King, Crib
  • Available colors/patterns: 1
  • Cover: organic cotton sateen

Label: best organic option

Made with certified organic Merino wool, the Sleep & Beyond comforter combines organic elements and a construction that makes a really nice luxury comforter, even if it’s not filled with natural down. Neatly covered in cotton sateen and having an outer shell with a count of 300, this is not your average budget comforter (yet again, few organic products are actually cheap).

When cared for properly, this is the kind of quality comforter that could last for decades and, as plenty of other customers have agreed upon, this product is in many ways even better than a natural down product.

The wool inside acts as a natural insulator that provides breathability and moisture-wicking properties during the summer and proper thermal insulation during the winter. Because it is naturally resistant to mildew, mold, and dust mites, it’s a great hypoallergenic product. For eco-friendly shoppers, we can state that the filling of this comforter comes from sustainable and renewable sources.

Pros:

  • Organic product.
  • Moisture-wicking properties.
  • Can last a lifetime.
  • 300 thread count.
  • Organic cotton outer shell.

Cons:

  • Expensive.

Who Should Buy This?

If you are preoccupied with buying organic bedding products that come from sources you can trust, if you want an organic product because you have sensitive skin, or if you simply want a high-quality down alternative comforter that’s made with wool, this is a great choice for you.

buy now

Silk Camel Luxury Comforter

Specs:

  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King, Cal King
  • Available colors/patterns: 1
  • Cover: cotton

Label: best silk option

Ready for the final product on today’s list? To mix things up and make this list as versatile as possible, we decided to check out what would be the best silk comforter out there. That’s how we came across Silk Camel, a luxury comforter with a product designed to be suitable for each of the four seasons.

The comforter is filled with mulberry silk in order to provide you with the very best silk fill that money can buy. Silk is a moisture-wicking product that manages to stay temperature neutral. It features a long zipper that actually allows you to inspect the quality of the fill, a nice touch that we believe shows the company stands by its product.

However, keeping in mind that silk can be a rather pretentious fabric, it’s important to know that this comforter is best cared for when spot cleaned and that tumble dry and bleaching should always be avoided. The cover is made entirely out of cotton, giving you the very best type of outer shell, with a soft and cool feel.

Pros:

  • Zipper for fill quality inspection.
  • A version for each season.
  • Moisture-wicking fill.
  • Cotton outer shell.
  • Naturally hypoallergenic.

Cons:

  • Requires spot cleaning.

Who Should Buy This?

If you want a luxurious silk comforter that feels extremely soft to the touch, is made with high-quality materials, and provides you with a sensation that only the cotton/silk combination can provide, then you have to check out the Silk Camel comforter.

buy now

Bottom Line

Buying the very best down alternative comforter is typically an issue of how much money you are willing to spend. Even if these comforters are generally less expensive compared to those filled with natural down, that doesn’t mean you can’t buy a down alternative product that costs a few hundred dollars.

You need to know what are the main differences between the fill materials that are typically used to make such a product so that you can understand what are the properties of each product that you come across and determine if that really is the best choice you can make. Even if we’ve shown you some of the market’s best down alternative comforters, you have plenty of other viable options to choose from, so make sure that allow yourself the time to do the research and explore as much as you feel the need to.