The Best Double Sided Pillow Tops Mattress Reviews

Once you learn what makes a good mattress for your sleeping habits and body configuration, mattress shopping can actually become an enjoyable process. We love buying new things, especially things that contribute to our comfort. It’s true that getting a new bed is a process that takes research, but the long-term benefits of having a comfortable and durable bed are enormous. While mattress manufacturers are constantly upping their game, a new type of bed arises the double-sided pillow top mattress. You can probably get a grasp of a pillow top just by analyzing the significance of each word. Having a pillow top mattress is basically having another comfort layer right at the top of the bed, kind of like a mattress topper that’s already sewn into the bed. Pillow tops offer more support compared to mattresses that lack this layer, but the rest of the bed’s construction is pretty much the same. 

Consider the pillow top layer as extra padding which makes the mattress feel different compared to what it would feel like without this layer. The padding can be made from a variety of different materials such as memory foam, latex, cotton, wool and synthetic fibers. We’ve put together a list of our top 5 recommendations for the best double-sided pillow top mattress you can find, so have a scroll through our suggestions and buyer’s guide below to determine which will be ideal for you and your sleeping needs.

Top Double Sided Pillow Top Mattress Reviews

What is a Pillow Top Mattress?

Pillow top mattresses are available in all the standard dimensions of a bed, ranging from Twin all the way to California King. Even if pillow-top mattresses are generally a more expensive compared to their regular counterparts, they’re still cheaper than buying a high-quality mattress topper.

While an amazing solution and go-to product for a lot of people, mattresses aren’t perfect for everyone, so let’s go through their main characteristics before you decide if this can be your future bed:

• Pillow top mattresses are extremely comfortable for people who want a softer bed, especially for side sleepers. The materials that are used to make this extra layer are really soft and comforting and can reduce pressure points significantly.
• Some people suggest that since they’ve started sleeping on a pillow top mattress, they are now experiencing fewer pains and aches.
• While affordable and comfortable, pillow-top mattresses aren’t as durable as regular beds. That’s because the materials that are sewn into this layer wear out/compress faster compared to those integrated into the comfort layers of other types of beds. When this happens, the pillow top loses a lot of its properties and becomes less effective.
• Pillow top mattresses aren’t good for overweight people. That’s because a good pillow top mattress is supposed to offer a plush top-side, which is generally not recommended for people who sport a few extra pounds. Because of the excess weight, having a softer mattress surface caused the body to sink into the bed way too much, making position-switching a lot more difficult.

What is a Double-Sided Mattress?

Generally speaking, most mattresses can only be used on one side, which makes them one-sided beds. Sure, in the past when people used those awful coil mattresses, they would flip the mattress to the other side at least once per year to prolong the lifespan of the bed.

This would help reduce visible signs of wear and tear, which was important considering that old mattresses didn’t have all the comfort levels we see today. With the first signs of wear, a few coils would likely poke you in the back while you were sleeping.

There are certain mattress manufacturers out there that have opted to include double-sided mattresses to their product line, for a variety of reasons. Some manufacturers have chosen to create a double-sided mattress with different firmness levels on each side.

The main advantage brought forth by this type of mattress is that you basically have two beds in one. The obvious disadvantage is that you can’t use both sides of the bed at the same time. There are companies out there, like Helix, which offer DUAL sided mattress, which isn’t the same thing as a double-sided one.

A dual-sided mattress offers two different firmness levels that can be used simultaneously by the one mattress. This means that you can sleep on a configuration that’s soft as a cloud, while your partner sleeps on the other half, which is firmer and more suitable for their sleeping position. 

What are the benefits of a double-sided mattress?

• Its cost is very similar to that of a one-sided mattress, but with the benefit of providing two beds in a single product. As a general note, double-sided mattresses will be a bit more expensive compared to one-sided beds because they’re made with more materials.
• It usually has a different firmness level on each side, so if there’s ever a time you need to switch between firmness options, you don’t have to pay more money to get a new bed.
• They’re also compatible with almost every type of platform bed, as well as adjustable beds.

However, there are some things that you should consider before buying a double-sided mattress. A lot of different articles will tell you that a double-sided mattress lasts longer than a one-sided bed. It makes sense if you consider that by flipping the mattress over, you are ensuring even weight distribution, thus significantly lowering wear and tear.

What most articles don’t tell you is that the durability of the mattress isn’t due to the fact you can flip it over; it’s a result of the construction and layering of the bed itself. A one-sided mattress made with a combination of natural high-quality latex and a sturdy innerspring core is bound to last longer than a double-sided mattress made of poor-quality memory foam layers.

The subject of mattress durability is often more complex than that. Theoretically speaking, it’s very possible to make a double-sided mattress last longer than a single-sided one. For example, if you’re a lightweight person and your sleeping partner weighs more, the comfort layers of the mattress will end up having a body impression, which is normal. Your side of the bed will have less, but your sleeping partner will have more visible indents.

When you flip the mattress over, you can make it so that your sleeping partner rests on what used to be your side, causing the mattress to wear out more evenly. With a trick like this, you can truly make your mattress last longer.

Another thing to keep in mind is that double-sided mattresses are heavier, which probably makes them unsuitable for people who sleep alone, or those who simply have no interest in turning the mattress over.

Conclusion

There are many benefits to sleeping on a pillow top mattress, but that doesn’t mean it will suit everyone. Those who need a pillow top are usually people who require additional comfort and more pressure point relief, which they can’t seem to get from bed without this feature.

Having a pillow top mattress that’s also double-sided means you can periodically flip the mattress over and get the same level of comfort on both sides of the bed. A lot of people love these mattresses because they last longer (although this isn’t a rule, as durability is influenced by a lot of different factors). After weighing up and comparing each of our top 5 suggestions for the best double-sided pillow top beds on the market, our favorite is the mattress from Nutan. This bed is ideal for those who struggle with orthopedic pain and need a cloud-like mattress to relieve their pressure points, as well as those who enjoy a higher loft and plush support in their bed. 

Recent Updates

June 22, 2021: Personal Comfort A8 and Spectra Organic mattresses have been replaced with the Nutan 12-Inch Medium Plush Double Sided Pillowtop Mattress and Mattress Solution Double Sided Pillowtop Innerspring Mattress as our top 1 and 2 products, due to unavailability of previous brands. A fifth product, Greaton Medium Plush Double Sided Pillowtop Mattress, has been added to round out our top 5 list.