Menu

Best Crib Sheets You Can Buy

Updated July 31, 2020

When it comes to finding the best crib sheets, it can be a gamble. You obviously want the best for your baby and when every brand claims to be the best of the best, things can become a bit overwhelming. You can always check out the customer reviews on products, but, until you’ve tried them out for yourself, you just can’t be sure. To take some of the guesswork out of crib sheet buying, we’ve explored some of the best brands out there and made a nifty list of the best of the best.

High-quality crib sheets are important because, not only will your baby or toddler be using them, but they can also protect a crib mat or mattress from any kind of spills, stains and dust. You want crib sheets that are soft, breathable and perfectly safe for your baby, especially if you have babies with sensitive skin or breathing issues such as allergies. We’ve compiled a list of features to review before you purchase your new crib sheets on important elements to look for.

Rank Product Highlights
 

#1

American Baby Company

BUY NOW

 

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 28 inches x 52 inches x 9 inches
  • Weight: 1.1 pounds
  • Warranty: N/A
 

#2

Burt’s Bees Baby

BUY NOW

 

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 6 inches
  • Weight: 4.8 ounces
  • Warranty: N/A
 

#3

Brolex

BUY NOW

 

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 52 × 28 × 9 inches
  • Weight: 14.4 ounces
  • Warranty: Money back guarantee
 

#4

TILLYOU

BUY NOW

 

  • Material: Microfiber
  • Product Dimensions: 52 × 28 × 8 inches
  • Weight: 7 ounces
  • Warranty: 30-day Money back guarantee
#5

AmazonBasics

BUY NOW

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 52 × 28 × 9 inches
  • Weight: 11.2 ounces
  • Warranty: One-year warranty from the manufacturer

Crib Sheet Features

No two crib sheets are made alike, as so many different brands offer so many different features. If your baby has sensitive skin, always make sure to check out the product components, especially if your child has an allergy to plastics or other textiles. Once you narrow down your search, you’ll be better suited to look for your exact specifications in crib sheets.

— Waterproof

A waterproof crib sheet is a great idea, especially if you have a young child that you are trying to potty train. Diapers alone sometimes can’t protect a crib mattress against potential stains, so if you add a waterproof crib sheet into the mix, you could very well be adding that extra level of protection. While some waterproof sheets may not be as soft as others, there are plenty of different brands that make waterproof crib sheets differently.

Some have a plastic layer underneath the actual sheet, while others make waterproof blended sheets that incorporate water-wicking materials into the actual fabric. You just have to look around and decide which waterproof crib sheet would be best for you and your child.

— Organic Cotton

Organic cotton crib sheets are great for babies with allergies or sensitive skin. These blends are organic, so that means that there are no added pesticides, rubber, plastic or any other kind of chemicals or components that could harm extra sensitive skin.

While organic cotton crib sheets may be a bit pricier, you’ll know exactly what is going into your crib sheets and you can worry less about the potential of harmful chemicals seeping into your baby’s skin. This is extra important for babies who already have compromised immune systems or delicate lungs due to asthma or other breathing issues.

— Regular Cotton

If your baby doesn’t have extra sensitive skin and is overall pretty indestructible, regular cotton crib sheets will definitely save you monetarily and are really easy to care for. Cotton sheets can be thrown in the washer and dryer with no problems and are usually really durable so these will more than likely be built to last. You can find cotton crib sheets in almost every department store that sells baby items, and there are so many amazingly cute prints that come in regular cotton sheets. Popularity wise, cotton crib sheets are pretty much the universal staple for cribs.

— Jersey Knit

Jersey knit sheets are just as great as cotton sheets, but with a little extra softness and coolness. These sheets are ideal for the spring and summer months as they are highly breathable and are super easy to clean and wash. These are just a bit more delicate than regular cotton crib sheets, so be sure to check your packaging’s washing care before you just toss them in the washing machine. Since jersey knit sheets are thinner, a little extra precaution may need to be taken, especially if you want to use your dryer on these sheets.

— Protective Mattress Pads

If you want the versatility of super cute crib sheets, but still want that extra protection or softness for your baby, you might want to look into protective mattress pads. Just like regular mattress covers for adults, these protective mattress pads are great to use underneath the baby’s crib sheets. These go on easily, like a fitted sheet, and will add some extra softness into your baby’s bed along with that extra protection you’re going to need.

These also can be tossed in the washing machine and used in a standard household dryer, but you’re always going to want to check out those washing instructions beforehand. Protective mattress pads are great if you want to preserve a mattress yet keep using cotton or jersey knit sheets with fun patterns.

 

The Top Five Crib Sheets Review

While there are hundreds of potential crib sheets you could buy, we’ve weeded out the best of the best, complete with specifications to help you narrow down your search. While every family is different, these are some of the most popular and most positively reviewed crib sheets that you can find online right now. Best yet, is you can purchase these immediately! Happy shopping!

 

1. American Baby Company 2 Pack 100% Cotton Value Jersey Knit Fitted Crib Sheet

SPECS:

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 28 inches x 52 inches x 9 inches
  • Weight: 1.1 pounds
  • Warranty: N/A

Best value crib sheets

American Baby has come up with the best bang for your buck. These convenient packages come with two jersey knit fitted crib sheets instead of one, saving you on money and time. Two are always better than one, and for the price that American Baby is offering, you might just want to buy several packages in several different fun prints they offer!

These great crib sheets are 100 percent cotton jersey and are super soft. These sheets offer a warm, tee shirt like feel for that extra level of comfort for your baby. Best yet is the variety. There are so many amazing color patterns and prints to choose from, you might just want to change out these sheets every few days just to be able to show them off. These will easily be incorporated into any kind of theme you have or want to try out.

These crib sheets come with nine-inch-deep pockets and elastic trim to fit securely around a standard crib mattress. These are also standard machine washable and dryable. This brand offers a truly great selection at an even more amazing price, so you just can’t go wrong with American Baby crib sheets.

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Soft jersey cotton fabric
  • Comes in multiple colors and prints
  • Comes two to a package
  • May be too thin for some cribs

Who should buy these?

Anyone who loves that jersey cotton feels with the added versatility of cute prints and colors. Also, anyone who likes to buy in value as these sheets come two in a package.

CHECK AMAZON PRICE

 

2. Burt’s Bees Baby – Fitted Crib Sheet

SPECS:

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 6 inches
  • Weight: 4.8 ounces
  • Warranty: N/A

Best organic crib sheets

Burt’s Bees is famous for its organic, fresh products, so you could expect no less from their amazing crib sheets. These sheets come in some really great colors and everything put into them is organic. With a name like Burt’s Bees, you have a standard to uphold and these sheets definitely hold up to that standard.

These are solid colored fitted crib sheets made with premium elastic to provide that extra stretch you need in order to make flush, snug fit over mattresses. When you have small babies, a snug and strong fit is crucial to prevent any accidents or the baby getting tangled up in loose sheets. There is an extra fabric overlap at the bottom edge of these sheets on top of the 360-degree elastic which prevents sheets from creeping up on the actual mattress. These added extra precautions are designed to let you and your baby rest easier.

Pros Cons
  • 100 percent organic
  • Organic cotton
  • Comes in multiple colors
  • Extra snug fit
  • Maybe a bit pricey for some

Who Should Buy This?

These are 100 percent organic, and GOTS certified with breathable cotton – ideal for a baby’s thin and porous skin. These crib sheets are perfect for standard cribs and toddler mattresses.

CHECK AMAZON PRICE

 

3. Stretchy Fitted Crib Sheets Set-Brolex 2 Pack Portable Crib Mattress Topper

SPECS:

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 52 × 28 × 9 inches
  • Weight: 14.4 ounces
  • Warranty: Money back guarantee

Best stretchy crib sheets

Brolex has made some super cute, extra stretchy crib sheets that come in a nifty two-pack. These packs offer two separate crib sheets with fun designs that can be easily incorporated into a preexisting theme or as a standalone. With the extra stretch to these sheets, these crib sheets are sure to easily and effectively fit over any standard sized crib mattress.

These crib sheets fit most standard sized crib mattresses due to their extra stretchiness and high-quality construction. These are ultra-soft jersey knit sheets which are really great for baby’s skin. These are so soft they help prevent any kind of rashes or skin infections, which babies are prone to. These crib sheets are also machine washable, so you can easily toss them into your home washer and dryer whenever they need to be cleaned.

Due to the elastic bottom of these sheets, these crib sheets can be applied to mattresses or mattress toppers in sheer seconds. These are also guaranteed to stay in place, so you don’t have to worry about these sheets creeping up on top of the mattress or bunching up. If you are not one hundred percent satisfied with these crib sheets, the company guarantees your money back with absolutely no hassles at all.

Pros Cons
  • Super stretchy design for easy use
  • Soft jersey cotton fabric
  • Elastic bottom for extra stretch
  • Comes two to a package
  • May be too thin for some cribs

Who should buy this?

Anyone who likes an extra stretchy, super soft jersey knit sheet that is easy to clean and care for.

CHECK AMAZON PRICE

 

4. TILLYOU Microfiber Silky Soft Crib Sheet

SPECS:

  • Material: Microfiber
  • Product Dimensions: 52 × 28 × 8 inches
  • Weight: 7 ounces
  • Warranty: 30-day Money back guarantee

Best overall crib sheets

TILLYOU microfiber silky soft crib sheets are the best bang for your buck and the best quality for your baby. These are luxurious, super soft sheets that are easy to use, come in fun colors and won’t cost you too much money. These are top-rated sheets that are ideal for baby’s sensitive skin and hair.

These are made of 100 percent extra fine brushed microfiber fabric which makes these sheets exceptionally silky and smooth. This means no rough sheets to scratch up babies’ skin or pulls hair. This also helps with tangles in the hair and unwanted frizz, which also helps reduce a baby’s hair loss over time.

All products by TILLYOU is CPSIA passed and CPSC standard approved. This means these sheets will lull your baby to a comfortable and cozy sleep while being thoroughly protected. These will fit standard crib mattresses and toddler mattresses. They come with an elastic band around all four sides of the sheet in order to make them fit easier. There are also elastic trims and 8-inch-deep pockets for accessibility. These are fade resistant and quick-drying, so you don’t need to fuss with these. These also come with a 30-day money-back guarantee from the manufacture.

Pros Cons
  • Made of super soft microfiber
  • Extra elastic for an easy fit
  • Up to safety standards for babies
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • May be too soft for some

Who should buy this?

Anyone who needs extra soft sheets that only microfiber can provide or anyone who needs easy to maintain sheets.

CHECK AMAZON PRICE

 

5. Amazon Basics Heather Jersey Fitted Crib Sheet Bedding

SPECS:

  • Material: Cotton
  • Product Dimensions: 52 × 28 × 9 inches
  • Weight: 11.2 ounces
  • Warranty: One-year warranty from the manufacturer

Best basic crib sheets

Amazon Basics brings their customers the best basic crib sheets which are easy to use, easy to clean, and easy to mix and match. These sheets are made of cotton, are extremely comfy and will be sure to be your baby’s best bet when it comes to basic crib sheets.

These sheets are made of 100 percent imported cotton with a cotton jersey for extra comfort. These are perfect for any nursery setting and the colors are easy to integrate with any sort of décor. This jersey knit fabric provides slight stretch and the softness is similar to an old tee shirt. The colors within this brand are easy to incorporate with baby blankets, stuffed animals and other nursery furniture.

These are machine washable and can be thrown into the dryer on low for convenient cleaning. These will fit standard crib mattresses up to six inches thick. These also meet safety and environmental standards, so there’s extra reassurance for you and your baby.

Pros Cons
  • Made of cotton and jersey cotton
  • Fits standard mattresses
  • Great basic crib sheets
  • Easy to clean and dry
  • May not come in enough colors

Who should buy this?

Anyone who wants a basic crib sheet that is easy to use and easy to incorporate with existing nursery or bedroom décor.

CHECK AMAZON PRICE

 

The Wrap Up

There you have it: some of the best crib sheets you can find in the market and buy right now. Whether you want a crib sheet with a fun pattern or design, or you want to make sure you are getting super soft, organic products for your baby, we have the best of all worlds within this list. Since these are the best of the best, you can rest assured that these sheets will provide your baby with a good night’s rest and will keep the family reassured of safety quality.

You can’t lose with any of these great crib sheets, all you have to do is decide which crib sheet is the best for you. If you still aren’t’ too sure, try looking at some of the customer reviews, or you can always call up customer service with your own questions to get answers from the manufacturing professionals. There are tons of resources to utilize and most of these manufactures would be happy to provide any extra information.