Best Cotton Comforters
When it comes to blankets, comforters, and duvets, there are few fabrics as desirable as cotton for the job. That’s why there are so many comforters on the market made out of cotton. But when you have so many available, how do you know which one is the best or the right one for you?
It’s important to know what you need to look for in order to make the right choice. This buying guide can help you make an educated purchase and provide you with some recommendations, so you can rest assured you’ll be satisfied with whichever one you choose.
| Rank | Product | Highlights |
| #1 |  Egyptian Cotton All-Season Goose Down Comforter
|
|
| #2 |  Eddie Bauer Multi-Season Cotton Comforter
|
|
| #3 |  Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter
|
|
| #4 |  APSMILE Luxury Goose Down Comforter
|
|
| #5 |  Utopia Bedding
|
|
Table Of Contents
- What You Should Know
- — The Benefits of Buying A Cotton Comforter
- Comforters vs. Duvets
- Features to Look for in a Comforter
- — Fill type
- — Fill weight
- — Fill Power
- — Size
- — Style
- — Care options
- Best Cotton Comforters Reviews
- 1. Egyptian Cotton Factory Outlet Store All-Season Goose Down Comforter
- 2. Eddie Bauer Multi-Season Cotton Comforter
- 3. Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter
- 4. APSMILE Luxury Goose Down Comforter
- 5. Utopia Bedding
- Conclusion
What You Should Know
This buying guide will cover the basics of cotton comforters and what to look for in them, as well as why you might want to buy one.
— The Benefits of Buying A Cotton Comforter
The first question you might have that comes to mind is why cotton? There are many upsides to using cotton as a cover when you sleep but what exactly are they?
First off, cotton is a very soft fabric. It doesn’t feel rough or itchy, especially when well-woven or using higher quality long fiber cotton.
It is also very breathable, helping you wick away moisture like sweat to keep you comfortable and cool.
This high breathability from cotton allows it to be used comfortably all year round, and there are multiple weave types that provide comfort for more specific seasons as well.
Plus, cotton is an ideal material to use for comforters because it’s warm, soft, and breathable so you get the ideal, most well-rounded comfort when you sleep.
Comforters vs. Duvets
Sometimes there’s confusion between comforters and duvets, often concerning the difference between them or if there is a difference at all. To avoid any inconveniences caused by misconceptions it’s better to be able to clearly tell them apart.
Comforters and duvets are both covers and filled with either down or synthetic fibers for insulation. They work both in function and in decoration, though duvets are usually plain white and are designed to be put into a cover, much like a pillow and its case. Comforters, on the other hand, are essentially quilted blankets that are either plain or colored in print.
In both cases, most duvet covers and comforters are dry-cleaning only while a few can be machine washed. You can wash the duvet cover less often, because duvet covers can be easily removed, and machine washed.
Features to Look for in a Comforter
— Fill type
There are two main types of fill to comforters: down and synthetic alternatives to down. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, though it’s ultimately up to a preference for which one you choose.
Down filling is a superior fill in general as well as in comforters. It’s very warm and effectively insulating so you’ll never feel cold at night. Down is also incredibly lightweight, giving the comforter a comfortable amount of breathability to avoid sweating despite being so warm.
Down-filled comforters do tend to be pricier, as down is often used for higher quality products. If your comforter is down-filled, you can’t machine wash it and it has to be dry-cleaned. Though there are hypoallergenic options being made now, down may trigger asthma attacks or allergic reactions.
Synthetic fills are usually made from fibers of cotton, rayon, or polyester. They are generally less expensive than down, and are hypoallergenic. They are not animal-derived like down is, meaning they count as an ethical vegan option. Synthetic-filled comforters are for the most part machine washable making them easier to clean than a dry-clean only down comforter.
It is difficult to match the warmth quality in down fill using synthetic alternatives, so a lot more synthetic fill would have to be used in order to achieve the same amount of warmth. The result is lower breathability, and a higher chance of waking up sweaty.
— Fill weight
The amount of weight down in your comforter (measured in ounces) is the fill weight. It is one of the deciding factors in the comforter’s warmth and breathability. You’ll notice that higher-quality down fill comforters will often have relatively lower weights, but that also depends on the fill power.
— Fill Power
In short, fill power is how much space an ounce of down fill takes up. It measures how fluffy the fill is. It’s a very important factor when deciding on your comforter as it depends on how warm you need it to be. The higher the fill power, the higher the down quality and the warmer the comforter.
There are general guidelines to the fill power and general warmth, so you can more easily determine the best one for your needs:
- 400 and less is ideal for summer or those who sleep warm.
- Between 400 and 600 is the most versatile and can be used year-round.
- Between 600 and 800 is better for the colder part of the year or for people who feel colder in their sleep.
- 800 and higher is super warm and best for extreme cold.
— Size
Of course, you want a comforter that properly fits over your bed when not in use, so be sure to check the dimensions of your bed. Not every queen-sized frame is made the same, so find a comforter with dimension specifications that are acceptable for your situation. You decide whether you want a comforter that just fits over the top or an oversized one that will drape over the sides for some style.
— Style
This is up to personal preference and the design of your room. Comforters come in a variety of colors and patterns, so it wouldn’t be difficult to find one that fits the aesthetic theme of your bedroom. You can’t really change the design as much as a duvet and its many covers, so it may be appropriate to find a style that fits various themes or you won’t be tired of.
— Care options
Before purchasing your comforter, check the cleaning instructions and recommendations for an ideal option. You don’t want one that only recommends spot cleaning. Instead, find one that can be machine washed, or dry cleaned if you want to pay extra for a quality clean.
If you find a machine washable comforter, follow the instructions given to ensure a longer life and maintain its initial quality.
Best Cotton Comforters Reviews
1. Egyptian Cotton Factory Outlet Store All-Season Goose Down Comforter
Specs:
- Sizes: Twin, Queen, King
- Fill: 100% cotton
- Fill power: 750
- Machine wash: Not recommended
Best Overall
This luxurious bed comforter is one of the best cotton comforters you can find. It exceeds in overall comfort and quality with features you’d find in a far more expensive premium comforter.
The cover is made with 100% Egyptian cotton, very high-quality cotton known for its durability and soft smooth feel. The 1200 thread count makes it feel even softer and keeps your comforter nice and breathable at the surface level.
It’s tightly woven and double stitched to be down-proof, avoiding fill leakage and itching. The material of the cover is naturally hypoallergenic and safe for your skin from dust, mites, or mold.
As for beneath the surface, this comforter has a medium weight goose down fill with a fill power of 750 to keep you cozy (but not too hot) no matter the weather.
The pinch pleated style of the comforter will give your bed a timeless look when laid out, giving the illusion of an extra lofty and plush sleeping arrangement. Baffled box stitch construction makes sure that the fill is even throughout and avoids any shifting that would lead to lumps. It also allows for a nice even distribution of warmth.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy This?
This is the best overall mattress if you’re looking for high quality and value. It offers a premium quality using materials unmatched in reputation.
2. Eddie Bauer Multi-Season Cotton Comforter
SPECS:
- Sizes: Queen (90″ x 90″), King (104″ x 90″)
- Fill: Goose Down
- Fill power: 600
- Machine wash: Yes
Best Year-Round Comforter
This premium quality cotton comforter from Eddie Bauer is made to be just the right temperature for any time of the year. Forget the constant shift between quilts and thin blankets and you cycle through the seasons, and get yourself the best year-round comforter instead.
Made with 100% cotton and a thread count of 300, this comforter is just the right amount of warmth, softness, and breathability on the surface. The down fill with a power of 600 is just right to keep you comfortable whether you sleep warm or cold, or whether it’s winter or summer outside.
The Multi-Season Comforter is sized down and features a striped white design for a stylish and simplistic modern look that doesn’t hang too far off your bed. The lofty baffle box construction will keep your comforter nice and fluffy for time to come.
Taking care of your comforter is easy as it’s both machines washable and dryable, so there’s no need to take it to the dry cleaners.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy This?
If you’re willing to pay for a quality comforter that’ll keep you covered and comfortable all year round, the Eddie Bauer Multi-Season Comforter is an excellent choice for you.
3. Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter
SPECS:
- Sizes: Twin, Queen, King
- Fill: Siberian Goose Down
- Fill Power: 750
- Machine Wash: Not mentioned
Most Luxurious
The Egyptian Bedding comforter has just what you look for in a high-end comforter: top-quality materials and stitching, premium durability and comfort, and safety for anyone to use. Made to be used in venues like world-class five-star hotels, you know you’re getting a quality you’ll love.
Cased in 100% Egyptian cotton and a 1200 thread count, this comforter feels high-end to the touch and is breathable enough to wick away unwanted moisture. It’s hypoallergenic and incredibly soft and gentle to your skin, so those with allergies and sensitive skin don’t have to worry.
You can avoid cold spots with an even heat distribution thanks to the comforter’s Baffle box design. The double-needle stitch and piping ensure that nothing falls apart or out of the comforter.
The comforter’s fill is a 100% luxury Siberian goose down that provides year-round comfort, especially warmth when needed. The 750-fill power makes this luxurious comforter perfect for colder temperatures and breathable enough for the rest of the year.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy This?
Those looking to spend more on the best quality product in a reasonable price range will love this luxurious pillow from Egyptian Bedding.
4. APSMILE Luxury Goose Down Comforter
SPECS:
- Sizes: Twin, Queen, King
- Fill: Goose Down
- Fill Power: 650
- Machine wash: No
Best Organic
This heavyweight and the all-organic comforter is a premium-quality option for the cold sleeper or areas where winters can get very cold. It’s made with 100% OCS Standard organic cotton and filled with ethically sourced premium quality goose down for the best possible warmth and comfort.
For the concerned buyer, there’s no need to fret over the use of chemicals. Everything is naturally sourced, and no bleach or dye was used so you know it’s safe for your skin. This comforter is hypoallergenic and environment friendly with certifications from third-party organizations and standards for the utmost quality.
The baffle box design gives the comforter a nice even and lofty feel, while the high fill power insulates heat well without being too suffocating. The high thread count of 1200 ensures that the comforter feels smooth and soft against your skin. This comforter version designed for winter is made for keeping you warm in nights under 57 degrees.
In terms of care, the comforter is spot and dry-clean only.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy This?
For the concerned organic buyer, the cold sleeper, or anyone who needs adequate covering in harsh cold winters and climates, the APSMILE Luxury Goose Down Comforter is the perfect comforter for the job.
5. Utopia Bedding
SPECS:
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
- Fill: Siliconized fiberfill
- Fill Power: Not mentioned
- Machine Wash: Yes
Budget Pick
The Utopia Bedding comforter is a great value product that covers your basic needs without advertising the need for anything extra, and it offers good quality for anything in its price range.
Available in plenty of sizes ranging from Twin to California King, you can find the right size comforter for everyone in the family, and replace them easily once they’re outgrown. A fairly durable construction, including box-style stitching and piped edges, ensures this comforter (and its fill) will last you a while. The synthetic fill of this comforter won’t shift around and clump up as easy.
The Down alternative fill is made up of siliconized fiber that’s thin enough to keep a familiar softness and have a comfy feel. At 350 GSM, this comforter hardly feels heavy and is easy to breathe through.
The Utopia Bedding Comforter is available in a small variety of stylish solid colors, so you can customize it to better match your room.
This comforter is also machine washable for easy care.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy This?
Anyone looking for a comfortable comforter without having to spend too much will really appreciate the price tag this piece comes at. In fact, it’s priced so that you can even buy a couple of these without feeling any burden on your wallet.
Conclusion
A comforter might be just the thing you need to help have a better, more comfortable sleep. The right comforter for you is out there and can be found – you just have to know where and what to look for, so you find the perfect one with little hassle. Be sure to always check customer and critic reviews, so you can get opinions from previous users of the product you’re looking for.