Unless you already have a garage-full of old holiday decorations, adding that color and warmth to your home can be very expensive. That’s where throw pillow covers come in.
Even if nothing else in your home is ready for the season, your beds, sofas, and windowsills can be. Just slip some pillow covers onto your favorite throw pillows, arrange them in a manner you see fit, and watch how your living room goes from normal to…Thanksgiving-Christmas-New Years!
Today, we’re going to cover the top five buffalo check pillow covers. Buffalo check is a pattern similar to plaid, featuring large, checkered patterns that add layers of warmth and comfort to your home. We think they’ll all look gorgeous in your living room, but the best one is for you to decide.
| Rank | Product | Highlights |
| #1 |  JOHOUSE Red and Black Buffalo Check Covers
|
|
| #2 |  4TH Emotion Set of 2 Christmas Buffalo Check Covers
|
|
| #3 |  Tatuo 6 Pieces Christmas Buffalo Check Cover
|
|
| #4 |  Anickal Set of 2 Fall Buffalo Check Covers
|
|
| #5 |  4TH Emotion Set of 2 Fall Thanksgiving Farmhouse Buffalo Check Cover
|
|
Things You Should Know Before Buying a Pillow Cover
While pillow covers make holiday decorating easy, there are a few factors you should keep in mind while shopping for one. These include the materials they’re made from, whether you have the correct pillow insert size or need to buy a different one, and how to care for your new covers.
For your convenience, here’s a brief overview of what to expect from your pillow cover and what to look for in a quality product.
— Fabric and Fill Materials
Before purchasing a pillow cover, make sure that it’s made with high-quality materials. Life happens, and we all know that this doesn’t always fare well for our furniture or décor! You don’t want to lose your charming cover before the season’s over. Here, we’ll break down which materials are best for the fabric of your pillow cover.
There are three options that tend to outrank others:
- Cotton-linen blends
- Polyester
- Velvet
These are materials that hold up well against regular use, while offering both style and comfort. In addition, cotton-linen blends and polyester are particularly easy to wash and care for.
— Pillow Inserts
One thing that many new pillow cover buyers struggle with is the pillow inserts. To get you started on the right foot, we’ll quickly break down a couple of things you need to know about pillow inserts.
What is an insert?
An insert simply refers to the pillow itself. If you have throw pillows already, simply measure them and use the charts available from many manufacturers to determine what cover size you’ll need. If you don’t already have throw pillows, you’ll need to purchase them separately from the covers. To do this, it’s crucial that you pick the correctly sized inserts for the covers you’re getting (and vice-versa). You can take a look at your living space to decide what sizes and shapes you want your throw pillows to be; this will make the process easier for you in the long run!
— Sizing
There’s no single rule for how to size your insert compared to the size of the cover. That said, you need to purchase an insert that is bigger than the cover. Experts agree that an insert 1 to 2 inches larger is a good reference point. The exact size you’ll need depends on factors such as the material of the insert, what look you’re going for, and your intended use for the throw pillows. Many manufacturers have sizing recommendations on their website or product listing pages to help you out.
— Materials
The type of material you opt for will depend on your budget, your personal preferences, and your intended use for the throw pillows. If you’re able and willing to spend a little more, down and faux-down fills are the best option; they provide soft comfort, are long-lasting, and work particularly well with covers. If you’re on a tighter budget or are looking for a firmer, more supportive pillow, poly-cotton and non-woven fills may better suit your needs.
How to Wash
Life happens: drinks are spilled, pet fur gets everywhere, and people are touching those pillows all day long. A common concern amongst new pillow cover buyers is whether their covers can be washed—and if so, how easy it is.
This depends on the type of material your cover is made of. If your cover consists of cotton or polyester, it should be pretty easy to wash; these materials can usually be thrown into the washer with no problems. For other materials, you’ll need to take more caution. Handwashing is always a safer bet than assuming something is machine-washable.
In addition, if your cover has any special bells and whistles (such as the pompom lining on the final product of our list), handwashing is definitely the way to go.
When in doubt, you can always check the manufacturer’s website, see the pillow cover tag for washing directions, or contact the manufacturer directly.
Best Buffalo Check Pillow Covers
Still not sure where to look for the throw pillow covers you need? No problem. We’ve done a lot of the research for you and have handpicked five fantastic buffalo check covers. These are covers made with quality materials, all available at an affordable price.
1. JOHOUSE Red and Black Buffalo Check Plaid Throw Pillow Covers
SPECS:
- Materials: Cotton and Polyester
- Washing: Can hand wash or machine-wash
- Size: 18” X 18”
- Color: Red and Black
The red and black buffalo check pattern on these covers will add a hint of winter festivity to any room. Whether you’re looking to get your home décor in-line with the season or want to lend your living room a rustic air, these pillow covers from JOHOUSE are sure to please.
They’re made with cotton and polyester, which makes them both practical and comfortable. Did one of your covers get a bit battered during the Thanksgiving football game? Simply remove the cover and throw it in the washing machine! You and yours will also love the soft, clean feel of the material while holding it tight during a Hallmark movie or resting your head after a long day of social gatherings.
An invisible zipper and colorfast design ensure that these pillow covers will look good for a long time. No awkward zipper hanging from the pillow when guests come over, and no more worrying about how long the color will last!
While these covers do have limited size and color options, we think you’ll love having them grace your sofa or bed.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy It?
Anyone looking for a versatile pillow cover that’s great for any occasion and will look great years down the road.
2. 4TH Emotion Set of 2 Christmas Buffalo Check Plaid Throw Pillow Covers
SPECS:
- Materials: Polyester/Cotton blend
- Washing: Can hand wash or machine-wash
- Size: Available in 7 sizes
- Color: Available in 4 colors
Really, all you need to spice up your living room for the holidays are a couple of well-placed throw pillows. This quality set of 2 makes things even easier for you by providing four color options and seven size options—no matter what look you’re going for or what decorations you already have out, you’re sure to find a cover that works with everything perfectly.
These covers are made with an eco-friendly cotton-polyester blend and feature overlocked seams. This means that you can rest assured all holiday season long that your covers will hold out against everyday stressors. And this includes spills and crumbs! The seam design ensures that you can wash the covers as needed in the washing machine, not worrying for a moment that they’ll rip or tear. So you can eat your Thanksgiving dinner with peace of mind—even after the little ones ask to eat on the sofa!
The covers also feature an invisible zipper design, ensuring a smooth and clean appearance.
Best of all, 4TH Emotion offers a 3-month warranty guaranteeing free replacements should the quality not be up-to-par for any reason.
Convinced yet? If not, just head over to its Amazon page and read what others have said!
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy It?
Anyone who wants an attractive pillow cover set that’s good for the environment and made to last.
3. Tatuo 6 Pieces Christmas Buffalo Check Pillow Cover
SPECS:
- Materials: Polyester Peach
- Washing: Machine-wash cold without bleach; tumble dry on low
- Size: 18” X 18”
- Color: Each pillow in the set has a different color; all feature black, white, gray, red, or green
Are you willing to spend a few extra dollars for a top-notch set of pillow covers this holiday season? If so, this six-piece set from Tatuo may be right up your alley.
These festively colored covers will complement any Christmas decorations you happen to have out already and will fill your home with a lighthearted spirit. From white and red checks to those with a touch of holiday green, each of these six covers features a different color pattern to offer you diversity and vibrancy as you start decorating.
Made with a soft polyester peach material, these covers promise comfort and years’ worth of use. ‘Peachskin’ materials like this are known for their durability against tearing and wrinkling, so you don’t have to worry about your upcoming family gathering getting a little rowdy or the cat decided to take a nap on your favorite cover. In addition, you can easily machine-wash (and dry) these covers at any time.
Like the other covers on this list, this set from Tatuo features an invisible zipper design to ensure unfettered elegance all season long.
Not sure this set is right for you? See what others have said about their experience with it. (Believe us, people are loving it!)
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy It?
Anyone who wants a truly high-quality pillow cover set that will look great, last for years, and provide tons of options.
4. Anickal Set of 2 Fall Buffalo Check Plaid Throw Pillow Covers
SPECS:
- Materials: Linen (fabric) / Cotton (filling)
- Washing: Machine-wash on gentle cycle with cold water; dry on low
- Size: Available in 4 sizes
- Color: Available in 11 colors
For a fantastic price, you can get a set of two pillow covers that you’ll over the holidays—and year-round.
Their simple but elegant design will add a touch of festivity to your home as Thanksgiving and Christmas approach, but they’re not too holiday-exclusive. This means that if you really like having them out, you can keep these covers on your throw pillows all year long! With a whopping eleven colors and four sizes available, you can also opt to purchase a couple of sets: one for the holidays and one for the rest of the year. With so many options, there’s something for everyone.
These covers boast a comfortable linen-cotton construction that’s both durable and machine-washable. Whatever you have planned for the holiday season, you can have peace of mind knowing that your new pillow covers will be able to withstand the pressures and hassles of day-to-day holiday happenings.
Each cover has a hidden zipper to keep your living room looking sharp and sophisticated at all times.
If you’re on a tight budget but want quality pillow covers to brighten your holidays, these maybe your best option!
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy It?
Anyone on a budget who wants decorative throw pillow covers they can love all year long.
5. 4TH Emotion Set of 2 Fall Thanksgiving Farmhouse Buffalo Check Plaid Throw Pillow Covers
SPECS:
- Materials: Polyester/Cotton blend
- Washing: Must be handwashed with cold water, without bleach
- Size: Available in 5 sizes
- Color: Available in 6 colors
4TH Emotion hits our list again with its set of two Thanksgiving-oriented pillow covers.
These covers are made with a polyester-cotton material that’s designed to stand up against day-to-day activities during the holiday season. It offers a soft and comforting feel, making it perfect for movie-watching or post-Thanksgiving dinner naps. Speaking of good feelings, this material is also eco-friendly—when you purchase this cover set, you can feel good about your minimal impact on the environment.
These pillow covers also boast the ability to retain their full color even after several washes. Washing by hand is recommended, which may be a hassle for some. But trust us, once you’ve placed these covers in the spotlight and seen the way they enhance your décor, you’ll want to take the very best care of them.
You can order these covers in several colors and styles, so you can find a design that best meets your needs and complements the rest of your holiday-ready home! Their hidden zipper design keeps them looking sharp no matter where you place them.
Now for the X-factor: The pompoms! Each of these pillowcases is lined with a rim of little pom poms that add flair and fun to what would otherwise be just another pillowcase. They’re cute, they’re classy, and they really add depth to any room.
Best of all, these pillow covers are so affordable; it’s quite a deal for the level of style and comfort you get!
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Who Should Buy It?
Anyone who wants pillow covers that make a statement at a price that won’t break the bank.
Conclusion
There you have it: our top five picks for the best buffalo check pillow covers!
Any of the options we outlined will make a wonderful addition to your home for the holiday season. If you’re struggling to make a choice, we recommend that you visit each product’s page and see what others have said about each one.
Everyone has different tastes, needs, and holiday plans. We hope that our list provided you with valuable insight into what’s available on the market today and opened your eyes to the features you should watch for.
In the end, the best pillow cover for you and yours depends on what you’re looking for and what you’re willing to spend. Happy shopping!