Menu

Saatva Mattress is $200 OFF for Mother's Day

Nest vs. Loom & Leaf – Which One is the Best?

Updated October 31, 2019

The advent of memory foam mattresses a few decades ago revolutionized the sleep industry, giving way to a unique firmness level, which has since gained acclaim from all corners of the populace. Consistent R&D efforts by manufacturers have helped rectify several initial problems that plagued these mattresses, such as heat buildups.

Some issues still remain; however, memory foam has established itself as one of the major types of all-foam mattresses.

Today, manufacturers generally follow the practice of designing hybrid products that contain several different layers of foams along with innerspring units, with varying ILD, thickness and coil count, generating maximum comfort.

The Nest vs. Loom & Leaf comparison entails two such manufacturers who have made clever use of memory foam layers within their products, holding on to classic plush response while supplementing it with firmness and superior thermal regulation.

Nest Breakdown

For this comparison, we have selected the Nest Alexander Hybrid Mattress that is a luxury offering at a reasonable price tag. The design of the mattress features different types of foams – each of which downplays the weaknesses of typical memory foam – as well as a pocketed coil system that generates conformity.

Click for price

Construction

Cover

The mattress has its cover made of quilting foam polycotton blended with Thermic Phase Changing fabrics, which is a patented technology that absorbs excess heat from the body and releases it into the atmosphere. The polycotton blend is soft to touch providing a luxury feel to the mattress while the inclusion of Thermic fabrics tackles the issue of heat buildups that otherwise may disturb you as the night progresses.

First Layer

The initial layer of the mattress is 3 inches thick, featuring gel memory foam. The initial impact made by the body is absorbed by this layer, which in turn sinks according to the body’s contours, providing pressure relief through its plushness. The manufacturer has incorporated gel within the layer that keeps heat away from the surface, transferring it into lower layers.

Second Layer

The layer consists of 1 ½ inch of copper-infused Energex Visco foam that was developed as an alternative to viscoelastic foam, characterized by a plush and resistive response. The aim is to prevent the body from sinking too quickly into the mattress, which otherwise would result in an inappropriate feeling of entrapment. Furthermore, the firmness of this layer helps align your sleep posture.  Moreover, as the layer is infused with copper, a conductor, it takes away heat from the surface and transfers it to the layer underneath.

Third Layer

1.5 inches of SmartFlow Support Foam form this layer, acting as a buffer between the softer upper layers and the support core underneath. The SmartFlow technology helps in thermal regulation, dissipating heat away from the mattress.

Fourth Layer

This is the support layer, consisting of an 8-inch Quantum Edge Pocketed Coil system. Firstly, the coil system acts as a resistive layer that prevents the body from getting trapped into the mattress, generating an inner push. Next, the presence of the coil system means that the memory foam’s poor edge support can be tackled effectively. Furthermore, the aerated design means that thermal regulation can be guaranteed at all levels of the mattress.

Firmness and Feel

Comfort and Support

As you lay down on the mattress, you would find yourself slowly sinking into the mattress, with the initial layers taking shape of your body’s curvatures. At the same time, the body will be pushed upwards by the force of the pocketed coil system, not only preventing entrapment but providing pressure relief through firmness. The coil system adds bounce to the mattress, meaning changing positions throughout the night would be effortless, while also ensuring that spinal alignment is preserved.

The mattress is available in two variants, classified according to its firmness; medium and luxury firm. The choice would mostly depend on the amount of weight you carry. For heavier individuals, a luxury firm is recommended, since this would minimize any chances of sinkage to uncomfortable levels while also increasing the longevity of the product. At the same time, it must be noted that the overall response generated by the medium variant is slightly firmer than average memory foam products in the market, due to the presence of Energex foam as well as an innerspring unit.

Edge Support

Edge support is one of the most important parameters of any mattress. Not only does it play a part as you rest on the sides, but also helps you get out of bed easily. Memory foam doesn’t hold the best reputation when it comes to providing edge support, however, Nest’s inclusion of an innerspring system eliminates this problem. Spring coils are excellent at solidifying the mattress’ shape. This means you get to use the entire area of the mattress, without worrying about toppling over the edge.

Cooling

Starting from the cover, all the way to the innerspring unit, all layers incorporate some type of heat dissipating technology. The presence of Thermic phase change materials in the cover rids the body of excessive heat. Moving downwards, the infusion of gel in the memory foam prevents heat buildups. The inclusion of copper in the Energex foam, while the aerated design of the innerspring unit means thermal regulation is kept to a maximum, preventing sweaty episodes during the night.

The average time for a mattress to cool down to room temperature after its heated for 30 minutes is 10 minutes. To put things into perspective, the Alexander Signature took only 6 minutes!

Motion Transfer

Traditional memory foam mattresses are highlighted by their ability to sink according to the body’s shape. This, however, makes it difficult to move around. At the same time, too much bounciness, such as that provided by latex mattresses, results in disturbed sleep partners. The combination of viscoelastic foam and pocketed coil system strikes a balance between mobility and firmness, with the former working to minimize disturbances while the latter prevents over-envelopment.

Unique Features

Thermic Phase Change Cover

The use of Thermic Phase Change in the cover of the mattress keeps heat away from the body, tackling the longstanding issue of poor thermal regulation held by memory foam products.

Plush Conformity

The hybrid design of the mattress means the user gets to enjoy both the plush response of upper memory foam layers as well as the inner push of the support core. The Energex foam layer prevents the body from sinking in too quickly, while the bounce of the innerspring unit means even after contouring, you won’t feel trapped. This makes the product a respectable choice for average sleepers who want plush comfort but at the same time want to avoid the pitfalls of memory foam.

Edge Support

Memory foams are inherently soft, and thereby poor at providing edge support. By incorporating the innerspring unit, the manufacturer is able to ensure that all corners of the mattress are usable, whether it’s for the purpose of sharing the bed or for other activities.

Cooling

Along with the Thermic Phase Change materials, each layer of the mattress has some type of cooling mechanism that allows it to keep the temperature to comfortable levels. This makes the mattress good for sleeping in temperate climates or for people whose sleep is disturbed by episodes of hot sweat flashes.

Lifetime Warranty

The manufacturer’s trust in its product is reiterated by the Lifetime Warranty tag. This should be enough to give you peace of mind and enjoy the mattress’ dual responses without worrying about disintegration or deformation.

Less Expensive with Coupon

By using our $150 coupon, the product can be purchased at a lower price than Loom & Leaf mattress. This gives you the chance to own a hybrid product that gives you both plushness and conformity.

Click for price

Loom & Leaf

The Loom & Leaf is an all-foam mattress, that contains several layers of modified memory foam, to tackle heat retention issues.

Click for price

Construction

Cover

The mattress’ cover is made if pure organic cotton, a that holds inherent softness and breathability. In order to minimize wrinkles, the manufacturer has carefully stretched the cotton over all sides of the mattress, holding all layers together in a tight formation.

To add to the cover’s soft feel, a 5/8” thick quilting along with a natural thistle flame retardant has been added below. The quilting pattern varies from the top to the bottom, being more concentrated in the middle, thus, providing better support to the body’s pressure points.

First Layer

The first layer is composed of 2” of gel-swirl viscoelastic foam, that provides a classic plush response to the body’s contours. The memory foam variant has been embedded with gel particles that help the layer get rid of the greater amount of heat. In addition to this, another panel of the gel has been added specifically to remove heat from the lower back portion of the body.

All these modifications are supplemented by a convoluted design that allows air to pass through the mattress, catalyzing heat dissipation.

Second Layer

This layer is 2.5 inches thick and is composed of typical memory foam, but at a density higher than that of the first layer. The purpose of this layer is to provide greater resistance to the body while at the same time continuing the contouring action. This slows down sinkage at an excessively fast pace, eliminating any discomforting feelings.

Third Layer

2 inches of transition foam forms this layer that acts as a passageway between the plush upper layers and the support core underneath. It considerably slows down the body’s impact, preventing it from directly feeling the firmness of the base layer.

Fourth Layer

Made of high-density polyfoam with a thickness of 5.5 inches, the layer holds the integrity of the mattress and prevents the body from entrapment. Furthermore, it helps conform the body’s posture keeping the spine aligned throughout the night. To aid in heat loss, the layer has been studded with breathable air channels.

Firmness and Feel

The Loom & Leaf is available in two variants, Relaxed Firm, and Firm.

Comfort and Support

Relaxed And Firm

The variant can be seen as equivalent to Medium-Firm in most mattresses and caters for the requirements of the average sleeper. It is immensely popular among the majority of Loom & Lead customers who want a plush memory foam mattress along with a solid support base. The manufacturer hasn’t disclosed the specific ILD ratings of the layers, however, they place it between 5 & 7 on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest.

Firm

This version of the Loom & Leaf targets individuals who are looking for a product that features lower sinkage. The upper layers have a higher ILD rating and thus, contour according to the body’s curvature with greater resistance while the stiffness of the base is also more highlighted. On the manufacturer’s firmness scale, the variant has a rating of 8. This is a mattress more suitable for heavier individuals who wish to enjoy plush comfort.

Edge Support

Unlike the Nest mattress that features an innerspring unit, the Loom & Leaf is an all-foam mattress. This means the mattress features below average edge support. As soon as you move towards the edges, you would find yourself losing balance, ultimately falling off if too much force is exerted. The stiff core does offer some support, but due to the presence of softer upper layers, the effort doesn’t make much of a difference. If you wish to purchase the Loom & Leaf mattress, but at the same time want better edge support, it is recommended you opt for the Firm variant.

Cooling

The Loom & Leaf performs excellently when it comes to heat dissipation since each layer possesses some feature that aids in this. However, compared to Nest, the mattress still holds second place, primarily due to the presence of the naturally aerated innerspring unit in the former. Nonetheless, the mattress performs well compared to other typical memory foam products in the market.

Motion Transfer

While edge support may not be the mattress’ strong suit, it does perform exceptionally well at clamping down unwanted disturbances. The reason behind this is the memory foam’s naturally dead response that ensures that any movements during the night by you or your partner, doesn’t disturb the other person.

Unique Features

Typical Memory Foam Response

The Nest is a hybrid mattress and thus fails to produce the typical memory foam response, often sought out by several individuals. If you’re looking for this classic plush comfort, then opting for Loom & Leaf would be a better choice. Apart from the polyfoam base, all layers within the mattress are made of memory foam, which in conjunction result in a cushioned, contouring response.

100% Pure Cotton Cover

The mattress’ layers are held together by a 100% pure Cotton cover, which provides a luxury feel upon touch. The Nest also has a cover made of cotton, but as it isn’t 100% pure, it lacks the superior feel of Loom & Leaf.

Extended Trial Period

The Loom & Leaf has a 120-day trial period, which is longer than the Nest mattress, enough to let you try out the product and get used to it, before making a logical decision.

Motion Isolation

Unlike Nest, the Loom & Leaf’s support core isn’t bouncy. This means the amount of motion isolation you get isn’t minimized by any inner push. This makes the mattress especially suitable for individuals who have a spasmatic sleep partner.

Zero Offgassing

The Loom & Leaf features no offgassing, something that has been reported from time to time in the Nest Alexander. For those of you who are unaware, offgassing involves the release of organic compounds when a new product is unpacked, which makes it unusable for a couple of hours – days. Since the Loom & Leaf doesn’t possess any such problem, you can use the mattress right away.

Click for price

Which One To Get?

Nest Alexander Hybrid

Click for price

Here are some reasons to consider Nest Alexander Hybrid:

You want an affordable mattress: Our coupon lets you take away the Nest mattress with a $150 discount! This means you get to enjoy a hybrid mattress, with both plushness and conformity at a price lower than that of an all-foam mattress.

You want a hybrid mattress: While some people are happy with a single highlighted response, be it plushness or conformity, there are others who want the feeling of both. The Nest Alexander generates viscoelastic comfort from its upper memory foam layers while the innerspring unit at the base generates an inner push, i.e. conformity. This gives the sleeper the best of both worlds, enjoying contouring without the fear of sinking in too deep.

You want better edge support: While memory foam mattresses aren’t the best at providing edge support, combining them with innerspring units turns this notion around immediately. The innerspring unit found within Nest Alexander keeps the mattress upright and provides valuable edge support as you move towards the sides.

You want a cooler mattress: Starting off with Thermic Phase Change materials, and ending up with aerated innerspring design, the manufacturer has left no stone unturned in tackling memory foam’s heat buildup issues. As a result, you get to sleep on a cooler surface, while enjoying the hybridized response of the mattress.

You want a longer warranty: The mattress’ durable build and superior design are reinforced by its lifetime warranty. In retrospect, the Loom & Leaf offering carries a limited time (15-year) warranty. So, for a lower price, you get a memory foam hybrid product with a lifetime warranty, which is certainly a rare combination.

Loom & Leaf

Click for price

However, you might want to choose Loom & Leaf if:

You want a typical memory foam mattress: If you’re not looking for a hybrid product, and simply want a memory foam mattress that delivers the promised viscoelastic response, then Loom & Leaf is the way to go. The mattress generates the classic plush response, cushioned by the presence of a polyfoam base, providing relief to the body’s pressure points by adjusting according to its curvatures.

You want a 100% Pure Cotton Cover: The touch and feel of pure cotton is extremely soft and luxurious, something Loom & Leaf has been able to preserve for its customers. The cotton cover is tightly stretched over the mattress and the subsequent layers, giving you the chance to enjoy the luxury fabric, without worrying about wrinkles or buildups.

You want a longer trial period: If you’re purchasing a memory foam mattress for the first time, you might want to try it out for a few weeks. This gives your body enough time to get used to the product. The Loom & Leaf mattress holds a 120-day trial period that is sufficient for you to explore the product, after which you can make your decision.

You don’t want any offgassing: The Nest Alexander has faced some negative criticism regarding offgassing concerns. However, the same cannot be said for Loom & Leaf, meaning you get a mattress that is ready for use as soon as you get it.

Nest vs. Loom & Leaf Comparison

Nest Alexander Hybrid
Loom and Leaf
Layers Used
  • Cotton blend cover
  • 2” 4pcf Hypersoft foam and
    stabilizing gel
  • 1.5” 3.5pcf Copper-infused
    Energex foam
  • 1” Lumbar support pad
  • 8” 1300-coil Quantum Edge
    Pocketed Coils
  • 100% organic cotton cover with
    5/8”quilting
  • 2” 4lbs. convoluted memory foam
    with spinal gel panel
  • 2.5” 5lbs. memory foam
  • 2” transition foam
  • 5.5” breathable HD support foam
Height 12.5 inches 12 inches
Firmness Medium, Luxury Firm Medium-Firm, Firm
Motion Transfer Minimal Minimal
Breathability Above average Above average
Trial Period 100-day 120-day
Warranty Lifetime 15-year
Pricing (Queen) $1,199 $1,099
Shipping Free across the US Free across the US


I hope you found the comparison informative and helpful. If so, please don’t forget to share it with others who’re trapped in a similar situation. As always, please leave your comments and questions in the section below.

Quick Compare

Heat retention
9/10
Durability
9/10
Edge support
9/10
Value for Cost
9/10
Motion isolation
8/10
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
100 nights
Type
Hybrid
Organic
No
Crib Mattress
No
Heat retention
9/10
Durability
9/10
Edge support
8/10
Value for Cost
9/10
Motion isolation
8/10
Warranty
15 years
Trial
120 nights
Type
Memory Foam
Organic
No
Crib Mattress
No
View Full Comparison
Our Rating

Read Review

Our Rating

Read Review