Brooklyn Bedding Mattress vs Tuft & Needle Mattress

The ultimate battle of the beds has to be between Brooklyn Bedding Mattress and Tuft & Needle Mattress. The two are designed with different materials, but offer similar support and feel.

Can’t pick between an affordable hybrid mattress and a premium all-foam mattress? Read on as we compare Brooklyn Bedding Mattress vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress. We’ll analyze their similarities and differences in construction, thickness, off-gassing, edge support, shipping warranty, and sleep trial.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress vs. Tuft and Needle Mattress Compared

Brooklyn has six mattress variants, while Tuft and Needle has three kinds of mattresses. But let’s compare their original mattresses, the Brooklyn Signature Mattress and the Tuft and Needle Original Mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Tuft and Needle Mattress
  • Thickness: 11 ½ inches
  • Off-gassing: Low
  • Price Range: $699-$1799
  • Sleep Trial: 120 nights
  • Thickness: 10 inches
  • Off-gassing: Medium
  • Price Range: $895-$1695
  • Sleep Trial: 100 nights

About the Brooklyn Bedding Mattress

The Brooklyn Bedding Mattress is an American-dreamed and American-made company that has been around for over 20 years now. What began as an online store on Amazon became a real retail shop, then got rebranded by naming it after the owner’s daughter, Brooklyn.

Since 2018, Brooklyn has doubled their production capacity. And they are expecting more growth in their company as they plan to build a 600,000-square foot factory.
Brooklyn features six kinds of mattresses: Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid, Bloom Hybrid, Brooklyn Bowery, and Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress is their most affordable mattress that features premium quality materials for a luxurious feel. The bed has 2 inches of TitanFlex polyfoam and 2 inches of Energex polyfoam.

The hybrid mattress provides latex-like responsiveness and a firm transitional layer to relieve pressure points. Although it’s cheap compared to other hybrid mattresses, it still has pocketed coils to stabilize the bed.

About the Tuft and Needle Mattress

Tuft and Needle is the brainchild of two software engineers and 150 workers who wanted to give everyone premium sleep at an affordable cost.

Focused on customer feedback, the brand is known to cater to everyone’s sleeping needs without the need to utilize pushy salespersons and confusing buzzwords in marketing. This is evident in the straightforwardness of three mattresses: Tuff and Needle Original Mattress, Mint Mattress, and Hybrid Mattress.

The popular mattress is a medium-firm bed constructed with polyester and micro polyamide for its top cover. It has a three-inch comfort layer that is high-density and durable, along with a 7-inch polyfoam that provides support and circulation.

Let’s Compare Brooklyn and Tuft & Needle Mattress

There are several factors to take into account before choosing between Brooklyn vs Tuft and Needle. Here’s a thorough comparison of the two mattresses.

— Construction

The Brooklyn Signature Mattress, which is 11.5 inches in thickness, claims to be the original “Best Mattress Ever” because it is made of Ascension coils and hyper-responsive foam at a very affordable price.

The quilted top makes the bed breathable, while the variable foams consist of the 2-inch comfort layer with gel polyfoam called the TitanFlex polyfoam. Its pocketed coils, located in the support core, are 6 inches thick to keep their firmness and provide support to all kinds of sleepers.

What makes the Brooklyn Signature Mattress special is that you can choose its firmness, whether it’s medium-soft, medium-firm, or firm feel. Its construction also allows motion isolation to be effective, especially if you choose the medium-soft and medium firm models.

Tuft and Needle Construction. On the other hand, the Tuft and Needle Original Mattress is a 10-inch medium-firm bed with two layers of foam. It has a cover made of micro polyamide and 3 inches of T&N Adaptive Foam that is durable and high-density. This layer is also engineered to soothe the pressure points with its graphite and cooling gel.

The following layer is a 7-inch polyfoam that stabilizes the whole bed. As the support core, it prevents sagging over time so that sleepers can comfortably sleep for the next years to come. The open-cell construction makes it more cooling because of the air circulation.

The all-foam mattress has motion isolation that is similar to other mattresses. Its medium firmness helps reduce ripples when your partner moves, giving you a more restful sleep.

— Sizes

Both mattresses are available in six standard sizes, although Brooklyn offers custom mattresses where you get to decide the precise dimensions of your mattress.

Despite the differences in materials, both beds have almost the same soft-foam feel, except Brooklyn Signature is just a little bouncier.

— Warranty

Brooklyn Bedding has a 10-year warranty for impressions of 1 inch or more, sagging beds, and defects not produced out of misuse and abuse. These defects include splitting, cracking, and the actual cell structure. The company repairs or replaces your mattress if it qualifies for a warranty.

Make sure that your Brooklyn Signature Mattress is not compressed for over 60 days. Otherwise, you may not qualify for a warranty.

Tuff and Needle has a 10-year limited warranty for US customers. It covers sagging and indentations that are more than ¾ inches deep, splitting foam, and stitching unraveling if they are not due to mishandling. They either repair or replace your mattress.

— Shipping

Both Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle ship for free within the contiguous United States, but Brooklyn only takes 3-4 business days to arrive at your home. The Brooklyn Signature Mattress is compressed, wrapped, and boxed. If you order from Canada, Alaska, or Hawaii, the shipping fee ranges from $125-$250.

Tuft and Needle Shipping. Tuft and Needle take up to a week to deliver your bed via FedEx, but they also offer White Glove Delivery for $150. Your Tuft and Needle Original Mattress is also compressed, wrapped, and boxed. A White Glove Delivery sets up your mattress at home and gets rid of the old one. The shipping fee for Canada, Alaska, and Hawaii is $150-$200.

— Sleep Trial

120 nights are given to Brooklyn Bedding customers for the sleep trial. It encompasses a 30-night break-in period that is required before they can request a return. Aside from returns, the company may suggest fixing the mattress, performing mattress assessment, and exchanging the mattress.

If you pick a more expensive model to replace your Brooklyn Signature Mattress, you have to pay the price difference. But you can also request a full refund during the sleep trial period.
Tuft and Needle customers in the United States get a 100-night sleep trial. If you are not satisfied with your order, the company lets you donate it to charity and gets service providers to remove it from your house for free.

After the donation, you are required to submit the receipt to get a full refund or get a different mattress model. However, the new mattress does not have a sleep trial period anymore.

— Off-Gassing

The Brooklyn Mattress is a clear winner when it comes to off-gassing. It produces a slight odor when you remove it from the box, but it eliminates after a few days. The odor fades more quickly because of the airflow in its coil system.

Tuft and Needle has a stronger odor than Brooklyn because it is your typical all-foam mattress. However, its breathability allows the pungent smell to dissipate within a few days.
The “new mattress smell” can’t be avoided because the volatile organic compounds or VOCs release once you remove them from the box.

— Edge Support

You have three firmness options for your Brooklyn Signature Mattress, and all of them provide better edge support than the Tuft and Needle. Hybrid beds are known to be exceptional in edge support because of the coil system. They provide more stability to the sides of the bed than foam and latex mattresses.

Meanwhile, Tuft and Needle does not have reinforced edges due to its all-foam construction. If you purchase this, it might feel like you are going to fall on the edge of the bed. You may also shrink more, especially if you are heavy or sleeping with a partner.

Who Should Get the Brooklyn Signature Mattress?

The Brooklynn Bedding Signature Mattress is ideal for those who want an affordable yet thick, hybrid mattress. It’s made for couples, heavy sleepers, and those who sleep in different positions because it is the perfect balance of responsiveness and conforming.

Who Should Get the Tuft and Needle Original Mattress?

The Tuft and Needle Mattress is for light sleepers and those who sleep in different positions. But it is the most favorable option for hot sleepers because the mattress provides optimal airflow through its advanced cooling technology.

So, Which Mattress Should You Get?

No mattress is better than the other but if you’re all about premium comfort and versatility, Brooklyn Signature Mattress is the best choice. If you want a traditional all-foam mattress that features better cooling and breathability, Tuff and Needle Original Mattress is the way to go.

We hope this guide has helped you choose a mattress for a good night’s sleep. Got more questions about mattresses? Comment them down!

Mattresses are an investment, so make sure to select one that suits your needs and preferences!