Best Mattress for Couples

by | Mattress | 0 comments

When you sleep alone, you get to spread out all starfish style if you want, or you switch from side to side without anything in your way. However, when you share a bed with your partner, there are rules you both have to follow. There’s often an invisible line down the middle of the bed, and you have to stick to your designated side. It’s worth it, though. You get to share a bed with your loved one.
Sometimes, though, you might miss your single days when you didn’t have your sleep interrupted by someone getting into or out of bed. Plus, there’s the expected compromise when you share a bed. What if you prefer something softer, and your partner likes a firm mattress? There’s a way to find the best mattress for couples, and a compromise might be required.

Best Mattress for Couples Comparisons

MODEL
                    DETAILSWARRANTY
Helix
Mattress
Read My Review
-Type: Hybrid
-Materials: Foam, coils, cotton
-Firmness level: Soft to medium
-Dimensions: 60x80x12 in. (Queen)
-Trial period: 100 nights
-Discount: $50 off with coupon
10 years
Saatva
Mattress
Read My Review
-Type: Hybrid
-Materials: Memory foam, coils, cotton
-Firmness level: Soft to medium
-Dimensions: 60x80x11.5 in. (Queen)
-Trial period: 120 nights
-Discount: None right now
15 years
Amerisleep
Liberty (AS3) Mattress
Read My Review
-Type: Foam
-Firmness: Medium
-Weight: 79 lbs.
-Dimensions: 60x80x12 inches
-Trial period: 100 nights
-Discount: $200 off with coupon
20 years
Layla
Mattress
Read My Review
-Type: Memory foam
-Materials:
-Firmness: Soft, firm
-Dimensions: 80 x 60 x 10 inches (queen)
-Trial period: 120 nights
-Discount: $50 off with coupon
Lifetime
Bear
Mattress
Read My Review
-Type: Memory foam
-Firmness: Soft
-Dimensions: 80 x 60 x 10 inches (queen)
-Trial period: 100 nights
-Discount: $50 off with coupon
10 years
Avocado
Mattress
Read My Review
-Type: Hybrid
-Firmness level: Firm to medium-firm
-Dimensions: 60x80x13 in. (Queen)
-Trial period: 100 days
-Discount: $100 off with coupon
25 years

The Biggest Issues Facing Couples Buying a New Mattress

We all have our preferences when it comes to sleep. Most of us sleep on our sides, but many of us prefer to sleep on our backs or stomachs. There are plenty of issues you’re going to have to figure out when you switch from sleeping alone to sleeping with a partner, but a new mattress won’t help you keep the covers from someone who hogs them. However, a new mattress could help with other common issues couples face when sharing the same bed.

• Support

A mattress works hard to support you as you sleep, but when two people are taking up space, the mattress has to work harder. Many mattresses have an average of, say, a 350-pound weight limit for one sleeper, and then there’s a 500-pound weight limit for two. Why such a discrepancy? Collectively, you two- even with different weights each- are putting more pressure on the mattress than just one of you would.

You won’t necessarily find more support on a memory foam mattress versus an innerspring coil mattress. It comes down to the density of the support core foam or the number of coils. The more weight you two end up putting on your mattress, the more supportive you want it to be.

• Motion Transfer

If you’ve ever been rudely awakened by your partner who’s just climbing out of bed to get a glass of water late at night or just rolling over to find a more comfortable position, you’ve experienced motion transfer. This is something that’s a common problem with bouncy mattresses, like the traditional innerspring coil mattress. As your partner moves on the mattress, that movement travels across the mattress to your body.

One of the best types of mattress to consider if motion transfer is a problem is memory foam. These types of beds absorb that motion and isolate it to that one spot. This means your partner can move freely, and you’re likely to stay asleep. There are other options that also offer motion isolation, including hybrid and latex mattresses.

• Feel

This may be the most difficult part of the process when choosing a new mattress as a couple. The feel of the mattress is how firm or soft it feels to you when you lay down. It’s such a subjective decision, so it can be hard to come to a compromise on the feel of it. The good news is that there are some mattresses out there that are made with adaptive foam which means it can feel soft as you lay down on your bed, but it’s firm underneath, so it’s still comfortable for both of you.

For example, if you’re lighter in weight and require a softer surface, but your partner is heavier and wants a firmer surface, there are mattress options that respond to more pressure, giving you that soft feel on top, but it has firmer surface underneath for those who put more pressure on the bed.
If you two still can’t come to an agreement on mattress feel, you may need to choose a mattress that offers a large bed size with separate components, namely a split queen or split king. This option means you won’t have to compromise. Just choose your side and the mattress can be made soft on one side, firm on the other. There’s one more option: some mattress companies offer the ability to customize your mattress so it’s a blend of what you both want and not a split.

• Sex

It’s important to consider what sex will be like on your new mattress whether you’re newlyweds or been married for years – after all, you don’t just sleep in the bed. A memory foam mattress may be comfortable to sleep on, but you should think about how the mattress responds to your amorous activities. Many people say sex on a memory foam mattress can feel like you’re in quicksand. Latex, hybrid, and innerspring coil mattresses offer better bounce, and therefore, it has better and quicker response.

How to Make Sure You Both Get What You Want

To ensure you and your partner get a mattress that works for both of you, it’s important to discuss priorities, sleeping positions, and preferences. Even edge support is an important factor for some couples – if you sit on the edge of the bed for sexual activities or putting on your socks and shoes in the morning, then you need some support there.

If you prefer to sleep on your back, but your partner is a side sleeper, there’s a chance that you’re looking for a firmer mattress, and your partner needs something softer to not put pressure on his/her hip and shoulder joints. One of the best ways to make sure that you both get what you want is to read the best mattress for couples reviews. You’ll be able to compare mattresses that are great for two people and find the one that suits both of you perfectly.

Top 6 Mattress for Couples Reviews

#1. Helix

Specs

  • Type: Hybrid
  • Materials: Foam, coils, cotton
  • Firmness level: Soft to medium
  • Dimensions: 60x80x12 in. (Queen)
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years
Finding the right mattress that’s comfortable for you and your partner is an easier task when you turn to Helix. This mattress company doesn’t just give you an option for soft, medium, or firm. Rather, Helix has you take a sleep quiz in which you answer a few questions about your preferences and your partner’s preferences. If your answers are similar enough, you’ll get a blended mattress that should work for both of you. If you two have vastly different sleeping styles and preferences, you’re likely to get an option for a dual comfort mattress which lets you have your most comfortable side, and your partner gets their preferred comfort, too.

This mattress is the very definition of “hybrid.” You’ll get a mattress with three layers, including a polyfoam base that provides lots of support, a layer of pocketed micro coils which gives you more support and bounce, and finally a dynamic foam top layer which provides the softness and comfort you want. It has a fast response time, and it keeps the heat at bay, unlike most memory foam mattresses. Because the Helix mattress is created especially for each sleeper, it’s hard to comment on edge support and firmness, as they’re all going to be different. Generally, though, it’s safe to say that this is a comfortable mattress that’s a good happy medium for two sleepers with different preferences. There is a chance of getting a mattress that’s a bit too firm or too soft for one partner, though.

R

Pros

  • Blended and dual options
  • Comfortable for two sleepers
  • Little to no motion transfer
  • Supportive
Q

Cons

  • May be too soft or too firm
  • Cover can bunch up

If you’re looking for two separate mattresses in one for you and your partner, this one may be the best choice – whether you go with blended or dual comfort.

#2. Saatva

Specs

  • Type: Hybrid
  • Materials: Memory foam, coils, cotton
  • Firmness level: Soft to medium
  • Dimensions: 60x80x11.5 in. (Queen)
  • Trial period: 120 nights
  • Warranty: 15 years
When it comes to choosing a mattress for two people, you might think that a traditional innerspring coil mattress shouldn’t even be considered, but then there’s Saatva. Not all innerspring coil mattresses are created equally, and Saatva did what it could to combat common issues with spring mattresses, such as motion transfer. By isolating each spring and making it a pocketed coil system, you still get support and bounce, but movements aren’t registered as obviously otherwise.

You and your partner will have to come to an agreement on whether you’ll choose plush soft, luxury firm, or firm, though. The luxury firm is the most common choice because it strikes that compromise between soft and firm that most couples are looking for, but it may still be too soft for some sleepers. Most innerspring coil mattresses have excellent edge support, and the same is true for Saatva. The support base of steel coils is strong enough to support up to 600 pounds of combined weight from you and your partner, so it should work for most couples. Perhaps the only issue with the Saatva is that it can trap heat a bit, so you might find it’s a bit too warm when you sleep.

R

Pros

  • Excellent edge support
  • Little to no motion transfer
  • Comfortable for most sleepers
  • Good bounce
  • Good durability
Q

Cons

  • Might be too soft
  • Could sleep hot for some

If you’re looking for a comfortable mattress that has motion isolation and still provides good bounce, this could be an ideal mattress for you and your partner.

#3. Amerisleep Liberty (AS3)

Specs

  • Type: Foam
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Weight: 79 lbs.
  • Dimensions: 60x80x12 inches
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 20 years
If you and your partner aren’t sure about buying a memory foam mattress because you’re worried about environmental issues, the Amerisleep Liberty (that’s its former name, now its AS3) might be something to consider. While it is memory foam, the mattress is created in the eco-friendliest way possible. It’s considered a medium firmness, but many users have reported it’s a bit firmer than that. Of course, most memory foam mattresses have a breaking-in period, but side sleepers may not find this mattress comfortable at all.

Because this mattress is made with an eco-friendly process, there’s no off-gassing, so you won’t have to worry about airing it out for days before you can sleep on it. As with most foam mattresses, the motion transfer is almost nonexistent. You could easily do your own test with a bowling ball and a glass of wine and be impressed. However, this also means that you’re going to get that memory foam hugging feel, and this mattress does retain heat.

R

Pros

  • No off-gassing
  • Eco-friendly
  • Higher response than memory foam
  • Little to no motion transfer
Q

Cons

  • Retains heat
  • May not be suitable for side sleepers

If memory foam is what you and your partner agreed on for a new mattress, this Amerisleep could be a good choice for you two.

#4. Layla

Specs

  • Type: Memory foam
  • Firmness: Soft, firm
  • Dimensions: 80 x 60 x 10 inches (queen)
  • Trial period: 120 nights
  • Warranty: Lifetime
If you’re having a hard time coming to a compromise on a new mattress with your partner, you two might want to take a look at Layla. This mattress is made up of three levels of foam. The base is firm, copper-infused memory foam. That’s topped by a middle-convoluted layer of foam which provides airflow on one side. And then the soft top is also a copper-infused memory foam, but it’s much softer in feel. The unique aspect of this bed is that you can flip it. If you prefer a softer bed, go with that side up or you can go with the firmer side which is more comfortable for back and stomach sleepers. With that said, it still may be too firm for some sleepers.

Some people can’t stand to sleep on mattresses that retain heat, and if that’s the case for you and your partner, you may want to sacrifice a bit of softness for the firm side and its ability to cool off faster. That’s why this mattress is made with infused copper in the foam layers – it’s meant to help keep you cool as you sleep. And still, some have said it’s a bit too warm regardless of which side is chosen. Foams are known for having a slight chemical smell to it, but the Layla hardly has any off-gassing at all.

R

Pros

  • Supportive
  • Comfortable for most
  • Offers two firmness levels
  • Little to no off-gassing
Q

Cons

  • Could be too firm
  • Sleeps hot

If you’re looking to try ‘soft’, then to ‘firm’ and back again if you want, you and your partner may want to consider a Layla mattress.

#5. Bear

Specs

  • Type: Memory foam
  • Firmness: Soft
  • Dimensions: 80 x 60 x 10 inches (queen)
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years
Bear creates a memory foam mattress that could be considered a hybrid to some when you take into account the quick-response foam that it also incorporates. The benefit of that quick-response foam is that it provides enough bounce and buoyancy that allows you to switch positions or get out of bed without too much effort. The base layer is thick and offers a decent amount of density as long as you and your partner don’t weigh too much. The weight capacity of this mattress is about 500 pounds, combined. If yours and your partner’s weight total more than that, this mattress may not have enough support for you.

When it comes to comfort, Bear has managed to strike a good balance between soft and firm to please most couples who don’t always agree on firmness levels. What sets the Bear mattress apart from others that are similar could be the cover which is infused with Celliant fiber. What it does, essentially, is help convert body heat into infrared energy. Why is this important? It’s believed that it helps regulate body temperature and improves blood circulation, which then helps deliver oxygen to all parts your body. It should help alleviate aches and pains as well.

R

Pros

  • Good motion isolation
  • Comfortable in most sleep positions
  • Good firmness levels for couples
  • Includes a Celliant fiber-infused cover
Q

Cons

  • May not be suitable for heavier people
  • Sleeps a bit hot

If you and your partner like the feeling of memory foam, but you don’t want that stuck-in-quicksand feeling that often comes with it, then this could be the mattress for you two.

#6. Avocado

Specs

  • Type: Hybrid
  • Firmness level: Firm to medium-firm
  • Dimensions: 60x80x13 in. (Queen)
  • Trial period: 100 days
  • Warranty: 25 years
Avocado mattress combines latex layers with an innerspring layer and then tops it with a wool pillow top if you like. This combination of supportive layers makes it comfortable to sleep on for most people so it should be a good option for a couple that can’t quite agree on a mattress. Innerspring coil mattresses often get a bad rap for making it impossible to sleep through a partner who’s keen on switching positions at night, but this coil system is different. The individual coils are pocketed, which means you get more stability and support. The motion isolation is comparable to memory foam mattresses.

One of the biggest differences between the Avocado mattress and others like it is the way it handles comfort and support. When you lay on the mattress, you should notice that the shoulder and hip areas are much softer, while the area where your lower back would be is a bit firmer. This allows people with multiple sleeping positions to be comfortable, no matter what. The only downside is that this is a firm mattress, and it could be too firm for your liking. Plus, the mattress is dotted by buttons, which could become bothersome if you feel it through your sheets. Otherwise, this is a responsive and supportive mattress, and it includes handles – most competitors of Avocado don’t – which makes it much easier to rotate your mattress.

R

Pros

  • Supportive
  • Comfortable in most sleeping positions
  • Eco-friendly
  • Responsive
  • Motion isolating
  • Has handles
Q

Cons

  • You might be bothered by buttons
  • Could be too firm

If you and your partner are looking for a firmer option in natural materials, the Avocado mattress could be a great choice for you.

The Bottom Line

Although each one of these mattresses reviewed here could be an excellent choice for any couple, there is one in particular that seems as though it was made with couples in mind. The Helix is a really great choice because it ensures that you get a blended mattress with both your and your partner’s comfort in mind, or it gives up on compromise and gives you both what you want with its dual comfort option. But the Amerisleep is also a great choice because of its long-standing reputation and eco-friendly features. Bottom line, there’s no one perfect mattress for couples because every couple is different. So check out all the options and choose what’s suitable for you!

To support our work we earn a commission if you purchase through some of the links listed below at no additional cost to you. We may also review products we’ve received for free. This does not influence our opinions, but we believe in transparency so you can make informed choices. Read more here.