Best Innerspring Mattress Reviews

by | Innerspring, Mattress | 0 comments

Most of us have an idea of what an innerspring mattress is, and this is largely because it’s been on the market for a long time, predating both memory foam and latex. While foam-based mattresses have taken the industry by storm, there is still a large group of the population that appreciates the bounce and cooling properties innerspring products feature.

If it’s been awhile since you’ve used an innerspring product, you may be surprised at the innovations that have been applied as they have effectively reduced issues common to innerspring products like motion transfer. If you’re considering the purchase of an innerspring product, let’s take a moment to understand the benefits of this popular mattress component and help you decide if it could be a good fit for you. We’ll even take a look at some of the best innerspring mattress brands on the market that we’ve hand-tested.

5 Best Innerspring Mattress Comparisons

PillowsDetailsWarranty

Saatva Mattress
Review
Trial Period: 120 Nights
Layers:
Euro Pillow Top Cover
Thin Layer of High Quality Memory Foam
Individually-wrapped Coils
Steel Coil Base
15 Years

My Green Mattress
Review
Trial Period: 100 Nights
Layers:
All-Natural Wool Cover
3 inches Natural Dunlop Latex
8 inch Pocketed Coil Base
10 Year Limited

Voila Mattress
Review
Trial Period: 100 Nights
Layers:
Stretch Polyester Cover
¾ inches Gel Memory Foam
1 ¾ inches Gel Memory Foam
¾ inch Talalay Latex
2 ¼ inches Edge Support Foam
¼ inch Support Foam
Fiber Insulator Pad
6 ¼ inches Pocketed Coils
6 ¼ inches Edge Support Foam
Fiber Insulator Pad
1 inch Support Base Foam
½ inch Base Foam
10 Year Limited

Helix Mattress
Review
Trial Period: 100 Nights
Layers:
2-4 inches Proprietary Helix Dynamic Foam
2-4 inches Pocketed Microcoils
2-4 inch Poly Memory Foam Base
10 Year Limited

AvocadoMattress
Review
Weight:
lbs.Twin- 59 lbs.
Full- 82 lbs.
Queen- 97 lbs.
King- 123 lbs.
California King- 122
Layers:
.5-1 oz/sqft New Zealand Joma® Wool
4 inches Natural Dunlop Latex, eco-INSTITUT certified
8 inch 3 zone pocketed coil system
25 Year Limited

What is an Innerspring Mattress?

Innerspring units use metal spring coils with high densities in order to offer consumers both support and pressure relief. It’s common to find an encasement foam or pillow top placed both on top and/or around the innerspring layer to increase comfort and minimize poking that can occur when upper layers begin to degrade over time.

Benefits of Innerspring Mattresses

Before we continue and discuss in more detail the different type of coils and springs available on the modern market, let’s review some of the top benefits of innerspring mattresses so you can get a better idea of whether or not it will be a good fit for your needs:

  • Many Options- Quality innerspring mattresses are offered as a result of many years of innovation. Over the course of many decades, mattress companies have learned what their customers like when it comes to firmness, feel, and support. As a result, there is a wide variety of options to choose from.
  • Accommodating for most budgets- Whether you’re on a budget of $300 or $3,000, you can find an innerspring product to accommodate. In most cases, you get what you pay for, so be weary of products that are really inexpensive. Most likely, the coil gauges are very thin, and the mattress won’t last as long as you hope.
  • Great bounce- If you have trouble getting in and out of bed or moving around, innerspring products are well-known for their high degree of bounce.
  • Low off gassing- Since there are limited foams used in innerspring products, you can expect a lower VOC output.
  • Good temperature control- Foams are more likely to retain body heat while innerspring and pocketed coil mattresses promote breathability.

How to Read Gauges

If you’ve shopped foams, you may have encountered terms like density and indentation load deflection. However, the number you need to understand how to interpret when shopping innerspring is going to be the gauge. This will help you get an idea of the firmness of the mattress. It can be a little bit confusing, however, because a higher number indicates a thinner spring. This means the mattress will be less firm. The thicker the gauge, the lower the gauge number and firmer the mattress.

Coil Count

Support and comfort are two of the most important factors in a comfortable mattress, so it’s critical that you understand how to examine coil count and density. The smaller the coil count, the fewer areas of the body that will come into contact. This can prove beneficial for those who suffer with aches and pains. However, those with higher coil counts offer more when it comes to contouring, bounce, and uniform firmness.

In general, Bonnel, continuous, and offset coils are larger than pocketed coils. Because of this, pocketed coils often feature a higher coil count. In a queen-sized product, a coil count of 800 is one that should stand the test of time. As you shop, the following chart features the bare minimum coil count. Any lower likely means a decline in durability:

  • Full- 300
  • Queen- 400
  • King- 480

Other Important Specs to Check

Aside from the gauge and coil count, there are a few other things you need to look for as you compare the best innerspring mattresses. These include:

  • Type of coil used
  • Whether or not the coils are connected to one another

A Look at the Types of Spring and Coils

There are four primary types of coils you’ll come across as you shop, and it’s important that you understand what they are. Let’s conduct a quick mattress coil comparison to help you make an educated purchasing choice.

Bonnell coils have been around the longest, and they feature an hourglass shape that compresses and expands in response to pressure application. The coils are each placed in rows, and they are then connected through helical lacing with spiral wire.

When it comes to shopping Bonnell coils, it can be tricky. Since they are inexpensive to produce, there’s often a cost savings for the end consumer. Make sure you check wire gauges and coil counts to ensure you can expect durability.

Pocketed coils are just what the name implies: coils wrapped in thin fabric. Without having to use wire, the coils are connected to tie the unit together. Since each coil is wrapped independently, you can typically expect a higher degree of motion isolation and more contouring support than you would experience with Bonnell coils.


A lot like Bonnel coils, offset coils are shaped like the letter “D” and lack the rounded top. This construction works to reduce the space between coils.

Using a single piece of wire, continuous coil mattresses are constructed by turning the coil into itself. Since the coil does continue, this means there is only one used. This often increases motion transfer and can prove to be a poor choice for sleep partners. Continuous coil mattresses are often inexpensive but use materials of poor quality.

Benefits of Hybrid Innerspring Products

If you’re torn between the features and benefits of foams and innerspring, you can find a viable compromise in hybrid innerspring products. Using a strategic variety of materials, these products are often able to complement each other in ways that eliminate common problems and offer a higher degree of comfort and support.

For example, memory foam combined with an innerspring unit can decrease motion transfer often found in the innerspring while increasing breathability that’s often lacking in memory foam. It’s a symbiotic relationship within your mattress that can offer consumers a number of distinct benefits.

Hybrid innersprings also work to increase comfort and body contouring. Due to their higher quality, you’ll typically find pocketed coils in hybrid products.

Is an Innerspring Mattress Right for Me?

While there is a lot of talk about the latest foam and latex products, many overlook the fact that top rated innerspring mattresses have addressed some of the most common downsides to accommodate customers. When you find the right one, you can expect a product that offers the support, durability, and comfort you’re looking for in a sleep product. I’d recommend an innerspring mattress to anyone who:

  • Enjoys the traditional feel of a bed that’s highly responsive and offers a good degree of bounce
  • Wants a mattress that helps the body stay cool to enjoy the deeper, more restorative stages of sleep
  • Wants the flexibility to explore products that offer the bounce of springs with the comfort of foams and latexes available in hybrid products

Top Rated Innerspring Mattresses

Now that you have a better idea of how to examine and understand innerspring products on the market, let’s take a look at some of our top picks of some of the top-rated innerspring mattresses using the online business model. We’ve hand-tested each of these products to help you decide which would work best for your unique needs.

1. Saatva- Best Innerspring for Stomach Sleepers

Specs

  • Warranty: 15 Years
  • Trial Period: 120 Nights
  • Layers: 
    Euro Pillow Top Cover
    Thin Layer of High Quality Memory Foam
    Individually-wrapped Coils
    Steel Coil Base

Innerspring sleep products are known to help make it easy to move around in bed, and they’re also ideal in offering the level of support necessary for stomach sleepers. On the other hand, they are also known for low motion isolation. When you choose the Saatva mattress, you receive a product that features individually-pocketed coils that provide bounce while keeping motion transfer low.

Saatva allows consumers the choice of three firmness options: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. I would suggest the firm option for stomach sleepers. If you have a low BMI, however, you may have better luck with the luxury firm option.

R

Pros

  • Good durability expectations
  • Excellent value for the cost
  • Easy to move around to find the best sleeping position
Q

Cons

  • Some complaints of sleeping hot

2. My Green Mattress- Best Innerspring for Side Sleepers

Specs

  • Warranty: 10 Year Limited
  • Trial Period: 100 Nights
  • Layers: 

    All-Natural Wool Cover
    3 inches Natural Dunlop Latex
    8 inch Pocketed Coil Base

If you sleep primarily on your side, I’d like to draw your attention to the benefits of My Green Mattress. This is a natural product that uses a combination of all-natural wool and Dunlop latex that can help those with dermatological problems and allergies.

The innerspring unit in My Green Mattress consists of individually-wrapped coils, and the coil gauges are placed in strategic zones to help the mattress conform well for side sleepers. In the middle of the product where there’s usually less pressure applied, the firmess is a little higher. This product also demonstrated good motion isolation making it a great one to consider if you a side sleeper with a sleep partner.

R

Pros

  • Low off gassing
  • Easy to move around with innerspring unit
  • Offers good support for those who carry more weight
  • Reasonable price for quality of materials
Q

Cons

  • Some reports of the product being too firm

3. Voila- Best Innerspring Hybrid Mattress for Back Sleepers

Specs

  • Warranty: 10 Year Limited
  • Trial Period: 100 Nights
  • Layers: 

    Stretch Polyester Cover, ¾  inches Gel Memory, Foam, 1 ¾ inches Gel Memory Foam, ¾ inch Talalay Latex, 2 ¼ inches Edge Support Foam, ¼ inch Support Foam, Fiber Insulator Pad, 6 ¼ inches Pocketed Coils, 6 ¼ inches Edge Support Foam, Fiber Insulator Pad, 1 inch Support Base Foam, ½ inch Base Foam

The Voila mattress is an excellent example of a hybrid sleep product in that it features the use of seven different material types all within the same mattress. These materials work to complement one another to provide a product more on the firm end of the spectrum that can be very accommodating for back sleepers.

The use of pocketed coils in the deeper layers of the mattress act to provide bounce and support to a mattress that features memory foam in the comfort layers. This helps reduce the sinking that’s typical in traditional memory foam. Consumers can also benefit from the fact that the coils implement five zoned coil technology to increase support and keep you properly aligned.

R

Pros

  • Good price for quality of materials used
  • Firmness accommodations available if you’re not initially satisfied
  • Great motion isolation
  • Good edge support
  • Quick response makes it easy to move around and get in and out of bed
Q

Cons

  • Some feel the product is too firm
  • Some complaints of sleeping hot

4. Helix- Best Innerspring Mattress for Back Pain

Specs

  • Warranty: 10 Year Limited
  • Trial Period: 100 Nights
  • Layers: 

    2-4 inches Proprietary Helix Dynamic Foam
    2-4 inches Pocketed Microcoils
    2-4 inch Poly Memory Foam Base

Helix is yet another hybrid innerspring mattress option that has a lot to offer those who suffer with back pain. Playing on the strengths and weaknesses of various material types within this product, sleepers can enjoy the compensation offered in the necessary weak areas of the different layers.

The Helix mattress uses a combination of memory foam and pocketed microcoils that work to offer a great combination of support and comfort. When you order, you take a sleep quiz that customizes a unique firmness for your needs. One of the factors considered is aches and pains, and the needs of your sleep partner are considered in their blended and dual product options.

R

Pros

  • Helps reduce back pain
  • Low off gassing
  • Accommodating for sleep partners
  • Customizable firmness
Q

Cons

  • Cover is thin and prone to bunching

5. Avocado- Best Organic Innerspring Mattress

Specs

  • Warranty: 10 Year Limited, Pro-rated
  • Weight: Twin- 59 lbs., Full- 82 lbs., Queen- 97 lbs., King- 123 lbs., California King- 122
  • Layers: 

    ½ inch Joma® New Zealand Wool
    4 inches Natural Dunlop Latex, eco-INSTITUT certified
    8 inch 3 zone pocketed coil system

One of the downsides of innerspring products is that they can begin to poke and prod the sleeper over time. The Avocado mattress utilizes a three zone pocketed coil system. Since the coils float independently of one another, motion transfer is effectively reduced, and the development of problems with one coil will not negatively impact the entire mattress as is frequently encountered with continuous coil units.

Avocado uses 16 gauge wire manufactured using recycled steel. It uses far more than the recommended 800 coils. Its 1,068 coils help ensure durability and support. You can also rest assured in the fact that it combines the use of ½ inch of 100% natural Joma® New Zealand Wool and 4 inches of 100 percent natural Dunlop latex, making it an organic innerspring mattress well worth considering.

R

Pros

  • Durable cover that’s aesthetically-pleasing
  • Side handles make it easy to move the mattress
  • Pressure points in your back are minimized by zoning
  • Great combination of bounce and motion isolation
Q

Cons

  • Sleepers with low BMIs may find the product too firm

To support our work we earn a commission if you purchase through some of the links listed below at no additional cost to you. We may also review products we’ve received for free. This does not influence our opinions, but we believe in transparency so you can make informed choices. Read more here.